Holly 2021-12-24

Supplement: 9.27 submission

Holly 2021-12-24

May I ask how long it will take for you to repair and give the message back?

Holly 2021-12-24

11.10 major revision
12.17 resubmission
12.21 Under Consideration
According to online comments, after a major and minor revision, the submission was ultimately rejected. I hope to be treated kindly and receive good news!

蛆蛆 2021-12-24

Excuse me, if I am not the corresponding author, where can I check the progress?

academic worker 2021-12-24

Has anyone ever encountered a situation where the status of a job application on JMS changed from "under consideration" (with the date changing several times) to "under review" and then back to "under consideration"? What does this mean?

academic worker 2021-12-24

Can I ask if there is a situation where the status changes from "under consideration" to "under review" and then back to "under consideration"? What does this mean?

carpenter 2021-12-24

The speed is extremely slow. How can such a poor journal be in Zone 3? It feels more suitable for Zone 4.

琪11111 2021-12-14

Change to a different journal, come down from the second-tier, there shouldn't be any problem. I submitted for five months and finally they told me they couldn't find a reviewer. How amazing!

琪11111 2021-12-14

You are not considered unfortunate, I have been waiting for five months. In the end, they told me they couldn't find a reviewer and rejected me. Interesting, isn't it?

我不想学计算机 2021-12-13

Hello, has your consideration been changing consistently over the past three months?

我不想学计算机 2021-12-13

2021/12/1 submit
2021/12/3 under consideration
2021/12/5 under consideration
2021/12/7 under consideration
Still waiting
This paper has been rejected many times. Let's take it easy. Good luck to all research friends!

ZH竟然 2021-12-13

9.18 submission
12.06 No response from the editor, replied that I did not receive the reviewer's comments
12.13 Suggested submitting to another journal, it's been nearly three months and it hasn't been reviewed. This journal is so unprofessional. It's a waste of three months, so frustrating.

Cry_stals 2021-12-10

10 days later, proof.

Cry_stals 2021-11-30

After 2 months of submission, minor revisions will be returned. After the revisions are made, it will take approximately 1 month to receive feedback. In total, it will take 3 months.

西北扛把子 2021-11-24

Have you finished your proof?

同玉 2021-11-22

It has been two months and there is still no response, it's really annoying.

dadmm 2021-11-21

The article review was indeed quick, but could you please give me some rejection feedback?

观天澜 2021-11-20

This bird journal is quite easy to publish in, with a large number of articles being published. The neighboring research group manages to publish within a month without doing much. In order to graduate quickly, you should submit to open-access journals, and gradually submit to higher-quality journals.

观天澜 2021-11-20

After being rejected by the Journal of Materials Science, I did not bother to read the comments on this journal. The journal editors are actually exhausted, as there is a huge volume of submissions, and the reviewers are slow in reviewing. Therefore, it is a graduation strategy to submit to open-access journals and other slow but good journals.

同玉 2021-11-08

Mine too. I guess the reviewer took too long, the process is also too long. Still waiting to graduate.

琪11111 2021-11-07

The reviewer is really nagging, I have reminded them twice already.

琪11111 2021-11-07

Share the same illness, always unable to reject or return the manuscript.

琪11111 2021-11-06

I have been waiting for four months, hahaha, and still haven't received any feedback. It's not the journal's fault, they are very efficient in replying to my inquiries. The problem lies with the quality of my own work, which is garbage, or it could be due to the procrastination of the reviewers.

烧陶瓷专家 2021-11-04

This journal is quite good, and the review process is also fast.
20210906 Submission
20211005 Major revision (three reviewers, very meticulous, can tell that they are professional)
20211019 Revisions requested
20211025 Minor revision
20211104 Accepted
I hope the magazine continues to improve and prosper.

观天澜 2021-11-04

Also, the whole process is still under consideration. Consider your mother, consider, consider.

观天澜 2021-11-04

In the hands of the editor for two months, I sent an email to urge them and they said the review was delayed due to COVID-19. Shortly after, it was reviewed for a month, with a minor revision and another modification (uncertain about the extent). In the end, it was rejected. I can't believe it, it's harmful. Even in the third district, they are still so arrogant.

Holly 2021-11-04

My current status is still under consideration.

小刘要发paper 2021-11-02

Submitted on September 6th, it arrived at the editor's desk on the third day. The following dates have been changing continuously. On October 21st, there were revision suggestions, which were minor adjustments. On October 29th, it was sent back for revisions and returned on the third day with revised illustrations. On November 2nd, it was accepted. Overall, the speed was very fast.

DREAMCHASER 2021-11-01

May I ask how long it took for everyone to receive the proof after acceptance? I have been waiting for over a month and still haven't received any updates.

李万里 2021-10-30

Does this journal charge page fees? Are there any already accepted papers? Please let me know.