yzyx 2022-07-04

ACS publishing center

yaoyuan156 2022-06-30

Hello senior, your description of the status and time frame of the manuscript is very clear. Did you check it in the system or did you receive email notifications as well? Thank you.

陈锦佑 2022-06-27

As a salty fish doing research in traditional chemical engineering, I have always regarded the three major chemical engineering journals as the ones I most want to submit to. Although they have now become third-tier journals, it has not affected their status in my heart at all. The editors are very quick, and the reviewers are also very professional.

Submitted on March 24, 2022;
Assigned an editor on March 25, 2022, and sent for review;
Major revision on April 15, 2022;
Revised and sent for review on May 12, 2022;
Ready for acceptance on June 11, 2022;
Accepted on June 15, 2022;
Online on June 26, 2022.

jiangduojiang 2022-06-24

Give a message within one month, make modifications and resubmit. After resubmitting, there will be a small revision period of twenty days, and four days to accept the modifications. It's quite fast.

9527_yy 2022-06-22

May I ask everyone, how can I, as a co-author, see the review status of the paper submitted by our supervisor?

lxy12134546 2022-06-16

Brother, have you received any updates? It has been over 20 days since my second review as well.

Wuuu' 2022-06-13

The first trial took 40 days, and now it has been 23 days since it was sent back for repairs. I don't know what happened o(╥﹏╥)o

唐伯虎点蚊香 2022-06-04

The text "online 6.3" is already in English and does not require translation.

夏迎春 2022-06-02

Did you submit it for review later? How long has the editor had it?

夏迎春 2022-06-02

Did you get rejected after staying with the chief editor for more than a month, or were you rejected after being sent for review?

夏迎春 2022-05-29

The manuscript was submitted on the afternoon of the 24th and is still in the hands of the editor-in-chief, Phillip E. Savage. It has not been assigned a deputy editor yet, while my senior sister in the same group submitted hers in the afternoon and got a deputy editor assigned in the evening. Are there many recent journal submissions? I feel a bit anxious about it!

唐伯虎点蚊香 2022-05-26

submitted to journal 2022.4.11
in peer review 2022.4.15
minor revision 2022.5.11
revision submitted 2022.5.13
accept 2022.5.24

Translation:
submitted to journal 2022.4.11
in peer review 2022.4.15
minor revision 2022.5.11
revision submitted 2022.5.13
accept 2022.5.24

朗格缪尔-归去来兮 2022-04-26

4.26 Rejected

小菜鸡 2022-04-18

February 20, 2022: Submitted to editor's office
February 22, 2022: Associate editor assigned
March 2, 2022: In peer review
April 5, 2022: Minor revision
April 12, 2022: Revised manuscript resubmitted to editor's office, associate editor assigned on the same day
April 15, 2022: Accepted

The review process was fast and efficient, but unfortunately, as one of the top three journals in chemical engineering, it has declined. It seems to have undergone reforms this year and is now headed in a positive direction. Even though the impact factor has exceeded 4.2, the future looks promising.

爱吃咸鱼的猫 2022-04-13

2021-12-2 submit
2022-2-27 major revision
2022-3-35 resubmit
2022-4-2 accepted

Translation:
2021-12-2: Submitted
2022-2-27: Major revision
2022-3-35: Resubmitted
2022-4-2: Accepted

朗格缪尔-归去来兮 2022-04-13

3.15 under review. It has been almost a month now and there is still no news.

爱郄郄 2022-03-25

2022/3/25 Under review.

元气森林 2022-03-17

If it is sent for review, you will receive an email from the assigned editor.

心随 2022-03-15

Excuse me, OP, my paper has been in the "under review" status for about 20 days. Can you tell me if this status means it has been reviewed or not?

夏迎春 2022-01-08

2021.11.28 submit - Submitted on November 28, 2021.
2021.12.28 major revision - Major revision due on December 28, 2021.
2022.1.4 resubmit - Resubmit on January 4, 2022.
2022.1.6 minor revision (technical revision) - Minor revision (technical revision) on January 6, 2022.
2022.1.7 accept - Accepted on January 7, 2022.

晨嘟嘟 2022-01-06

Just saw the acceptance notice this morning, happy! Happy New Year to everyone and may all your endeavors be successful!

2021.7.27 Submit
2021.7.28 Under Review
2021.10.18 Reject & Resubmit (Deadline: 1.16.2022)
2021.11.15 Resubmit
2021.11.17 Under Review
2022.1.4 Minor revision (Deadline: 1.24.2022)
2022.1.5 Resubmit
2022.1.6 Accept

QQQMY 2021-12-27

Can I choose the deputy editor? Or will the editor assign randomly?

C2H4 2021-12-18

Hello, after one week of submission, what I see in the publishing center is "Associate Editor Assigned." However, in the submission interface, it has been showing "under review" from the beginning. I'm wondering if it has been sent for review or not. Thank you.

永恒八一 2021-12-10

10.29 submit
11.01 associate Editor Assigned (Pro. Chunzhong Li, East China University of Science and Technology)
11.03 under review
11.16 major revision (three reviewers, three weeks)
11.29 re-submit
11.30 under review
12.07 minor revision (Technical revision)
12.09 re-submit
12.10 accept

黑帝31 2021-11-29

2021-5-27 Delivery
2021-6-29 Rejected & Submitted
2021-8-21 Resubmitted after modification
2021-9-23 Three reviewers, two accepted, one considered experimental design unreasonable, editor rejected
2021-9-25 Sent an email to the editor-in-chief stating that the reasons for rejection were insufficient, after careful discussion by the editor, made unified modifications
2021-10-2 Resubmitted after modification
2021-11-16 Three reviewers, two agreed, minor revisions
2021-11-22 Submitted after modification
2021-11-27 Accepted
For my first SCI paper, I still want to thank my supervisor for their help and the editor for their patience. I'm happy!

李香香 2021-11-15

Two reviewers, one gave a very high evaluation, and one admitted it was critical. The editor offered a transfer but they do not intend to submit it anymore.

李香香 2021-11-08

2021.7.29 First submission
2021.7.31 with editor
2021.8.1 in peer review
2021.9.3 reject&resubmit
2021.9.29 resubmitted after revising according to reviewer comments
2021.10.1 in peer review
2021.11.8-present status unknown

Read One 2021-10-23

I saw the acceptance this morning and I was very excited. I want to share the submission process with everyone:
August 16, 2021 - Submission
August 19, 2021 - Peer review
September 25, 2021 - Revision
October 10, 2021 - Revised version returned
October 23, 2021 - Accepted.

NEUGZ 2021-10-19

This belongs to the category of rejection with the option to resubmit. You can find detailed processing results in the instructions&forms. Just revise the paper according to the reviewer's comments and resubmit it.

晨嘟嘟 2021-10-19

Just received the following email. I would like to ask the senior editors for their interpretation of this sentence: "... I don't believe could be addressed through a standard major revision. In light of the comments received, I am unable to accept the manuscript for publication in Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research." Does this mean that resubmission is not recommended? However, the content of the email suggests the possibility of revisions. This is my first submission to IECR, and I would greatly appreciate any advice from experienced colleagues. Thank you very much!!

------------------------------------Separator (Submission System)------------------------------------

Resubmission requested on 18 October 2021
Resubmission due before: 16 January 2022