月光下徜徉 2022-03-28

It has been ten days since the repair was submitted, but it is still "Inviting Reviewers." What is going on?

月光下徜徉 2022-03-28

The major repairs were submitted in just five days and accepted in just over ten days. Even minor repairs do not have such speed, right? This is so impressive!!!!

sunshine9966 2022-03-24

Very good journal, the review process is very fast. The opinions of three experts in the field are very helpful in improving the article.
2021-11-09 submitted
2021-12-22 major revision
2022-02-01 revision submission
2022-03-04 major revision
2022-03-09 revision submission
2022-03-22 accept

小悟空 2022-03-23

The first review process usually takes about 2 months from submission, and eventually received a "Reject & Resubmit" decision.

wale 2022-03-21

May I ask if you have followed up on AE40 for several days?

wale 2022-03-21

May I ask how long everyone has been waiting for Awaiting AE Recommendation? Mine has been over a month already...

我想再试试 2022-03-20

14-Feb-2022 Submitted, feedback received same day, exceeding 8 pages, over 30 references, requires revision
17-Feb-2022 Submitted
18-Feb-2022 Co-Editor-in-Chief assigned
25-Feb-2022 Reviewers assigned
16-Mar-2022 Additional reviewers assigned
17-Mar-2022 Reviewers assigned

小悟空 2022-03-20

Currently still in the "Awaiting reviewer scores" stage, will update progress status once there is news.

月光下徜徉 2022-03-19

What is the situation now? Has it been accepted?

SCI点评专家 2022-03-18

My repair has already been one month, still selecting reviewers, and I am not clear about the situation...

gdfzck 2022-03-16

2022.03.02 submitted
2022.03.10 awaiting co-eic assignment
2022.03.16 awaiting review scores

Translated:
2022.03.02 submitted
2022.03.10 awaiting co-editor-in-chief assignment
2022.03.16 awaiting review scores

mingyunjianshu 2022-03-14

Previously, the process was not recorded, so I will briefly explain the current process...
Submitted on March 4, 2022.
Awaiting Review Scores since March 14, 2022.
Today, I have been waiting for the review results... In between, I had to make format changes twice and there were reviewers invited. And today, it's already Awaiting Review Scores. I have never seen it happen this fast before, and I feel a bit anxious. Hopefully, the results will be better.

wwbo 2022-03-12

Already rejected after submission, the reviewer's comments were very fair. It was a direct rejection, not a request for resubmission. Can I make modifications and submit it again?

胡图图0222 2022-03-11

I am also in this situation, it has been a month already. Looking at others, some have received rejection letters and resubmitted or made major revisions, but they haven't mentioned this situation. After submitting, it's just waiting for the outcome...

elliotletpub 2022-03-10

It turns out that it's not as good as expected, even though it was proofread by an IEEE fellow personally. However, the content is still lacking. The review comments were very objective, and all three reviewers had similar opinions. The field of submission is not my expertise, so I had no idea of its depth. Here is the submission process:

2021.12.4: Awaiting co-eic assignment
2021.12.8: Assigned additional reviewers
2021.12.29: Assigning reviewers
2021.12.31: Assign additional reviewers
2022.01.27: Awaiting review scores
2022.02.25: Awaiting AE recommendation
2022.02.28: Awaiting EIC decision
2022.03.09: Rejected

mingyunjianshu 2022-03-07

What is said is that just because there are more than thirty references, it needs to be modified.

我是小渣渣 2022-03-04

Note before submission: 1) The manuscript should not exceed 8 pages, with only a very limited allowance for excessive length (up to a maximum of 1/2 page). 2) The number of references should be limited to 30 or fewer.

SCI点评专家 2022-03-04

Congratulations, everything is going smoothly, and my assignment is still waiting for review...

dzyha2011 2022-03-04

2021-9-30 submitted
2021-11-15 Major Revision
2021-12-18 a revision has been submitted
2022-1-4 Major Revision
2022-1-28 a revision has been submitted
2022-3-2 accept

The comments provided during the approximately five-month period were very helpful, and they greatly improved the paper.

小悟空 2022-03-04

[Little Goku] (Currently online) Published time: 2022-03-04 09:12:19
2021-09-20 submitted
2021-12-04 reject and resubmit
2022-02-24 resubmitted
2022-02-24 inviting reviewers
2022-02-24 waiting for review assignment
2022-02-26 selecting reviewers
2022-02-27 waiting for review assignment
2022-03-03 awaiting reviewer scores

小悟空 2022-03-04

2021-09-20 Submitted
2021-12-04 Reject and resubmit
2022-02-24 Resubmitted
2022-02-24 Inviting reviewers
2022-02-24 Waiting for review assignment
2022-02-26 Selecting reviewers
2022-02-27 Waiting for review assignment
2022-03-23 Awaiting reviewer scores

Translation:

2021-09-20 Submitted
2021-12-04 Reject and resubmit
2022-02-24 Resubmitted
2022-02-24 Inviting reviewers
2022-02-24 Waiting for review assignment
2022-02-26 Selecting reviewers
2022-02-27 Waiting for review assignment
2022-03-23 Awaiting reviewer scores

fanfan0000000 2022-03-03

May I ask, after my major overhaul, it shows "Waiting for Reviews" instead of "awaiting for review scores". Is there any difference between these two?

Clark Mark 2022-03-03

What's the matter? It has been 3 weeks waiting for AE recommendation.

Bayesian Slave 2022-02-28

Hello, I am also a resubmission after rejection. I would like to ask, on the official website, it says that revising a submission is considered a new submission, so the page limit cannot exceed 8. However, the editor in the decision letter mentioned it has been extended to 10 pages, with an additional fee for exceeding the limit... I am not sure which one to follow.

SCI点评专家 2022-02-28

Okay, I hope to enter "awaiting reviewer scores" soon...

小悟空 2022-02-28

Not sure, mine went from "waiting for review assignment" to "selecting reviewers" and then back to "waiting for review assignment" again.

SCI点评专家 2022-02-28

Shouldn't there be a new reviewer? Does this status mean that the review invitations have been sent to all reviewers and we are now waiting for their acceptance?

小悟空 2022-02-28

2021-09-20 submitted
2021-12-04 reject and resubmit
2022-02-24 resubmitted
2022-02-24 inviting reviewers
2022-02-24 waiting for review assignment
2022-02-26 selecting reviewers
2022-02-27 waiting for review assignment

Translated:
2021-09-20 submitted
2021-12-04 reject and resubmit
2022-02-24 resubmitted
2022-02-24 inviting reviewers
2022-02-24 waiting for review assignment
2022-02-26 selecting reviewers
2022-02-27 waiting for review assignment

小悟空 2022-02-28

Currently, it has also become "Waiting for review assignment." It is estimated that new reviewers have been invited, as the previous reviewers have declined to review.

SCI点评专家 2022-02-28

My first review is also RR (Reviewer Request), and recently after returning for repair, we first invite reviewers and then select reviewers. Currently, it is "Waiting for Review assignment," and I am also not sure what is going on...