Tyrion_liao 2021-09-18

2021.8.31 submitted to journal
2021.9.02 under review
2021.9.15 minor revision
2021.9.18 submit revised manuscript

root618 2021-09-07

You can see "In Peer Review" in the Instructions&Forms, right? It should have been submitted for review three weeks ago.

Read One 2021-09-07

What is your current situation now? I have also been under review for almost a month.

Read One 2021-09-07

Is your submission always under review after you have submitted it? Or is it something else?

Read One 2021-09-07

After submitting on 8.16, it has been continuously showing "under review" for over three weeks, and I don't know if it has been sent for review or not.

秋夜雨 2021-08-19

Although this journal has declined in ranking, its influence in the field of chemical engineering is still considerable. I hope it can regain its position in the top next year.

Meredith 2021-07-08

Two reviewers provided 7 revision suggestions, which were considered minor. After adding two experimental data, the revised manuscript was submitted again. Although the initial review process took almost 2 months, the later review was relatively fast. This is my first experimental paper and it was rejected 5 times before. However, it was successfully accepted by IECR on the 6th submission. I consider it a satisfactory response for myself.

Meredith 2021-07-08

Submission Experience:
2021.04.26 submitted to journal
2021.06.13 minor revision (revision time: 1 month)
2021.06.24 submit revised manuscript
2021.06.28 accepted
2021.07.08 proof

guowanjiang 2021-06-15

Excuse me, has your situation changed now? Have you provided feedback for repair?

小李~ 2021-05-14

Hello, OP. I submitted an article on the 12th, but the submission status is completely unknown. Is this normal?

陆摇礼 2021-05-10

Everything is going smoothly.
Submitted on January 25, 2021.
On January 26, the system reminded me that there was an issue with the form number, so I made the necessary modifications and resubmitted it.
In peer review on January 30, 2021.
Received review comments on February 25 (conveniently during winter break). There were three reviewers, the comments from the first reviewer were quite superficial, but the comments from the second and third reviewers were quite profound.
Returned after revisions on March 25, 2021.
Accepted on March 30, 2021.
Online on April 7.

元气森林 2021-04-13

May I ask, what does "Under Review" mean when it has been a month since the submission?

有梦就去追啊 2021-04-08

1.31 Submitted to Journal
2.2 with editor
2.3 In peer review
3.9 Received reviewer comments, major revisions requested, given one month to complete. Three reviewers in total, one provided standard feedback; one helped with grammar and polished the writing; the last reviewer posed more challenging questions.
4.2 Responded to reviewer comments
4.4 In peer review
4.5 Accepted

This is the first paper published by a master's student. There were moments of discouragement due to failed experiments, late nights on campus, and times when stress affected appetite. However, there was also great joy upon acceptance of the paper. The entire process was a valuable experience, and gratitude is expressed to everyone encountered along the way.

仙lv 2021-03-19

A little weird and ambiguous? Isn't it just that both are on the borderline, and there must always be one to bear the decline zone. Mei Tao has also declined, can it be said that its quality is clearly inferior to Guo Tao...