TheShine 2022-11-16

Hasn't it already been under review? How can you tell that no one has reviewed it?

科研-婷婷 2022-11-15

2022.8.30 submitted
2022.10.1 under review
2022.11.14 No reviewers have reviewed yet, should I follow up in this situation?

xueli zhang 2022-11-09

The first article was submitted to this journal almost 5 months ago. Recently, I asked the journal about it, and they replied that they had contacted 15 reviewers, but only two of them were willing to review it. They are still waiting for feedback from the other reviewers...

jaylen 2022-11-04

How is it now? Have you submitted it?

huanghelouzi 2022-11-03

Translated:

Submitted 27 Oct 2022
With Editor 30 Oct 2022
Under Review 07 Nov 2022
Decision in Process 21 Nov 2022
Revise Major from 21 Nov 2022 to 12 Dec 2022

The review process was quite fast, but the time given for revisions was very short, with around twenty suggestions from three reviewers.

Xiology 2022-10-27

2022.9.13 with editor
2022.10.17 under review
Just noting it down, looking forward to a positive outcome.

11o 2022-10-25

Just had an external audit on the night of the 24th, hoping everything goes smoothly!

Maxj2020 2022-10-25

It's probably not going to work out. Mine has been with the editor for almost a month too.

11o 2022-10-25

2022.9.13 Submit
2022.10.24 Under Review
I hope everything goes smoothly!

11o 2022-10-23

I have been editing and reviewing for over a month, but it has not been submitted for review yet. Is this normal? Why is it so slow?

yanwei123 2022-10-22

It has been over a month since the necessary review was completed, and several emails have been received stating that the review is sufficient, but no comments have been given. Is this normal?

nunu_bupt 2022-10-19

The first review has been two months already, one has already been reviewed, but today suddenly added another reviewer, splitting open...

fiveClock 2022-10-18

It should be luck, encountered a reviewer who submitted quickly :)

xueli zhang 2022-10-18

I submitted on June 18, 2022, it changed to "under review" on June 27, 2022, and it is still "under review" until now. Why is it so slow? Can I follow up on it?^_^

yx2022 2022-10-17

The first trial took two months for major revisions, and it has been three months since the second trial with no result yet.

lana123456 2022-10-17

Why are you so fast? I have been waiting for the external review for 4 months...

fiveClock 2022-10-16

First submission, it feels quite fast.
2022.6.16 submit
2022.7.22 major revision
2022.8.30 submit
2022.10.7 revise language issues
2022.10.11 submit
2022.10.15 accept

leo99 2022-10-15

In the email, you asked about communication. If you are the communication itself, then I am not sure.

leo99 2022-10-15

It seems like only communication emails can be received.

haohao 2022-10-14

Excuse me, did you receive an email where you can check the progress of the review? In the email, there is a link that you can click on to see it. So, you can see that two reviewers have completed the review.

haohao 2022-10-14

Previously, if you submitted to other journals under Elsevier, they would send you an email when the review process started. The email would contain a link where you could see how many reviewers have accepted the review and how many have already completed it. However, for the journal "Information Sciences," it has been one month since I submitted on the website and I haven't received this email. I'm not sure if this journal does not send emails or if it is still in the hands of the editor and has not been sent for review yet. I have seen other colleagues who have received this progress update email when their comments were published, so I suspect that not receiving an email means it is still with the editor, but the status has been changed to "under review."

Everest11 2022-10-12

First round: Submitted on 2.14, under review on 2.17. First round of revision completed on 5.19, with two reviewers. Questions were answered satisfactorily.
Second round: Submitted on 6.10, second round of review completed on 7.3. Only one reviewer had concerns, minor revisions required.
Third round: Submitted on 8.5, third round of review completed on 8.29. Editor requested reducing the number of references to 50 or less.
Fourth round: Submitted on 9.2, accepted on 10.11.

lana123456 2022-10-12

I did not receive the email with the link to check the progress. How can I check it?

METAVERSE 2022-10-10

2022.10.10, 10:19 AM submission, ID assigned, Initial Date Submitted: 09 Oct 2022, Status Date: 09 Oct 2022, Current Status: Submitted to Journal;
2022.10.10, 11:47 AM REJECTION, reason being manuscript is not suitable for publication in the journal.

haohao 2022-10-09

Excuse me, have you received an email notification for external review after your submission was under review? I heard that when it is under review, you will receive an email with a link to check the progress of the review. However, it has been a month since I am under review and I haven't received any email.

JeremyLau 2022-09-30

Decision was made on the 22nd. It has been a week and I still haven't received the rejection letter.

lana123456 2022-09-29

Still Under Review

nunu_bupt 2022-09-27

A few people have accepted the review.

leo99 2022-09-27

Hello, may I ask how many reviewers have completed the review?

leo99 2022-09-27

How many reviewers' opinions do people generally need? It shows that two people have already finished reviewing. Three should be enough, generally speaking, for the first submission to this journal.