Dl113 2021-08-06

Most likely, it will be rejected.

App 2021-08-05

Is the speed so slow now?
7.28, Submit
7.29, With editor
The status hasn't been updated yet...

资源勘查 2021-08-05

May I ask those who have experience in submitting papers to the Journal of Cleaner Production: if two days after submission it says "With editor," and one day later it goes to "decision in process" without being sent for review, does it mean the paper will be rejected? How many days does it usually take to receive a rejection decision?

Dr. Simon 2021-08-04

The entire submission process takes about 100 days, and the editor-in-chief is responsible for the review process. The following are the specific date changes for reference:

4.20 WE
4.23 UR
4.27 UR
5.28 DIP
5.29 Major revise
6.16 Revise
6.16 WE
6.18 UR
7.30 Sent a reminder letter
7.31 DIP
8.1 Accept

lazylu 2021-08-04

Me! Major revisions, 4 reviewers, revised and resubmitted, 2 agreed to accept it, gave minor revisions, revised and resubmitted, only sent to 2 reviewers, revised again, damn it's still minor! Both reviewers agreed to accept it, one of them said my hypothesis needs further language improvement, and then went through the review process again!! It's still under review now! Submitted the manuscript in early April last year...

简单 2021-08-04

How do you find the time for each stage, everyone?

Dl113 2021-08-03

The speed is really slow, so be cautious about submitting. Especially for students who are about to graduate.

So far, the review process has already reached the third round. The R2 was submitted in early July, and the editor started making a decision on July 20th, but there are still no results at the moment.

The whole cycle has been close to 4-5 months already.

I don't know if there will be an R3.

苟延残喘 2021-08-03

Ah, I've been warned again this year?

zhanhaolin 2021-08-02

Now it's District 1, but this year it has been warned because of self-citation issues.

红色小瓶子 2021-07-29

May I ask if this journal charges publication fees starting from 2021? Is it included in the Chinese Academy of Sciences (CAS) Zone 1?

TrRick 2021-07-27

2021-07-14 min - July 14, 2021, minute
2021-07-15 sub - July 15, 2021, substitute
2021-07-16 wit edi - July 16, 2021, with editing
2021-07-25 accept - July 25, 2021, accept
Celebrate the ending!

zhanhaolin 2021-07-22

Three days after submission, they requested the tex source file. After another day, they said it did not meet the scope of the journal and asked me to carefully review the scope. They summarized in two sentences why it did not meet the requirements. I am curious as to why this cannot be determined by just looking at the PDF file. Now that I have sent the tex source file, I am unsure if there are any risks involved.

钟承昊 2021-07-21

I am also very anxious... After the external review is completed, I will update the status... and then submit it for external review again.

xusita1 2021-07-20

Directly without review, the decision is definitely going to be rejected. Why are you still waiting?

QCD 2021-07-20

My submission for 6.21, the decision in processes for 7.14, has been a month and still hasn't been reviewed.

钟承昊 2021-07-19

External audit for three months, still under review, quite anxious.

jjccccc 2021-07-18

Posted on July 7th, after 11 days under review, the speed is still acceptable.

zasphalt 2021-07-17

The first review took three months, with five reviewers. One rejected, one required major revisions, but the rest of the feedback was quite good. As a result, it was recommended to submit to a subsidiary journal under the same publisher... feeling exhausted...

Sunny-Meng 2021-07-15

May I ask about the current situation of the original poster? My situation is the same as yours now.

592993578 2021-07-14

I have been WITH EDITOR for 12 days too, I want to remind them.

jjccccc 2021-07-13

Does this mean that I will also be finished soon? I submitted my manuscript on July 7th at noon.

Moneymore 2021-07-13

I also submitted my draft on July 7th, it was with the editor on the 8th, with the editor on the 12th, and on the morning of the 13th, it changed to "under review".

小顺子 2021-07-13

6.29 until now with editor

TrRick 2021-07-13

Continue
2021-06-30 min
2021-07-03 sub
2021-07-03 wit edi
2021-07-09 und rev
The current result is unknown. Elsevier's online chat told me that only one reviewer has been assigned, and the reviewer has accepted the invitation. I didn't expect that there would be a third round of review after minor revisions. I hope everything goes smoothly. Please bless me.

小小青椒~ 2021-07-13

Still with editor on June 24th.

jjccccc 2021-07-12

The manuscript submitted on July 7th is currently still with the editor.

环境工程 2021-07-12

The results will be available soon.

lazylu 2021-07-04

7 months for major repairs, just in time for the Chinese New Year. It took an additional 2 months to repair and send it back. 4 reviewers, 2 suggesting acceptance, 1 agreeing in principle, and 1 not explicitly stating but mentioning the need for further language revisions, providing minor edits. It took another month to send it back for repairs. Under review for 2 weeks and then it has been "required reviews completed" for 2 weeks, feeling anxious~~~ I'm afraid the reviewer might change their mind again...

Asueyi 2021-06-30

The above-mentioned time supplements:
4.21 return after major revision
4.30 under review
5.20 minor revision
5.21 revised
6.1 under review
6.27 decision in process
6.29 accepted
The editors are Cecilia Maria Villas Bôas de Almeida and Thokozani Majozi, thank you.

云朵奥 2021-06-30

May I ask if anyone has the status of "Required Reviews Completed"? What does this situation mean?