认证评论 - Journal of Alloys and Compounds
注: 认证评论选取于全球各个学术评论平台和社交媒体。

z123 2021-03-04

2020 12 04 submit Electrochemistry
2021 01 07
A minor revision A major revision
2021 02 03 submit
2021 02 07 review
2021 02 28 accept
The editor is Jennifer Aitken.

start 2021-03-03

The translation of the text "编辑是Isabel Van Driessche" into English is "The editor is Isabel Van Driessche."

zyfc 2021-03-02

Same, my small revision was replied on February 1st, and it is still under review until now.

Yuria 2021-03-02

My revision 2.5 has been submitted, and there is still no news. It has always been "required reviews completed".

Yuria 2021-03-02

May I ask which editor you are?

start 2021-03-01

2020.11.17 Submitted to journal
2020.11.21 With editor
2020.12.20 Under review
2021.01.10 Minor revisions
2021.02.07 Revisions submitted to journal
2021.02.08 With editor
2021.02.28 Accept

Translated:

2020.11.17 Submitted to journal
2020.11.21 With editor
2020.12.20 Under review
2021.01.10 Minor revisions
2021.02.07 Revisions submitted to journal
2021.02.08 With editor
2021.02.28 Accept

zmmlong 2021-02-26

It roughly takes about two months from submission to acceptance.

银子 2021-02-23

The article has finally been accepted, and the graduation task is completed. Let me share my submission experience.
2020.12.20 submitted, under review after one week
2021.1.21 major revision
2021.1.30 submitted to the journal
2021.2.03 under review
2021.2.15 accepted
Thank you to Editor Renbing Wu and the reviewers. I wish everyone smooth research.

胡萝卜S1 2021-02-09

2020.11.21 submitted
2020.11.22 with editor
2020.11.23 under review
2020.12.29 required reviews completed
2020.12.30 major revision
2021.01.24 submit to journal
2021.01.25 with editor
2021.01.26 under review
2021.02.08 accept
Thank you to the editor and reviewers, the best New Year's gift of '21, very timely! Two reviewers, 16 comments, greatly helpful to the article!

jm82-1 2021-02-01

I received a reply after eight months of waiting, and it took twelve months to accept. Please be patient and wait.

挚爱灵儿 2021-01-30

I submitted it around mid-September, but have not received any response yet. It has been consistently under review. I followed up once to inquire about it.

SHEN 2021-01-27

Received 28 October 2020
2 reviewers, 12 comments, all quite simple
Received in revised form 27 December 2020
Accepted 7 January 2021
Available online 9 January 2021

做一只化学dog 2021-01-14

I thought that the Swiss were also involved in the "Civil War" in the United States, but actually it was about impeaching Donald Trump. All the master's work ends here, although it is the worst one, but still thank you to the Swiss magazine "Journal of Alloys and Compounds" for wrapping it up. Thank you for your recognition and approval.
2020.11.11 submitted
2020.11.14 with editor
2020.11.17 under review
2020.12.12 Required Reviews Completed
2020.12.15 major revision
2020.12.21 submit to journal
2020.12.22 with editor
2020.12.24 under review
2021.01.13 accept

会翻身的咸鱼干 2021-01-11

Submit for review two days later, receive review comments after 20 days. One reviewer agrees to accept directly, while the other disagrees and provides 8 suggestions. The editor rejects it directly. This system for assigning reviewers is really frustrating. It assigned someone who specializes in nano materials to review an article about alloys. It's absurd.

奔跑& 2021-01-09

After a three-month review process, the editor finally gave minor revisions and hopes that the journal will continue to improve.

王路飞 2021-01-08

What is your current status, please?

Find the ideal target journal for your manuscript

Explore over 38,000 international journals covering a vast array of academic fields.

Search

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started