刘减减 2023-06-12

29-Nov-2022 Submitted
11-Apr-2023 Major Revision
06-May-2023 Submitted Again
24-May-2023 Accept with Mandatory Minor Revisions Including English Usage
01-Jun-2023 Submitted Again
06-Jun-2023 Accept as Regular

Translation:
29-Nov-2022 Submitted
11-Apr-2023 Major Revision
06-May-2023 Submitted Again
24-May-2023 Accepted with Mandatory Minor Revisions Including English Usage
01-Jun-2023 Submitted Again
06-Jun-2023 Accepted as Regular

刘减减 2023-06-12

25-Oct-2022 Submitted
23-Jan-2023 Major Revision
17-Feb-2023 Submitted Again
Until now In Peer Review

Boobooboo 2023-06-10

No results yet, it has been eight months. The second reminder has been sent, and they said they are still waiting for the reviewer's comments. It's really outrageous.

fengqh 2023-06-09

Dear respected contributors, how long does the first and second review usually take?

fengqh 2023-06-09

Really slow, I dare not rush.

拉风的树 2023-06-09

My application has been under review for almost 7 months. May I ask if you have received the result yet? It won't take a year, will it? That's really unreasonable.

拉风的树 2023-06-09

It takes one and a half months to assign an AE, and it's been over six months since the first review and still no response. Sigh, it's worrisome for those who are eager to graduate and carefully select investment opportunities. I want to ask, is urging for the manuscript useful?

fengqh 2023-06-03

The reply to the reminder is always very official, without any useful information, just waiting.

Lanllllllllll 2023-06-01

Translated text: I submitted a TMM in 2019, and the experience was okay. I thought the slow review process mentioned in the comments was an occasional situation, but I didn't expect the following:

Submitted on October 1, 2022.
First reminder sent on March 15, 2023. The editor said they couldn't find enough reviewers, and if they can't find any, a decision will be given directly.
Second reminder sent on April 20, 2023. The editor said they will reply soon, but I immediately received a rejection notice.

Conclusion: Rejection is not the problem, the problem is the slow process.

Wenlve 2023-05-31

Classmate, is your AE an Indian?

fengqh 2023-05-31

Encountered very slow reviewers and AE...

fengqh 2023-05-31

Is there a reply to the reminder for submission?

Wenlve 2023-05-31

Hello, did the editor reply after reminding them about the manuscript?

researcherpku 2023-05-31

2022.8.22 - Submitted
2022.9.5 - In peer review
2023.3.10 - Urgent request for submission
2023.5.30 - In peer review

Why is it so slow?

Boobooboo 2023-05-23

2022.10.10 Submission
2022.10.25 Assigned to AE
2023.05.23 in peer review
It has been almost eight months, and there is no news at all. I sent an email once in between to inquire, but there was no clear response. It's slow, incredibly slow!

feifei_cv 2023-05-11

Add a sample for reference:
September 22, 2022, submission
March 19, 2023, major revision (four reviewers, two AQ, two RQ)
March 19, 2023 - March 27, 2023, revision, supplemented with experiments, submitted on March 28
April 26, 2023, minor revision (AQ), three reviewers gave A directly, one reviewer still gave AQ
Submitted on April 28, 2023
Accepted on May 10, 2023 (A)

Jason 2023-05-08

Add a sample for reference:

December 7, 2022, submitted
January 10, 2023, assigned to AE
February 10, 2023, major revisions (all three reviewers were RQ, with nearly 20 comments)
February 11 to March 23, 2023, revised, added many experiments, wrote a 30-page response letter, submitted on March 23
April 15, 2023, minor revisions (AQ), two reviewers gave an A directly, satisfied with my response, another reviewer suggested adding a small experiment, so I added it
Submitted on April 23, 2023, 6-page response letter
Accepted on May 4, 2023 (A)

Overall, it took more than five months. The full paper is 16 pages long. I'm very happy. This is my first time being published in Trans, TMM is currently a recommended A-class journal by Tsinghua University, with good quality, better than other journals like TCSVT, TNNLS, but still a distance from TIP, TPAMI, but it is definitely getting better. I wish everyone can publish their papers soon! My personal experience is that TMM values innovation and experiments. You must constantly polish the work you have done, avoiding rushing. Improving performance is not the only thing the reviewers care about, so don't blindly try to improve it. The most important thing is the idea and experiments!

找个好工作 2023-04-30

Posted on 2022.09.23, it is currently in peer review as of 2023.04.30. There was one reminder sent to the editor in between, but there doesn't seem to be much response. The journal is a bit slow.

囷囷 2023-04-26

2022.11.28 Submission
2022.12.14 Assigned AE, in peer review
2023.4.21 Major revision

fengqh 2023-04-23

Is this journal so slow? Did you urge them? Is there a response?

SemiZxf 2023-04-13

4.13 update, still in peer review, really slow, it's been 7 months.

尼斯湖之怪 2023-04-07

2022.7 Submission
2023.1 Major Revision
2023.4 Acceptance
Trans, a well-established name in the multimedia field, is trustworthy. The reviewers are professional and responsible.
Apart from the slow process (the submission took 9 months), the overall experience was good.

fengqh 2023-04-05

May I ask how many reviewers?

Elva_lkj 2023-03-26

Admiration, admiration. It feels like six months is still okay, relatively normal. I had a submission before that took a year and a half to be accepted.

xiaomujiang 2023-03-26

September 2022: Submission
January 2023: Major revision
February 2023: Revised submission
March 2023: Accepted

Overall, the review process takes a relatively long time.

清晨看露 2023-03-18

2022.10.30 submit - Submitted on October 30, 2022.
2022.11.15 in peer review - Under peer review as of November 15, 2022.
2023.3.18 Awaiting AE Decision - Waiting for the Associate Editor's decision as of March 18, 2023.
中间询问了一次AE的状态，虽然没回信，但是还是感觉起了一点作用 - Inquired about the status of the Associate Editor in the meantime, although no response was received, it still felt somewhat effective.
2023.3.20 Major Revision, 1RQ 2AQ - Major revision requested on March 20, 2023, with 1 major revision question and 2 additional questions.
需要补很多实验，感觉被扒了一层皮 - Need to conduct many additional experiments, feeling like being stripped of a layer of skin.
2023.4.28 resubmit, in peer review - Resubmitted on April 28, 2023, and currently under peer review.
2023.5.15 minor Revision, 2A 1AQ - Minor revision requested on May 15, 2023, with 2 minor revisions and 1 additional question.
审稿人还有一个实验上的问题，需要再补一组实验 - Reviewer has one more question regarding an experiment, need to conduct an additional set of experiments.
2023.5.19 resubmit, in peer review - Resubmitted on May 19, 2023, and currently under peer review.
2023.6.5 Accept - Accepted on June 5, 2023.

lyf_xmu 2023-03-17

2023-3-8 Submission
2023-3-12 Allocation of AE, in peer review

wpper 2023-03-15

Posted on September 18, 2022, returned comments on March 13, 2023, major revisions. It took nearly six months for the first review.

IseeArwin 2023-03-13

Excuse me, have you obtained the results now?

IseeArwin 2023-03-13

May I ask if you have received the verdict for the first trial?