吉大吴彦祖 2023-06-11

Already rejected, reason: We receive a much larger number of papers than we are able to accept. The number of submissions is particularly high, and the rejection rate is particularly high. We advise everyone to avoid this pitfall and not submit anymore.

吉大吴彦祖 2023-06-11

Brother, how are you doing now?

nature and science 2023-06-07

Is it considered a long time for the status of "Required Reviews Complete" to remain for 20 days in Neurocomputing's second review?

ww_1122 2023-06-06

If you don't submit during the submission stage, which one should you choose?

吉大吴彦祖 2023-06-05

At the beginning, it is not necessary. During the submission stage, there are options to choose from. If the journal requires data, they can apply for it from you.

ww_1122 2023-06-05

Do we need to provide the original code for submission?

吉大吴彦祖 2023-06-05

6.1 Submission, number 3000+
6.5 Status with editor

花～夢慶 2023-06-04

The submission is in the field of SLU (spoken language understanding). The review process is a bit slow, and although I felt that it might be rejected, I didn't expect the reason for rejection to be like this... (My advisor said that my paper was actually okay, but there are probably better articles in the same field, and that's it).

The timeline is roughly as follows:
2023.03.10 submitted to neurocomputing
2023.03.13 with editor
2023.03.15 editor invited (I have to say, I chose the right editor as their efficiency in reviewing is really high)
2023.04.07 under reviews
~~~ (two months later)
2023.06.03 reject ("We receive a much larger number of papers than we are able to accept.")

Keep going, be brave in learning and don't fear difficulties!

komm 2023-06-02

The journal speed is slow and the requirements are high.

xyk 2023-05-28

Is this submission for a double-column or single-column layout? Why didn't I see any requirements?

Xi Yi 2023-05-18

4-20 submit
4-25 with editor
No progress until now

mmmmmy 2023-05-18

What is the situation now?

让我如期顺利毕业吧 2023-05-15

What journal are you switching to, my friend?

23224 2023-05-13

Translation: It has been nearly 5 months since I submitted a special issue on "Vision Transformers and Graph-based Models for Human Activity Understanding" to neurocomputing, but I still haven't received any results. Does anyone know why?

哈哈 2023-05-04

The speed of reviewing is still acceptable.

哈哈 2023-05-04

The speed of reviewing is quite good.

努力划水毕业 2023-05-04

I have never rushed the manuscript. Both of my reviewers reviewed it after two months.

nature and science 2023-05-04

Excuse me, have you followed up on the manuscript? I submitted the revised draft on March 25th, and so far there are still two reviewers who haven't provided their feedback. It's too slow.

努力划水毕业 2023-05-04

For reference only!
Submitted to journal on November 10, 2022.
With editor in November 2022.
Under review in November 2022.
Revised and reconsidered on January 5, 2023.
Submitted again on February 5, 2023.
Under review in April 2023.
Under review in April 2023.
Required reviews completed on April 27, 2023.
Decision in process on April 27, 2023.
Accepted on April 30, 2023.

nature and science 2023-04-25

Hello, may I ask if you have reminded the second review of the manuscript? It seems like a long time.

CharlotteYYY 2023-04-25

4-9 submitted to journal
4-12 with editor
4-25 with editor

Is "with editor" too long?

感性男子 2023-04-23

Hello, how long did you wait for the second review comments?

等待 2023-04-23

Never encountered such a problem.

kaka 2023-04-22

The status after the first round of revisions and submission is "with editor". After 5 days, it changes to "editor invited". What does this situation mean? Do we still need to change the editor for the second round of review? Experts, have you encountered this situation in the second round of review?

娇娇123 2023-04-20

I want to ask if there is a possibility to convert "with editor" to DIP. Is it highly likely that it's not going to work out?

Moka加冰 2023-04-18

Hello, I would like to ask, it has been 2 weeks since I submitted it, but it has been in the editor's hands and hasn't been reviewed yet. Have you ever encountered this situation?

PG_CSL 2023-04-18

May I ask, is it normal for the Editor status to last for more than 10 days? Should I remind them?

upupup++ 2023-04-15

The text translates to: "The first-instance decision is in process for 12 days. What does this mean? I see that everyone's DIP (decision in principle) is coming out quickly. Did they get arbitrated?"

努力毕业的风痕 2023-04-14

I have been waiting for over two months for my second review. There is a reviewer who accepted the review but did not actually review it. ?

ZXXXX0305 2023-04-12

This is also a bit inexplicably disappointing...