小颗粒 2022-11-14

submitted: 2022.8.25
with editor: 2022.8.25
under review: 2022.8.25
major revision: 2022.9.11
reversion submitted to journal: 2022.10.02
with editor: 2022.10.02
under review: 2022.10.02
accept: 2022.10.22

Translation:
submitted: 2022.8.25
with editor: 2022.8.25
under review: 2022.8.25
major revision: 2022.9.11
reversion submitted to journal: 2022.10.02
with editor: 2022.10.02
under review: 2022.10.02
accept: 2022.10.22

eeee 2022-11-13

Do you know why the status remains "Submitted to Journal" after submitting the paper? Why is there no change?

Jenny 2022-11-10

10.21 required reviews completed: The required reviews were finished on October 21st.
10.21 under review: Currently being reviewed since October 21st.
11.08 required reviews completed: The required reviews were finished on November 8th.
11.08 major revision: A significant revision was made on November 8th.

taylor1993 2022-11-10

First draft of major revision on November 9th.

taylor1993 2022-11-08

The first submission was made on August 9th. It was under review on August 10th, and the required reviews were completed on October 31st until now. It feels quite slow...

The second submission was made on September 21st. It was under review at the same time and the required reviews were completed on October 12th. On October 15th, there were major revisions (four reviewers, one major revision, two minor revisions, and one rejection). It was revised on November 2nd, and the required reviews have been ongoing until now... On November 4th, the status remained unchanged, but the time has changed. It should be that three reviewers have completed their reviews, and only one reviewer is left. There are two possible predictions: 1. The three reviewers approved, and the rejecting reviewer is still reviewing. 2. Two reviewers approved, and the rejecting reviewer insists on their original opinion (or also approves), while one reviewer who requested major revisions is still reviewing. The final outcome could be: Accept-Accept-Accept-Accept or Accept-Accept-Reject/Major Revision-Accept/Revision.

Jenny 2022-11-05

I received the editor's email reply on the third day, but there are also some members of the same research group who haven't received a response.

Erik93 2022-11-04

Also, I contacted the editor-in-chief's personal email. How long does it usually take for them to reply to emails? It has been almost a week and I haven't received a response yet.

RoseLiu 2022-11-01

I'm really lucky. None of the articles were rejected, and the chief editor sent them for review... Then, during the major revision, I followed the suggestions of the reviewers and sent them back.

月亮 2022-10-31

Error displayed, submitted at 5:45, with editor at 6.

月亮 2022-10-31

Summary of the main editor MW's opinions and matters to be addressed.

You can summarize and revise in advance according to the opinions above, and MW can directly approve it. I submitted it on October 30th at 5:45 PM, and by 6 PM it was with the editor. When I opened it in the evening, it was already under review. Therefore, you can make the necessary modifications in advance and submit it directly, saving time. The following is a summary, not necessarily comprehensive:

1. 70 references.
2. Each section should start with an introduction explaining what the section is about.
3. Explanations should be provided below each image and table, including the meaning of abbreviations. This means that others should be able to understand what your image represents based on your explanation.
4. Pay attention to creating a graphic summary.
5. Each graph should have a sufficient number of major divisions (4-6) and should be oriented towards the inside. The image quality should be high.

The above is my personal summary. Feel free to continue updating.

忽然 2022-10-26

How should the content of this private email be written?

Cc_zz 2022-10-26

Encountered the same situation...
May I ask how to contact the editor-in-chief? Begging for sharing.

Jenny 2022-10-25

I made the changes according to the editor's opinions, contacted them via email, but received no response. So I submitted it again for review.

xiao Z 2022-10-25

Second submission, should I directly submit it? Or should I explain and say that it has been modified?

Erik93 2022-10-24

Okay, thank you very much.

Jenny 2022-10-24

No template was found, so I made modifications based on the guide and editor's rejection feedback one by one.

Erik93 2022-10-24

Okay, thank you. Is there a template when submitting the first draft?

Jenny 2022-10-24

Add an asterisk (*) above the name of the corresponding author and provide a footnote.

Erik93 2022-10-24

How to submit a joint communication?

Nirneo 2022-10-24

17th Sep - Major revision
20th Oct - Revision submitted to journal
20th Oct - Under review

Jenny 2022-10-22

This morning, the required reviews were completed. But at noon, it changed back to "under review". Does this mean that there is a significant difference in opinions among the reviewers?

yizhen 2022-10-22

What is the relationship between "Manuscript File", "REVISED Manuscript (text UNmarked)", and "Revised Manuscript - MARKED PDF"? What should be uploaded for "Manuscript File"?

hehe 2022-10-22

Then I uploaded the wrong one. The first one I uploaded was not modified, and the following two were the modified ones. The editing was not sent back, so I submitted it for review again. I don't know how serious the problem is. It has been submitted for several days.

Jenny 2022-10-21

I set the line spacing to 1.5 times, I don't know if I understand it correctly.

xiao Z 2022-10-21

M.W提的 重新格式化为一个半垂直空间，以便于回顾。这个怎么弄？

Translate: M.W suggested reformatting it into a semi-vertical space for easier review. How can we do this?

hyc_mechanic 2022-10-20

It is the revised manuscript by you.

shimin_7 2022-10-18

I submitted the initial draft in a general format, and when it was returned for revisions, the editor made a lot of suggestions regarding the formatting. The specific suggestions were quite similar to what was mentioned by the person on the 172nd floor.

任福川 2022-10-18

Hello, may I ask if there are any formatting requirements for this journal when submitting a manuscript?

shimin_7 2022-10-17

Translated:

Submitted: 2022.8.1
With Editor: 2022.8.2
Under Review: 2022.8.4
Required Reviews Completed: 2022.8.22
Under Review: 2022.8.24 (Arbitration)
Required Reviews Completed: 2022.9.1
Major Revision: 2022.9.4
Reversion Submitted to Journal: 2022.9.22
With Editor: 2022.9.22
Under Review: 2022.9.24
Required Reviews Completed: 2022.10.11
Under Review: 2022.10.11
Accept: 2022.10.17

ouc_gu 2022-10-16

In total, it lasted for 8 days, with three major repairs.