灰色灰 2023-05-08

Is the proofreading done now?

已投被接收 2023-05-06

The initial long period of unknown status, I thought it was under review, several months later it was under review, and one month later it underwent major revisions. After the revisions were completed, it took twenty days to receive the final version. Fifty days later, it went through proofreading. In summary, the normal process was not considered slow, but the strange status in the initial phase lasted for four months, causing a significant delay in time.

已投被接收 2023-05-04

To talk about the follow-up
Submitted in August 2022
Proof on April 30, 2023
Online on May 3rd

半斤橙子 2023-04-23

The first repair took me a relatively long time. In total, it took 3 months.

半斤橙子 2023-04-23

1/21 Submission
Editor assigned/invited
2/4 Under review
2/6 Under review
2/11 Under review
2/25 Review completed
2/28 Major revision
3/29 Revision submitted
3/30 Editor invited
3/30 Editor assigned
4/4 Minor revision
4/6 Revision submitted
4/7 Editor invited
4/20 Accepted

纽哈 2023-04-21

Why is this journal so slow?

已投被接收 2023-04-16

Friends, how long does it take for this journal to send the proof? It has been forty days since it was accepted in March, and I haven't received any communication yet.

细雨yy 2023-04-05

How long does it typically take for you to receive feedback on completed reviews?

纽哈 2023-03-24

Just write casually, for example, you can find data in this article, there is generally no additional information.

Sevin 2023-03-20

Is your present being reviewed or not?

Sevin 2023-03-20

Hello, I would like to ask how to fill in your Supplementary information and Data and code availability.

纽哈 2023-03-17

2023.3.17 Editor Assigned
2023.3.24 Editor Invited

Translated into English:
2023.3.17 Editor Assigned
2023.3.24 Editor Invited

纽哈 2023-03-14

2023.14 submissions sent back to author. Format change declaration 1.

纽哈 2023-03-14

2023.14 Submissions Sent Back to Author Format Improvement Disclosure

纽哈 2023-03-14

2023.3.13 new submitted. - Submitted on March 13, 2023.
2023.3.17 Editor Assigned - Editor assigned on March 17, 2023.
2023.3.24 Editor Invited - Editor invited on March 24, 2023.
2021.3.24 Editor Assigned - Editor assigned on March 24, 2021. (Note: There might be a typo in the year)
2023.5.1 Reviewers Assigned - Reviewers assigned on May 1, 2023.
2023.5.2 Reviewers Assigned - Reviewers assigned on May 2, 2023.
2023.5.3 Under Review - Under review since May 3, 2023.
2023.5.8 Under Review - Under review since May 8, 2023.
2023.5.11 Reviews completed - Reviews completed on May 11, 2023.
2023.5.15 major revision - Major revision required on May 15, 2023.
2023.6.7 Revision Submitted - Revision submitted on June 7, 2023.
2023.6.8 Editor Invited - Editor invited on June 8, 2023.
2023.6.8 Editor Assigned - Editor assigned on June 8, 2023.
2023.6.9 Under Review - Under review since June 9, 2023.
2023.6.11 Under Review - Under review since June 11, 2023.
2023.6.14 Reviews completed - Reviews completed on June 14, 2023.
2023.6.24 Minor Revision - Minor revision required on June 24, 2023.
2023.6.26 Editor Assigned - Editor assigned on June 26, 2023.
2023.7.2 Accept - Accepted on July 2, 2023.

xiezhiqi 2023-03-09

This journal is slow, mainly because the reviewers are slow. The editors are okay, but the cycle takes four months!!

初心8886 2023-03-03

Be cautious when investing, as the speed is slow.

依稀一梦中 2023-03-01

Why does it take so long for "under review"? Are they still finding reviewers?

HSCY 2023-02-27

2022.9.13 Submitted
2022.9.14 Under Consideration
2022.9.18 Under Consideration
2022.9.24 Under Consideration
2022.10.26 Under Review
2022.12.8 Under Review
2023.1.11 Major Revision (1 reviewer)
2023.1.17 Revision Submitted
2023.1.17 Editor Invited
2023.2.1 Reviewers Assigned
2023.2.26 Under Review
2023.2.27 Accept

Jack要努力 2023-02-27

Is it still in this state now?

cheng xie 2023-02-22

2023.02.07 Submission
2023.02.09 Editor assigned
2023.02.14 Editor invited
2023.02.18 Editor declined invitation
2023.02.18 Editor invited
2023.02.21 Editor assigned

HSCY 2023-02-13

2023.2.1 Revisores Asignados

2023.2.1 Reviewers Assigned

依稀一梦中 2023-02-04

Has the status of your submission changed? How long did it take to invite the editor for this stage?

依稀一梦中 2023-02-04

I am also in the process of editor invitation now, it has been ten days and still no news.

宁静的夜晚 2023-01-26

2022.9.13 Submitted
2022.9.14 Under Consideration
2022.9.18 Under Consideration
2022.9.24 Under Consideration
2022.10.26 Under Review
2022.12.8 Under Review
2023.1.11 Major revision (1 reviewer)
2023.1.17 Revision Submitted
2023.1.17 Editor invited
It has been ten days and it is still "Editor invited."

xiezhiqi 2023-01-16

Approximately 20 days or so.

冯老师炸了 2023-01-13

The reviewing process was slightly slow, and the expert opinions were relatively simple. After about a month of revisions, it was finally accepted. Overall, it was acceptable. This journal has dropped from Zone 2, which is disappointing. Hopefully, it can return to Zone 2 soon. Also, I would like to ask how long it usually takes to receive an online notification after acceptance. Experienced peers, please kindly provide information.

小菜青虫 2023-01-07

Isn't it in zone 3?

Beyond yourself 2023-01-03

Those who exceed the normal review time can give it a try, but it is not recommended to urge for other circumstances.

Beyond yourself 2023-01-03

Supplement:
11 August 2022 under consideration
30 August 2022 under consideration
12 September 2022 under consideration
26 September 2022 under consideration
18 October 2022 reviewers assigned
31 October 2022 major revision
17 November 2022 major revision submitted and editor invited
22 November 2022 reviewers assigned
23 November 2022 accept
29 November 2022 accept publishing agreement
3 December 2022 proof
6 December 2022 proof submitted
9 December 2022 online