PPAccepted 2022-01-11

Reply to hs8945, in the meeting, please wait patiently~ Although this journal is slow, it rarely rejects submissions.

didilala 2022-01-11

2021.1.11 submitted
2021.3.30 major revision
2021.4.26 major revision resubmitted
2021.12.12 under review
2022.1.10 review completed
2011.1.11 accepted
A whole year

hs8945 2022-01-09

What is the result of the 10-month period? Did you win?

PPAccepted 2022-01-09

Reply to hs8945, I also submitted an article last year, and it took 9-10 months for the first review... so it feels normal.

hs8945 2022-01-07

I submitted my contribution a month earlier than you, and it is still under review in the first round. I don't know how to evaluate it now. I have been following up every month, but there are still no updates.

PPAccepted 2022-01-06

Update the timeline a bit, hoping to provide some help for those who are confused:
2021.6.29 Submit
2021.6.30 Editor Assigned
2021.7.16 Under Review
2021.8.9 Reviews Completed
2021.8.13 Reviews Completed
2021.8.14 Reviews Completed
2021.8.16 Major Revision

2021.9.10 Resubmit
2021.9.13 Editor Assigned
2021.11.24 Under Review
2021.12.4 Reviews Completed
2021.12.21 Reviews Completed
2021.12.24 Reviews Completed
2021.1.3 Accept

The research field is very niche, and there aren't many options to submit. I hope that all the papers I submit in the future will go smoothly, with good luck and great success!

chaos and fractals 2022-01-06

March 8, 2021 - Submission
May 28, 2021 - Major Revision
June 13, 2021 - Revised
During this period - editor assigned
November 30, 2021 - Under Review
December 9, 2021 - Reviews Completed
December 28, 2021 - Reviews Completed
December 29, 2021 - Minor Revision (accepted after minor revisions via email)
January 6, 2022 - Just started revisions, hahaha
The first review took 3 months, and the second review took one month, which is actually quite fast. However, waiting for the editor assigned took almost 6 months. Since it has been submitted, let's wait patiently. I wish everyone and myself good luck. Effort will bring rewards.

didilala 2022-01-06

How to check the estimated time on the official website?

felix@ 2022-01-05

What is the current status of the original poster? Is it usually known within about a month after the second review under review?

SwanKnight 2022-01-04

21 December 23rd, reviews completed - skipped once
21 December 28th, reviews completed - skipped once
22 January 4th, Accept

When I saw the acceptance message, I wanted to cry.
From submission to acceptance, it took 11 months, which is about the expected time given on the official website.
Although the first reviewer's comments were numerous and harsh, fortunately, they gave me a chance for major revisions.

Overall, the speed was a bit slow, but it was suitable for someone like me who was a beginner a year ago.
I wish everyone's manuscripts to be accepted soon!

PPAccepted 2022-01-04

Almost exactly 6 months, finally Accepted. Although it feels like 6 months is relatively fast, about 5 months of that time was spent on "Editor Assigned" and "Reviews Completed", which was extremely confusing. Thanks to MTAP for letting me know that the most frustrating period is not "Under Review". Anyway, grateful and thankful, it's still a good outcome!

ハローキティ 2021-12-24

Do I still need to submit for a third review after submitting minor revisions? It has been one month since the editor was assigned. Should I remind them about it since it's Christmas?

PPAccepted 2021-12-24

The time you calculated for reviewing is incorrect. It has only been 3 days since your second review until today! The processing time should not be included!

Xi-Zeyu 2021-12-23

Does the second trial take so long?

Xi-Zeyu 2021-12-23

May I ask how many days it will take for the second review of this journal to yield results?

SwanKnight 2021-12-22

In the top left corner of the submission interface, there is a "contact us" option. If you are using Windows, click on it to directly switch to the email submission interface.
editorialoffice.MTAP@springernature.com is the email address for the editorial office.
bfurht@fau.edu is the email address for the journal editor.
To find the specific responsible editor for a particular direction, you will need to do your own research.

SwanKnight 2021-12-22

Finally, it was sent for review on Christmas Eve QAQ. Everyone has been through a lot.

Xi-Zeyu 2021-12-21

How to inquire about the progress of the review?

Hinton 2021-12-21

Really despair...
20200801 submitted
20210510 major revision
20210607 revision submitted
20210809 editor assigned
20211221 under review
It has been 7 months for the first review, 1 month for major revision, and 6 months for the second review. I admit that when I submitted, I thought this journal was relatively good. But this time has really made me despair. I have sent reminders at least 10 times, from one reminder per month to two reminders per month. I can only advise those who are considering submitting to be mentally prepared... I no longer have any expectations for this outcome. Let's write another article...

Berlinzzz 2021-12-21

August 5, 2020, submitted
February 16, 2021, major revision (3 review comments)
March 15, 2021, resubmitted after major revision
Until now, editor assigned
I guess I won't even live long enough to wait for the acceptance result.

科研小青年嘿嘿 2021-12-19

Second review said there is a lack of reviewers??? This reason seems a bit far-fetched. I advise everyone not to submit to this journal for now. My revised manuscript has been submitted for 10 months and still has not been assigned.

科研小青年嘿嘿 2021-12-19

Second review said there is a lack of reviewers??? This reason seems a bit far-fetched. I advise everyone not to submit to this journal recently. I have submitted my revised manuscript for 10 months, and it has not been assigned yet.

ハローキティ 2021-12-17

It has been a month since Xiaoxiu submitted, but there has been no progress. Should we continue to submit for review, it's unbelievably slow.

SwanKnight 2021-12-17

December 3rd, the second reminder for submission.
December 8th, the editorial department replied that there is a shortage of sufficient reviewers, so it is slow...

算哪个小饼干 2021-12-15

Excuse me, is this journal currently on the CSCI warning list? How can I check if this journal has been warned?

didilala 2021-12-15

How many reviewers are there in the second review?

willfor 2021-12-14

2021-05-10 15:49 submitted
2021-08-16 19:04 major revision
2021-09-12 04:14:25 revision submitted
2021-09-13 09:15:56 Editor Assigned
2021-11-24 18:30:06 Under Review
2021-12-11 05:14:02 Reviews Completed
2021-12-13 18:57:45 Reviews Completed
2021-12-14 05:06:56 Accept

Translation:

2021-05-10 15:49 submitted
2021-08-16 19:04 major revision
2021-09-12 04:14:25 revision submitted
2021-09-13 09:15:56 Editor Assigned
2021-11-24 18:30:06 Under Review
2021-12-11 05:14:02 Reviews Completed
2021-12-13 18:57:45 Reviews Completed
2021-12-14 05:06:56 Accept

hs8945 2021-12-12

Alas, it's so true. The first trial has been almost 7 months now, and there have been no changes at all.

ハローキティ 2021-12-12

人为刀俎，我为鱼肉，无奈。

PPAccepted 2021-12-12

A little confused, I noticed on the official website that several recent papers were submitted in June 2021 and have already been accepted. Why are some people so quick? What is the reason behind this?