vivo 2022-09-29

It has been 20 days since the required reviews were completed. I don't know what's going on. Does anyone understand?

KYJX 2022-09-26

2022.06.08 submit
2022.06.28 with editor
2022.06.29 Editor's feedback on modifications, images, formatting, etc.
2022.07.04 resubmit
2022.07.04 with editor
2022.07.05 under review
2022.08.01 revise The reviewer's speed of review is decent.
2022.08.24 Received reviewer's comments, with editor
2022.08.25 under review The second review is taking a bit long, perhaps the reviewer has some personal matters.
2022.09.26 accept

艾静 2022-09-22

This is the second submission, it has been in the hands of the editor for almost a month, sent for review for 2 months, and received after one week of revision.

Rock you 2022-09-21

May I ask if the original poster has any updates? I have been reviewing for one month and 20 days and still haven't received any results. It's so slow.

vivo 2022-09-19

It has been 8 days already, and there has been no movement, which is causing delays.

vivo 2022-09-19

It has been 8 days, what's the situation?

胖胖哒点 2022-09-16

Hello, if there are unconfirmed co-authors, does it slow down the review process?

vivo 2022-09-16

It has been five days already, why is it so slow?

卷若天朝 2022-09-14

Updated
2022-06-14 submitted to journal;
2022-06-28 with editor;
2022-06-28 under review
2022-08-08 revise
2022-08-28 revision submitted to journal (with editor)
2022-09-14 accepted

BigWaterMan 2022-09-12

2021.12.1 Submission
2022.08.1 First review
2022.08.19 Submission
2022.09.01 Second review
2022.09.07 Submission
2022.09.12 Acceptance

During this period, I sent two reminders. The editor mentioned it was difficult to find reviewers. On August 1st, I received four review comments. Reviewer #1 gave a direct positive evaluation, while reviewer #2 asked some detailed questions. Reviewers #3 and #4 provided some suggestions for improvement in the writing, pointing out that it lacked sufficient detail. After receiving the review comments, the processing speed improved significantly.

vivo 2022-09-03

It has been 50 days already, why is it still under review? Wasn't it supposed to be fast?

卷若天朝 2022-08-29

Updated on 2022-06-14 and submitted to the journal;
2022-06-28 with the editor;
2022-06-28 under review
2022-08-08 revise
2022-08-28 revision submitted to the journal (with editor)

科研人科研魂丶 2022-08-23

The speed is quite fast, and the efficiency is high!

yunyunname 2022-08-19

How long did it take to review?

michaelgaoy 2022-08-11

Excuse me, has the person upstairs contacted the author for confirmation?

michaelgaoy 2022-08-11

May I ask if the author must click confirm in order to proceed with the editor?

hanchunyu 2022-08-09

How long will it take to prove?

YDZ1119 2022-08-08

Excuse me, has the status of "required reviews completed" changed? What is the result? I have been in this state for one month already.

卷若天朝 2022-08-08

Updated on 2022-06-14, submitted to journal;
2022-06-28, with editor;
2022-06-28, under review;
2022-08-08, revise.

xiemei 2022-08-06

It has been half a month in the editor's hands and still no news.

Posctat 2022-07-23

March submission, June revision, July publication, finally published, it was not easy at all...

ComeGaby 2022-07-17

Other authors have not clicked to confirm, and the editor has already been assigned. 7.11 with editor, please submit for review.

Alex_aldrin 2022-07-15

No need for confirmation, I have submitted two articles. One was submitted on May 31st and accepted on July 11th. The other one was submitted on July 13th and is currently under review. The previous editing process takes at least 7 days to start, so it is still being divided among the editors.

卷若天朝 2022-07-11

Hello, MD requires confirmation from co-authors. After submission, an email will be sent to each author, and co-authors must register an account (if they don't have one) and log in to confirm.

Hebecicilee 2022-07-11

43 days since submission, still in "with editor" status. I'm really fed up. I don't want to submit to this journal again.

ComeGaby 2022-07-10

Excuse me, does everyone have to click "confirm" to agree?

ComeGaby 2022-07-10

May I ask, "Do all authors of this magazine need to confirm their agreement?" Other Elsevier magazines do not require it, right?

卷若天朝 2022-06-29

Updated on 2022-06-14 Submitted to Journal;
2022-06-28 With Editor;
2022-06-28 Under Review

Hebecicilee 2022-06-27

Didn't pay much attention to this, eh.

edcee30000 2022-06-26

Excuse me, after you submitted your contribution, did all the authors click to confirm registration?