认证评论 - GEOFLUIDS
注: 认证评论选取于全球各个学术评论平台和社交媒体。

goodgood 2022-06-12

The text translates to: "The submission has been showing as 'submitted' for 10 days already, is this normal?"

ruiwang1995 2022-05-29

Special issue submission on March 4, 2022, revision due on April 15, 2022, acceptance on May 5, 2022, and publication on May 28, 2022. Overall, the process was quite fast, and the feedback was also quite fair. As my first paper since starting school, even though it was for an open-access special issue, it still gave me a lot of encouragement.

ASDFASDFSADF 2022-05-18

Excuse me, but I can't see the place to upload the revised manuscript after receiving the feedback from this journal. There is only a stable upload option for replying to the reviewer's comments. Can someone please help me?

辉哥 2022-05-03

Seeking answers from the experts!

辉哥 2022-04-29

My paper was accepted in October 2021. I have inquired with the journal editors several times, and they have always said that the paper is still being processed and produced. However, I have not received any proof or online publication yet. I don't know what's going on. I seek guidance from all the experts!

SCI确实容易呵 2022-04-24

Our journal is good.

小王12106 2022-03-31

The first SCI paper in my life, both the reviewers and the editors were very patient and had a high level of expertise, which greatly improved the quality of the article. Although the journal's impact factor is not particularly high and it is open access (OA), it is suitable for someone like me who is new to scientific research and in a hurry to publish articles for graduation purposes. It is also relatively recognized in the field of geology. Recommended.

987mumu 2022-03-30

Excuse me, is there a Word or PDF version of the format instructions for this journal?

Averyzx666 2022-03-25

Submitted in November of the 21st year, rejected one month later, with the reason being two reviewers requesting revisions and one rejecting the manuscript. The article was then extensively revised based on the previous feedback.
Resubmitted on March 2nd.
Received reviewer comments on March 9th, requiring minor revisions, but there were a lot of suggestions, possibly reviewed by six reviewers because one of them was Reviewer 6.
Returned for revisions on March 22nd, pending approval for two days.
Received acceptance notification on March 24th.
Both rounds of review were conducted promptly. The editor was also very responsible, responding quickly to inquiries, rejections, and acceptance.

wuy 2022-03-04

I feel that the quality of this publication is higher than some third-tier journals. Some reviewers are very serious and their questions are also very pertinent. I estimate that it will be promoted to a third-tier journal next year.

阿拉灯神丁 2021-12-16

The time for publication is 5 months, and the time for returning the review results is less than 2 months.

阿拉灯神丁 2021-12-16

The speed of receiving the first review comments was very fast, less than 40 days. However, after submitting the revised manuscript, a small problem was discovered, so it had to be re-reviewed, which delayed the process for about three months. The communication efficiency with the editor is still very high. I wish Geofluids continued success.
Submission date: July 6th;
Review comments returned on August 13th, minor revisions, with 8 review comments;
Revised manuscript uploaded on August 17th, but the status remained as "Pending Approval" for 2 months;
Email sent on October 27th to inquire about the progress, and the editorial department replied that it was due to the reviewer's affiliation issue, so it was sent for another review;
Second set of review comments received on December 5th, still minor revisions;
Revised manuscript uploaded on December 12th;
Acceptance notice received on December 16th.

心里只有论文 2021-09-29

Bro, how long ago did you last assign an editor?

小小鱼 2021-06-13

I submitted a special issue, but it has been 19 days now and the editor has not been assigned yet. What could be the reason?

无道GG 2021-05-25

20200912 Submission special issue, 20200914 Initial review and revision, 20200919 Guest editor arranges for review, 20200923 Reviewer completes review, 20200925 Awaiting approval, 1011 Guest editor makes decision - revise and resubmit, 20201015 Revised manuscript assigned to AE, 20201019 Assigned to reviewer, 20201020 Reviewer suggests publication, 20201021 Awaiting approval, 20201026 Sent email inquiry, 20201030 Second reviewer contacted me and submitted review comments, 20201031 Acceptance notification, 20201031 Payment of 1650 USD, 20201101 Submission of final manuscript, 20201103 Accepted by publisher, 20201112 Submission of proof, 20201117 Published, 20201225 SCI indexed.

yyuuu 2021-05-06

2020.12.02, Submitted
2021.03.25, Received review comments
2021.04.22, Submitted revised paper
2021.05.04, Accepted
Currently, I have received the acceptance letter and look forward to the next steps. I just hope that it can be completed quickly. Although 5 months is not fast, I can still accept it.

Discover Peeref hubs

Discuss science. Find collaborators. Network.

Join a conversation

Ask a Question. Answer a Question.

Quickly pose questions to the entire community. Debate answers and get clarity on the most important issues facing researchers.

Get Started