冬臧 2023-01-05

Record
20220419 submit
20220802 reject and resubmit
20220925 resubmit
20221127 minor
20221209 resubmit

广仁 2022-12-31

I have also changed my teacher, are you Karin? Maybe John Wight went on vacation?

lhlhit 2022-12-30

5.3 Submission
6.5 Reject and resubmit
9.23 Resubmission
10.24 Major revision
11.15 Major revision submission
12.16 Acceptance

AAAZZZ 2022-12-30

May I ask what is the situation when it says "Undergoing Review" after changing ADM for half a month?

果园 2022-12-28

Update the progress for the team:
Submitted on March 29th;
Major revision on May 11th;
Major revision submitted on July 21st;
Minor revision on September 3rd;
Minor revision submitted on September 8th;
Another minor revision on November 2nd (originally no comments from the reviewer, but a new reviewer was added);
Accepted on December 27th.

小胖 2022-12-21

What does this mean?

再进一球 2022-12-21

I returned one day later than you, and there was no news either.

Pola_RSA 2022-12-21

Just wait, I guess people abroad are on vacation now. Good luck, there shouldn't be any major issues in your situation.

寿山下的牧牛人 2022-12-20

Comrades, has anyone been waiting for more than a month without any news? On November 11th, I received a notification from the editor, who provided only three suggestions for textual revisions, while the others indicated acceptance. Since November 14th, I have been hesitant to urge or inquire about the progress.

sweeny 2022-12-13

The revised version has already been published, noting the dates for everyone's reference:

Manuscript received: 19 October 2022;
Revised: 14 November 2022;
Accepted: 24 November 2022.
Date of publication: 28 November 2022;
Date of current version: 12 December 2022.

Jianxiang 2022-12-10

2022.6.14 Submit
2022.7.22 Reject and Resubmit
2022.11.9 Resubmit
2022.12.4 Minor Revision
2022.12.7 Accept

Translated text:

2022.6.14 Submit
2022.7.22 Reject and Resubmit
2022.11.9 Resubmit
2022.12.4 Minor Revision
2022.12.7 Accept

糖醋里脊男 2022-12-07

On October 14th, it became undergoing review... and then there was no "and then" anymore.

广域静默号 2022-12-06

06.01 Submission
07.01 Major Revision
09.22 Resubmit (due to being silent at home for nearly a month because of the epidemic, the revision took longer)
10.27 Minor Revision (at this time, all reviewers recommended acceptance)
11.01 Resubmit
11.27 Accept

Overall, it went relatively smoothly, but it was delayed due to the epidemic. Under normal circumstances, it could have saved another month. It is important to respond carefully to the revision comments and make the necessary changes as required. There should be no slackness in dealing with the issues. With effort and perseverance, success will be achieved!

德凯 2022-12-04

12.04, continue waiting, 51 days have passed.

chenhoho 2022-12-03

Will a hard copy be sent after the paper is published?

523616035 2022-11-30

What does "Undergoing review" show after submission? My current status is ADM Undergoing review. What is the external review like?

德凯 2022-11-29

On November 26th, I sent an email to inquire about the situation with the editor. The editor replied that they were waiting for the reviewer's feedback and it would be soon.
On November 29th, it is still undergoing review.

cnn123 2022-11-28

May I ask how much time you have been given to make the changes?

豆丁ys 2022-11-27

I have been waiting for the allocation of a reviewer. How long do I have to wait before the review process begins?

cnn123 2022-11-27

Received the review comments today.

冬臧 2022-11-25

The translation of the text into English is: "A timeline similar to yours, still waiting..."

cnn123 2022-11-25

I, like you, have cried myself unconscious.

德凯 2022-11-24

10.14 Submission
Currently Undergoing Review

木有名 2022-11-24

Wrote the wrong time: 10.30 submit and undergoing review.

木有名 2022-11-24

9.30submit and undergoing review - 9:30 submission and currently being reviewed.

小火汁 2022-11-21

96 days is too long, I feel like I can remind them.

海鹏 2022-11-21

It has been 96 days since the initial review, and there is still no news.

肥肥 2022-11-18

Hello, may I ask how much time you have been given to make modifications for the major?

GoodLuck 2022-11-17

Did they give a reject and resubmit, isn't it not possible to submit again if it is rejected?

寿山下的牧牛人 2022-11-14

I'm feeling a bit nervous about what you said. After the minor revision, there will be an additional reviewer. What's this all about?