yl45 2021-10-27

10.26. reject

yl45 2021-10-27

2021.10.11 submitted
2021.1012. under consideration
2021.10.17 under consideration
2021.10.25 under consideration
2021.10.17 reject

Translation:
2021.10.11 - Submitted
2021.1012. - Under consideration
2021.10.17 - Under consideration
2021.10.25 - Under consideration
2021.10.17 - Reject

观天澜 2021-10-19

Why are you so fast, it's so frustrating~~

观天澜 2021-10-19

Why are you so fast, so frustrating~

墨离殇 2021-10-18

It has been one and a half months and it is still under consideration.
9.13-9.18
9.24-10.7
10.7-10.18
It has been under consideration all along.

Holly 2021-10-15

9.27 submitted
9.28 under consideration
10.10 under consideration
Some people say that this journal is slow, but there are also fast ones. I hope mine can be fast too, so it can catch up with next year's funding application.

Holly 2021-10-15

You are so fast, which editor are you?

泽铭sama 2021-10-12

7.28 submission
8.20 minor revision
9.10 return
10.8 minor revision
10.11 acceptance
Overall, the initial review was relatively fast, but the review process after the revision was relatively slow. The editors are quite meticulous. The second round of minor revision was requested by the editor to change the title, and it took three days before it was accepted. This is my first article as a master's student. Thank you so much and I wish all the best for everyone to reach the top in the second district!

观天澜 2021-10-11

Stuck in the editor's hands for two months, still under consideration. Gave it a nudge and they said it's in high demand. Damn, then a few days ago there was some movement in the timeline, maybe it's under review now. How can this journal be like this? The neighboring research group submitted in 2018 and got published within a month.

绝云椒椒 2021-10-06

Recently, is the review process very slow? It has been in the hands of the editor for two months. I have reminded them twice but there has been no change in the status. My mindset is about to collapse.

绝云椒椒 2021-09-26

This journal does not have a "send e-mail" option, so I directly sent an email using the "contact us" feature.

观天澜 2021-09-26

Brother, how do I contact the editor? The Journal of Materials Science does not have a "send email" button for me to click.

DREAMCHASER 2021-09-25

The situation I encountered is the same as yours. It is now the third review, and it has been over a month without any news.

DREAMCHASER 2021-09-25

The situation I encountered is the same as yours. Now it is the third review, and it has been over a month with no news.

绝云椒椒 2021-09-25

The article has been with the editor for over a month now. I just reminded them to speed up the process, and they said they would initiate the review procedure. However, it has been two days and there hasn't been any progress. Can I remind them again to speed up the process?

月下干饭人 2021-09-24

It has been almost two months since the third review. I have reminded them in between and they told me that the review is still ongoing and they haven't given any feedback yet. It's already the third review! Could it mean that it's going to be rejected? Has anyone else encountered this situation? It wasn't this slow before when I submitted previously!

FRANCISAA 2021-09-22

Come to fulfill the vow.
Submitted on April 5, 2021.
Under consideration as of April 15, 2021.
Major revision on July 5, 2021 - Reviewer #1 is more friendly, Reviewer #2 is stricter, with a 40-day revision period.
Revision submission on August 17, 2021.
Under consideration as of August 25, 2021.
Accepted on September 10, 2021.
Visible online on September 17, 2021.

哒哒123 2021-09-06

Hello, I would like to ask how did you resolve it in the end? I have encountered the same problem.

哒哒123 2021-09-06

Hello, may I ask how did you finally solve it? I'm facing the same issue.

Saudadeeeee 2021-08-24

I received the proof after nearly 20 days of receiving it, and then waited another week for the online version.

观天澜 2021-08-22

Are you also majoring in wood materials, brother? Is this journal easy to get published in?

你好呀科研者 2021-08-19

Hello classmate, I would like to ask, after I received it, the editing department asked me to supplement supporting materials, and then today they asked me to sign the copyright agreement. I haven't received the proof yet. How long does it usually take for you to receive it?

你好呀科研者 2021-08-19

Hello classmate, I want to ask, after receiving it, the editorial department asked me to supplement supporting materials. After that, they had me sign the copyright agreement today. I haven't received the proof yet. How long does it usually take for you to receive both of these?

mechanicsaaa 2021-08-18

The proportion of domestic submissions is too high.

聃 2021-08-11

Submitted on May 10th, returned on July 7th after minor revisions, accepted on July 30th, and published online on August 10th. Overall, it was quite fast!

XCY 2021-08-05

2021.01.26 Submission
2021.03.30 Only one reviewer, took two months to say it is not suitable for this journal, editor gave an opportunity for resubmission
2021.04.27 Resubmitted after revision
2021.06.10 Minor revisions from two reviewers, editor requested major revisions
2021.06.29 Revised and resubmitted
2021.08.05 Accepted
It took half a year, but the result is still good~

LYW7506 2021-07-23

Do friends who have already received it know how long it takes to receive the proof?

LYW7506 2021-07-23

My speed is a bit slow, but the editors and reviewers are still very serious. I hope to return to Zone 2 soon.

辣鸡小邓博 2021-07-08

Addendum: Proof on May 28, 2021, online on May 30, 2021. Overall efficiency is still acceptable, hoping to return to the 2nd zone of the Chinese Academy of Sciences soon.

lkjc;vlkpcj 2021-07-07

Made a mistake, it's supposed to be received on the 6th of March, but until now, on the 7th of July, I still haven't received the proof.