独行侠 2023-02-22

It was not easy. After three and a half months of experiences, it was finally accepted. Let me share the timeline with everyone.

November 6, 2022: Submitted
November 8: With editor
November 12: Under review

There were many updates during the middle period, and the editor's handling was quite fast. However, the reviewers may have been a bit slow.

January 17, 2023: Major revision. There were three reviewers and they gave 42 days for revision. Unfortunately, it coincided with the Lunar New Year, which caused a delay of half a month. It was not possible to make up for the experiments.

February 15, 2023: Returned, and on the same day, with editor.
February 22: Accepted.

笙歌十里 2023-02-21

The disease diagnosis you submitted is a spectrum classification.

笙歌十里 2023-02-21

What is the status of your paper now?

独行侠 2023-01-17

I didn't rush, on the 8th it showed "required reviews completed", so I went to ask the boss and coincidentally received two review comments. Then I waited, on the 15th it showed "2+", and then I received an email this morning.

哇，是黑黑呀 2023-01-14

[Independent Traveler] I reminded the editor, and on January 11th, it was under review again. Did yours come back? If not, I also suggest you remind them. It's been such a long time without any results, so it's probably an issue with a specific reviewer.

Nanotechnology 2023-01-12

Has there been any progress from the original poster? I have been assigned with an editor since the 3rd, but there haven't been any changes so far.

Joyce_chem 2023-01-10

Translation:

Submission number 1, submission number 2 has become "with editor" and has remained in that status until now. I'm wondering how long it will take for it to be rejected or for it to change to "under review".

哇，是黑黑呀 2023-01-09

【Science Research Novice】Thank you~ I understand now.
【Lone Ranger】I plan to send an email today to remind them. Their vacation should be over by now, but the review process is a bit slow...

独行侠 2023-01-09

May I ask how long your "required reviews completed" status has been lasting?

科研小白兔 2023-01-07

There is an email in the communication mailbox that provides you with a link to check the progress.

独行侠 2023-01-06

Hey, I also submitted it for review on the same day, and it's still under review until now. The boss hasn't mentioned anything about urging it, but the editor updates the timeline every few days. However, the status remains unchanged.

哇，是黑黑呀 2023-01-06

November 12th, Under Review. It has been almost two months now and there has been no change. I want to send a reminder letter. Do you think it is necessary for those who have already submitted? Also, how can I find out how many reviewers are currently reviewing my article?

独行侠 2022-12-27

Hello, how can I check how many reviewers have replied?

gogolin 2022-12-23

Submitted on October 12th, reviewed on October 31st, and still no news. Previously, according to the paper tracking service, I saw only one reviewer's comments and couldn't find any other reviewers. Now, the paper tracking service shows that my paper cannot be found. Should I send a reminder letter?

moumou south 2022-12-16

One of the top journals in analytical chemistry, it requires a certain level of innovation, reasonable experiments, detailed data, rigorous arguments, and clear logic. An article in ACA greatly benefits the improvement of scientific literacy for master's and doctoral students.

勇敢牛牛 2022-12-13

I guess I'll probably be rejected too.

yerengege 2022-12-13

"直接被编辑拒了！" translates to "Rejected directly by the editor!" in English.

勇敢牛牛 2022-12-12

May I ask, what is the result now?

笙歌十里 2022-11-21

Excuse me, is there a brief "decision in process" in your status?

yerengege 2022-11-21

The direction of my research is in the field of spectral disease diagnosis. Initially, I submitted to Biosensors and Bioelectronics, but it was rejected after two weeks with a suggestion to submit to Talanta. Then I submitted to Analytical Chemistry, but it was rejected within a week, indicating that the quality was not sufficient. After that, I submitted to ACA on the 15th, and it is currently with the editor. Today, the status changed to "Decision in Process," which most likely means it will be rejected.

shishi 2022-11-19

Wishing your heart's desires come true~

笙歌十里 2022-11-18

Shishi, my opinion has come back. The required review is complete, but there are no results yet. Please bless it.

shishi 2022-11-18

No, but the latest status update in the system has been refreshed. The status is still under review. How about yours?

笙歌十里 2022-11-18

Shishi, have you received your results yet?

shishi 2022-11-16

With this thought, it seems like my heart feels much better.

笙歌十里 2022-11-16

No news, forget it, let's consider it as if the paper has never been submitted.

shishi 2022-11-16

Did you receive any news yet?

ningningya 2022-11-12

Same question, are the reviewers still the same after re-submission?

ningningya 2022-11-12

May I ask if the reviewer after resubmission is still the same as before?

笙歌十里 2022-11-11

Shishi, no reply, sigh, this journal is really slow, sigh.