认证评论 - AGRICULTURE ECOSYSTEMS & ENVIRONMENT
注: 认证评论选取于全球各个学术评论平台和社交媒体。

Nick 2022-07-15

I hope to be lucky.

Bee_worker 2022-07-13

It is a top-ranked journal in the field of agriculture, and the editor is particularly responsible. They gave us the opportunity to make revisions. The reviewers provided many relevant suggestions, and the quality of the revised article has significantly improved. The submission was made on February 6th, and after one major revision and one minor revision, it was published online on June 22nd, after a total of 4 and a half months. It is a journal with a great experience, highly recommended!

不要拉我,我还能写 2022-07-07

Have you been hired, OP?

尤四海 2022-07-07

6.27 submit
7.1 with editor
7.3 under review
After the last submission to this journal was rejected, I hope to have a good outcome this time.

myliuliu 2022-07-06

June 26, submitted to journal
June 27, with editor
July 04, under review
Looking forward to a positive outcome

Gaven 2022-06-30

I submitted it on June 28th, and until today, it still hasn't been assigned a number. Other people's submissions seem to have been processed quickly. Why is mine so slow?

要top啊 2022-06-20

June 18, rejection, the editor recommended submitting to a journal that they believed was suitable.

不要拉我,我还能写 2022-06-16

My item is still at RRC, it's getting annoying, it's been over two weeks.

IMZ 2022-06-16

Thank you, OP. What was the outcome later on for you?

要top啊 2022-06-16

15 June, 2022 with editor

要top啊 2022-06-14

Jun 14, 2022 Submitted to Journal.

不要拉我,我还能写 2022-06-14

Congratulations in advance, OP!

IMZ 2022-06-08

junio 8, bajo revisión

IMZ 2022-06-07

April 2, 2022 submitted
April 3, 2022 with editor
April 6, 2022 under review
April 8, 2022 under review
April 18, 2022 under review
April 28, 2022 under review
Because I was in a hurry to use the article for graduation, I sent an email to urge. May 31, required reviews completed
June 2, 2022 acceptable after minor revision
June 6, 2022 revision completed
June 6, 2022 with editor

温柔善良帅气 2022-05-30

Usually, it's best to be below 15%.

不要拉我,我还能写 2022-05-18

May 11, 2022 Submitted to Journal
May 13, 2022 With Editor
May 15, 2022 With Editor
May 19, 2022 Under Review
June 1, 2022 Required Reviews Completed
June 30, 2022 Acceptable after Moderate Revision
July 6, 2022 Resubmitted
July 6, 2022 With Editor
July 7, 2022 Under Review
July 8, 2022 Under Review
July 9, 2022 Required Reviews Completed
July 21, 2022 Acceptable after Minor Revision
July 21, 2022 Resubmitted to Journal
August 4, 2022 Accepted
August 9, 2022 Online

caicaihaha 2022-05-13

What is the repetition rate requirement for this journal?

筷子辣椒德芙 2022-04-24

Apr 24, 2022 Under Review

筷子辣椒德芙 2022-04-24

Apr 19, 2022 Subjected to journal
Apr 22, 2022 With Editor
Apr 23, 2022 With Editor

Translation:

Apr 19, 2022 Submitted to journal
Apr 22, 2022 Under review by editor
Apr 23, 2022 Under review by editor

筷子辣椒德芙 2022-04-22

Apr 22, 2022 With Editor

wzb666 2022-04-20

Could you please clarify the meaning of "AGEE" and "送审" in the context of the text?

筷子辣椒德芙 2022-04-20

Apr 19, 2022 - Con el Editor (Spanish) translates to "Apr 19, 2022 - With Editor" in English.

筷子辣椒德芙 2022-04-19

Apr 18, 2022 Submitted to Journal

Translation: The text has been submitted to a journal on April 18, 2022.

小伙伴快来 2022-02-04

The text translates to: "Submission with editor has changed within a week, sent to the editorial board for review, rejected in March, hahaha. Those in the same field can join the group to exchange submission experiences: [Ⅰ]~ [Ⅲ]~ [⑥]~ [five]~ [five]~ [⑥]~ [four]~ [⑤]~ [⑤]."

如梦 2022-01-07

Submitted in September, reviewed the next day, three reviewers for the first review. The first reviewer disappeared, and the second and third reviewers had conflicting opinions. The editor waited for two months for the first reviewer's feedback but did not receive it, so ultimately rejected the submission. The rejection reviewer acknowledged the innovation but criticized the writing quality, which is truly frustrating. Submitted again in October, underwent major revisions in November, returned in two weeks, and submitted for review one week later. The second review was completed in one month, and the acceptance was received the same evening. The speed depends on the editor and reviewers.

笨笨哒 2021-11-23

Submitted on November 16th;
With editor on November 18th
Looking forward to being reviewed.

U 2021-08-22

Already three days have passed and the outcome is still unknown.

邓建强 2021-08-10

Did you subscribe to the agricultural water cycle journal that you submitted?

Tiger的先生 2021-06-03

Jan 06, 2021 Submitted
Jan 07, 2021 With editor
Jan 15, 2021 Under review
Jan 16, 2021 Under review
Feb 25, 2021 Revise
Apr 20, 2021 With editor
Apr 29, 2021 Under review
May 01, 2021 Under review
May 08, 2021 Required reviews completed
May 09, 2021 Decision in process
May 11, 2021 Accept

Translation:
Jan 06, 2021 Submitted
Jan 07, 2021 With editor
Jan 15, 2021 Under review
Jan 16, 2021 Under review
Feb 25, 2021 Revise
Apr 20, 2021 With editor
Apr 29, 2021 Under review
May 01, 2021 Under review
May 08, 2021 Required reviews completed
May 09, 2021 Decision in process
May 11, 2021 Accept

Wei_c 2021-04-25

Oct 10, 2020 Submitted to journal
Oct 12, 2020 With editor
Oct 17, 2020 With editor
Oct 28, 2020 Under Review
Oct 29, 2020 Under Review
Nov 01, 2020 Under Review
Nov 02, 2020 Under Review
Nov 19, 2020 Required Reviews Completed
Nov 21, 2020 Required Reviews Completed
Dec 15, 2020 Decision in Process
Dec 29, 2020 Rejected and Transfer

There were a total of four reviewers, which is quite a few. One of the reviewers mentioned that the journal only publishes articles with actual experimental data and not solely based on models. The editor rejected the article based on this reason. The entire process took approximately three months, with rejection after the review, but a recommendation for submission to another journal of the same level was given, in hopes of a positive outcome.

Create your own webinar

Interested in hosting your own webinar? Check the schedule and propose your idea to the Peeref Content Team.

Create Now

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started