咸鱼突刺 2021-08-12

Gather good karma, everyone can discuss any questions together. Feel free to communicate at 346667980 (disbandment after three months).

咸鱼突刺 2021-08-12

There shouldn't be any specific pattern, so don't worry too much. Keep a positive mood.

tulips1994 2021-08-12

It has been a month and a half since the repair, I am really worried. Is there any pattern to this duration?

192308 2021-08-12

Record the process of accumulating good karma, la la la.

2021.4.30: Manuscript submitted
2021.5.09: Rejected (revised by a native English speaker)
2021.5.15: Manuscript resubmitted after polishing
2021.6.16: Feedback received (revision must be submitted within 21 days)
2021.7.01: Revised manuscript submitted (R1)
2021.7.28: Accepted
2021.8.12: Currently not published yet, undergoing proofreading and payment process.

tulips1994 2021-08-07

The major revision was given a 20-day modification period, while the minor revision has a shorter timeframe.

爱丽丝的姐姐 2021-08-04

I submitted on May 19th and received the review comments on June 24th. Your manuscript **** has been reviewed by the GRSL Editorial Review Board and recommended for publication, pending satisfactory response to the suggested revisions. I returned the revised version on July 10th, and the outcome is still unknown so far.

暴走萝莉熊 2021-08-03

Excuse me, is the opening of the email you received regarding the GRSL review comments reply "Recommended for Publication Subject"?

暴走萝莉熊 2021-08-03

Excuse me, the opening lines of the email reply regarding the review comments for GRSL, are they "Recommended for publication subject"?

爱丽丝的姐姐 2021-08-03

May I ask how you determined it to be a major revision? My first review states "revisions required" without specifying whether it is a major or minor revision. I submitted the revised draft on July 10th, but I haven't received any updates so far.

duang33 2021-08-03

How long does it usually take for the first review, OP?

tulips1994 2021-08-03

It has been more than a month since the major repair, why is there still no news? Is it dangerous to have a slow response?

KrisMing 2021-07-28

The reviewing speed is exceptionally fast!

Sharing the submission timeline:
May 7, 2021: Submitted
June 17, 2021: Revisions suggested
July 7, 2021: Revised (The reviewer requested additional experiments, which I conducted and added directly. The experiments were successful.)
July 27, 2021: Accepted

The speed is indeed impressive!

tulips1994 2021-07-27

Received after one month of major repairs? It's been almost a month since the major repairs, but still no news. It feels a bit slow.

暴走萝莉熊 2021-07-19

What direction are you pursuing?

一气三清 2021-07-19

2021.03.16 submission;
2021.04.27 feedback received, revisions suggested.
2021.05.13 revised;
2021.06.12 feedback received, minor revisions suggested.
2021.06.29 revised;
2021.07.19 accepted.
Before the new year, I was rejected by TGRS after two months, so I submitted to GRSL.
(1) There were two reviewers, one of whom was an expert in TGRS. They raised two questions, and I explained them in several pages. After making the revisions, they directly congratulated me.
(2) The second expert was very meticulous. In the first round of revisions, I missed one issue because I couldn't find similar references. Then, in the second round, they provided me with a list of relevant literature, including specific formula numbers. The paper was initially submitted after proofreading, so there were no grammar issues. After the first round of revisions, there were a few grammar problems pointed out by the expert.
(3) The (associate) editor-in-chief can review. After my revisions, the associate editor added some comments for the expert, but I didn't see the specific suggestions.
A diligent reviewer indeed provides great help to authors. This is something that Chinese people generally seldom do. I hope that in the future, when reviewing papers, everyone can be more serious. After all, writing articles is not easy for anyone, but poorly written articles should be rejected.

duang33 2021-07-15

Has the OP finished now?

ahfeqiweqiwohfeqiwo 2021-07-15

Don't worry about it, some manuscripts take three months for the first review, while others only take one month.

暴走萝莉熊 2021-07-14

Hope so, there is no other way, can only wait~

ohuo 2021-07-14

Definitely coming soon, the review process of grsl is very fast now.

暴走萝莉熊 2021-07-12

It has been over a month since I submitted it, and it has been under review all this time. I have sent two emails to the editor inquiring about the progress of the manuscript, but there has been no response. I don't know if I sent it to the wrong email or what the issue is. I was hoping that getting this article accepted would make my chance of getting a Ph.D. more stable. Have any experts here followed up on manuscripts with this journal before? How should I proceed?

ahfeqiweqiwohfeqiwo 2021-07-10

There is no fixed format for a response letter, just write it yourself and it will be fine.

凤山路齐达内 2021-07-08

No need. Just list the questions and answers clearly.

Alisa123 2021-07-07

Excuse me, everyone, what is the format for a response letter? Is it double-spaced like a research paper, or single-spaced? Thank you, everyone.

Alisa123 2021-07-07

Hello, may I ask what is the format for a response letter? Is it the same format as a research paper, with double spacing? Or is it single spacing? Thank you.

Alisa123 2021-07-07

Hello, may I ask what is the format of a response letter? Is it the same format as a research paper, with double spacing?

tdai05 2021-07-05

May I ask how long it takes for Accept to be published?

Q.W. 2021-06-30

So fast... So sour.

ahfeqiweqiwohfeqiwo 2021-06-30

The speed is very fast. Submitted on 4.14, received feedback for revision on 5.17. Two reviewers provided 14 suggestions. Revised on 5.23 and received minor revisions on 6.23. The revised version was accepted before 8 pm, less than three hours after it was sent back in the afternoon. The speed is as fast as a rocket.

加载中 2021-04-29

How long does the Undergoing Review process take?

摸鱼 2021-04-10

A very good journal, the first review took about two months. The editor found four reviewers, and their questions were very incisive. They gave me 28 days to make major revisions, which felt quite tight on time. I submitted the revised version one month later and it was accepted.