Xiaopi Ding 2023-06-05

Not yet, have you received any news? It's been two weeks and it still hasn't been reviewed.

Jason Peng 2023-06-04

The editor-in-chief is a Greek editor, and the processing speed is acceptable. Generally, it takes less than a week for the manuscript to be sent for review with an editor. The speed of the peer review process (DIP) is also good. I saw a few people saying it's slow, maybe it's related to the editor's preference for the field of review. I have a friend in the computer field who also submitted to this journal, maybe it's one of the IEEE affiliated journals!

The supervisor is a distinguished professor and the associate editor of a journal under a certain publication. They have high citation rates, and I didn't encounter many difficulties during the submission process!

The paper was submitted in January, received minor revision feedback in April, returned within a week, and was accepted after a month.

小摩的 2023-06-04

I am the same. Greek editors are extremely rubbish. I will never submit to this journal again. I have been working on it for nearly two months, and they rejected it by saying it doesn't fit within the scope of the journal. It's so unethical. Don't they feel even a little bit ashamed? They have deceived several people. They are truly idiots.

醇色9 2023-06-03

Only two people agreed to review the manuscript. One finished reviewing it in one and a half months, while the other has been reviewing it for a month and it hasn't ended yet. Generally, how long is the review period for each reviewer according to the editor's regulations?

WintersG 2023-06-02

No reply, the result came out directly. I saw the recipient of the internal message was Aisiweier, write down your demands and they will help you follow up on that side.

一只科研狗 2023-06-01

I am still missing a reviewer, but the editor hasn't resubmitted for a long time. It's worrying.

jasonshi77 2023-06-01

I would like to ask Brother W, after you sent the reminder for the manuscript through internal mail, did you receive a reply or did you directly obtain the result?

liusuxion 2023-06-01

A piece written in Mandarin was previously submitted to a scientific research management in Chinese. After receiving several suggestions from external reviewers, it was rejected by the editor. The teacher then asked for it to be translated into English and submitted to JCLP. In less than a week, it was directly rejected without any reason given, and I was told to submit it to Cleaner Environmental Systems instead. Speechless.

星星之火 2023-05-31

So far, the manuscript has been sent to 11 reviewers, but none of them have accepted to review it. Is it really that difficult to find reviewers now? My research topic is not even obscure, yet the paper is being overlooked...

宇宙无敌嘎嘎 2023-05-31

The corresponding author can see it, and they will send an email.

小青岛 2023-05-31

No rush for manuscript. Fortunately, it was received a few days before the student paper review.

liusuxion 2023-05-30

Admire the boss, bask in good luck!

jasonshi77 2023-05-30

Congratulations, bro! Then I'll wait for two more days, if it doesn't work, I'll remind you as well. Thank you very much.

WintersG 2023-05-30

Hey, buddy, what a coincidence! I'm also a "Cold Teacher". It has been 23 days since the second review of DIP. I just received the comments at noon. I don't know if the internal message I sent yesterday urging for the manuscript had an effect.

wait 2023-05-30

I want to ask how to inquire about the system.

wait 2023-05-30

So fast, wishing you well.

lqbush 2023-05-30

My editor is Dr. Leng Zhen, and I feel that Dr. Leng is very enthusiastic. However, every time I receive the reviewer's comments, it takes about a week for the editor to give them to me, and it is often on Tuesdays. This is probably related to Dr. Leng's work habits. Especially during the final dip stage, I had to wait for a full 22 days.

WintersG 2023-05-30

Just received a small repair, two agreed to accept, one requested that the icon instructions be more complete. It is still useful to remind them through the internal message.

Xue 2023-05-30

4.12 Submission
4.14 with editor
Until today, 5.30, there has been no news. Sent an inquiry once, but received no response.
It's very slow, not recommended.

scima 2023-05-30

Without submission for review, directly dip, the result was a direct dip for a month. Sending emails to urge also proved ineffective. I am preparing to withdraw the manuscript...

WintersG 2023-05-30

Who is the editor of this buddy? The efficiency is so fast.

jasonshi77 2023-05-30

Does the internal mailbox editor have a reply, bro?

xiaofanfan 2023-05-30

Hello, how can I see who the assigned editor is? I am currently with the editor.

stwen 2023-05-30

Almost the same experience, sigh, dragging it for so long without submitting for review and then getting rejected, what a pity. Lately, there have been many publications. I suggest transferring it to a subordinate journal.

stwen 2023-05-30

May 29, 2023 Reject
Comment: Very slow, the editor took 40 days with the manuscript and it got rejected without being reviewed.
This magazine is very unreliable. The editor asked me to transfer to their subsidiary's rubbish publication, which is disgusting. I probably won't submit to them again in the future.
The magazine has a bad reputation and only cares about publishing quickly without proper review. It's really not worth submitting when they're this slow and still reject without review.

海歌1234 2023-05-29

2023.3.23 Submitted with editor for 20 days, dip for 13 days. Results will be released on 5.29. Option 1 and 2 suggest publication, option 3 is neutral, option 4 says my selection is not suitable for publication, and option 5 implies a lack of understanding. I will never submit to this journal again as it is a waste of time.

WintersG 2023-05-29

Yes, I am also handled by Teacher Leng Zhen. The first review was quite fast, it took about a week to submit for review. Then it got stuck in DIP for about 8 days and was given major revisions. The second review was submitted 3 days later and it has been stuck in DIP for 22 days now. I just sent an internal message urging for the manuscript, not sure if it will be effective.

dragonlord 2023-05-29

How long does it usually take for Teacher Lengzhen's submission to be reviewed? It has been 5 days now and there has been no response yet. I feel like it's not going well.

jasonshi77 2023-05-29

Brother W, did Professor Leng handle your issue as well? Mine was also handled by Professor Leng. It was resolved quickly before, but this time it has been over a month since the second round of repair and there is still no news.

大西瓜 2023-05-29

Up until now, it has been 33 days since I submitted my manuscript, but I still haven't received any updates.