奥利给！ 2023-04-04

We are about the same, recently don't understand why it is generally slow.

奥利给！ 2023-04-04

Submit the card, pray for good luck, research content is inorganic materials combined with biological materials.
Submitted on March 30th, 20 minutes with editor.
Changed date with editor on April 2nd.
With editor on April 3rd.

Kush 2023-04-04

@麋鹿 My life has nothing to do with biology.

HAO 2023-04-03

Check in for the record, hoping for good luck.
Submitted on March 30th, with editor on the same day.
Currently, it is April 3rd, still with editor, and the date has not changed.

孤独幽紫 2023-04-03

3.24 submission
3.25 with editor
4.3 with editor
Is it rejected? /????

麋鹿 2023-03-30

Based on everyone's feedback, the field of biomaterials does indeed progress relatively slowly. The time with the editor is longer, and the dates are subject to changes.

hubugeorgeczy 2023-03-29

It has been a few days with the editor, I estimate that it's difficult to find a reviewer again. If we can't find one in a few days, I will transfer it to you.

alwaysever 2023-03-23

2.3 Submission
2.23 Major revision
3.20 Revision
3.24 Acceptance

deepblueccc 2023-03-23

1.26 Submit
2.10 Major renovation
3.10 Submit revised manuscript
3.23 Received~
The journal's speed is super fast. Wishing everyone a smooth submission. Finally, I can graduate. So happy!

Kush 2023-03-23

@Su Xiaogang, I hope to share some good luck with my brothers.

始终 2023-03-21

2022.11.17 Submission
2023.1.25 Feedback received
3.6 Repair submitted
3.21 Accepted
4 reviewers plus editorial comments

北城以北 2023-03-20

1.25 with editor - Under review with the editor
1.31 under review - Under review
2.10 required reviews completed - Required reviews completed
2.14 minor revision - Minor revision
3.11 with editor - Under review with the editor
3.19 accepted - Accepted

The acceptance was received in less than two months. The speed is good, but the majority of the time was spent on revisions for which I am thankful for Professor Wang's approval.

hydrate-111 2023-03-19

Received an email today, and the editing speed was still very fast. It took less than 2 months from submission to acceptance.

苏晓岗 2023-03-18

Submitted on the evening of the 17th, it was reviewed and approved on the 18th.

Kush 2023-03-17

Mar 14, 2023 - Submitted to journal
Mar 14, 2023 - With editor a few minutes later
Mar 17 - Still no movement, not sure if the editor is not very optimistic, so the speed is slower
Mar 23 - Still no movement
Mar 31, 2023 - Finally sent for review
Apr 2, 2023 - One reviewer returned comments
The other reviewers seem to have not accepted, so the editor found new ones again, the specific time was not recorded, probably around mid-April
May 2 - RRC (no clear meaning given)

hydrate-111 2023-03-17

Hey guys, I want to ask, is it normal to still be "with editor" after one week of returning the revised manuscript?

辉铜 2023-03-11

Reply "始终": Only communication can send emails for repairs, other authors cannot receive.

始终 2023-03-08

Will all authors receive an email when the revised manuscript is submitted?

辉铜 2023-03-08

2.7 with editor
2.9 under review
2.11 RRC
2.13 RRC
2.14 major revision (Three reviewers provided detailed feedback, only requiring an additional representation of light absorption)
2.19 revisions requested
2.28 required reviews completed
3.2 minor revision (Editor mentioned that I didn't include an error in a table and the error bars in a figure were not clear)
3.2 with editor
3.8 accept
It's really fast. Another junior colleague submitted and received RRC within 48 hours, but hasn't received feedback yet. Maybe they will seek a third reviewer due to the quick review process?

h,j 2023-03-05

It has been over two weeks with the editor, and then dip, I estimate it's gone.

Ruanyiru 2023-03-03

2023.1.21 Submission (Early morning of the first day of the Chinese New Year)
2023.2.7 Received reviewer's comments (Need to conduct two additional experiments)
2023.2.26 Revised submission
2023.3.2 Article accepted
Overall, everything went smoothly. The journal's processing speed was fast, and the editor was responsible. The reviewer's comments were all reasonable and very good.

咩小力 2023-02-28

Already received, the second review took a week in total. I would refresh the track link every day, afraid that the reviewer would not review it and it would be too late to change reviewers and graduate this year. Actually, the reviewer is just busy and doesn't have time to review the revised manuscript. In the past two days, the status showed that two reviewers finished reviewing the manuscript and provided feedback on the same day, so I guessed that it was accepted. Sure enough, when I opened the submission system at night, I saw "Accept". I also wish everyone good luck and hope that all papers will be accepted!

small biao 2023-02-27

20221228 under review (change of date) track shows that the reviewer who accepted the invitation completed the review on the 13th.
20230103 under review (change of date) track shows that a new reviewer accepted the invitation.
...
Then, it remained in the same status until today (February 27th).
During this period, a reminder was sent once and received a very positive response, but there has been no change.

咩小力 2023-02-26

First review with two reviewers, supplemented with experimental revisions, and about 3 days later, it was under review. And then, there was no further update. It has been almost a week now, and the link for that track shows that both reviewers have not accepted the review yet. I am really anxious because I'm afraid I won't graduate this year. For those who have submitted or reviewed papers, do you know how long the journal typically gives reviewers to complete their review or how long it takes for them to send a reminder?

浅夏初凉 2023-02-26

Posted in early December, it took about a week to submit for review.
Received a reminder in January, and another one in February. Until now, the submission status is still stuck at December 6th. I'm so frustrated, and I still haven't received any feedback from the review.

凡尘. 2023-02-21

It should be possible to consider switching.

小魔女 2023-02-21

What is the result of lz? I also encountered the same situation, I haven't submitted it for review yet, directly DIP.

BCN没完了 2023-02-18

2023.02.13 Submitted
2023.02.13 With Editor
2023.02.18 Under Review
2023.02.26 Under Review
2023.03.01 Required Reviews Completed
2023.03.02 Minor Revision

Translation:

2023.02.13 Submitted
2023.02.13 With Editor
2023.02.18 Under Review
2023.02.26 Under Review
2023.03.01 Required Reviews Completed
2023.03.02 Minor Revision

大空 2023-02-16

1.16 revised with editor
1.22 under review
2.14 accepted
After more than 5 months of experiencing, fortunately, it was finally accepted. Good things come to those who wait. Thank you to the editor and reviewers.

margot 2023-02-10

Two reviewers. Let's add up to ten questions.