飘 2021-07-01

Two reviewers provided their feedback on the paper. One reviewer mentioned that there is a lack of innovation, while the other reviewer was relatively positive and suggested some modifications. The associate editor recommended rejecting the submission.

erhgu8 2021-07-01

How many reviewers? Were their comments not very good, why was it rejected after 20 days of delay? The processing speed of this journal editor is really touching, slowly and leisurely, making people suspect that they only work once a month.

飘 2021-06-29

2021.2.24 Submitted to journal
March 5th, with Editor
March 17th, under review, first round
April 6th, under review, second round
June 6th, Required Reviews Completed
June 8th, Decision in Process
June 28th, Rejected

李囧尼 2021-06-24

After submitting, it has been two months and it hasn't been reviewed by the editor. The responsible editor has been changed from the editor-in-chief Binshan Lin to the deputy editor Karl Andersson. Has anyone encountered this situation before? It's too slow...

Winsun 2021-06-23

I haven't received any news for 9 months... You actually got a decision in just 3 months. I'm envious.

飘 2021-06-17

How long does it take for you to receive the review comments after the first review? It has been three months since my first review, and now it is in the "Decision In process" stage. How long does it usually take to get results at this stage? Thank you very much!

心想事成 2021-06-16

It feels like it's going to be a failure. The first two experts have no opinions, and the third expert asked a bunch of questions... Moreover, he suggested to edit and resubmit.

入坑 2021-06-16

It has been 50 days since submission, and the associate editor has not reviewed it yet.

heyige 2021-06-11

The first trial took four months, and the second trial has been ongoing for five months with no results yet... It's too slow.

Fighting_z 2021-06-10

May I ask how long will the "with editor" status last?

Fighting_z 2021-06-10

May I ask how long it took for you to edit and reply to the message about your thesis?

accept 2021-06-09

My application is in the third review stage and it has been 40 days already.

飘 2021-06-08

I would like to ask if you have encountered "Decision in process" during your first trial? How long does the first trial usually take?

飘 2021-06-08

I would like to ask if there is a "Decision in Process" during your first review? My application has now transitioned to this status. How long does this process typically take?

888y888 2021-06-08

Has Chief Editor Lin been busy recently since the decision was made over a month ago?

小白白2021 2021-06-07

After the third review, it has been a month since the decision in process, and there is still no news. Are there any similar colleagues? I don't know if I should send an email to ask the editor.

小白白2021 2021-06-05

Congratulations, I'm so envious. Mine has also been under review for almost a month. I really hope mine can also have a good result soon.

ddtenvelope 2021-06-05

I went through both the first and second review fairly quickly, but I had to wait for almost a month during the decision stage of the third review. The second review took about 3 weeks.

CCc666 2021-06-05

How long does it take for the elder brother to give his opinion on the second trial?

ddtenvelope 2021-06-05

Just asked a question on letpub in the morning, and shortly after received a notification of acceptance. I guess the editor-in-chief must have returned from vacation. ESWA journal is great, will submit more good articles in the future.

NookLook 2021-06-05

Do you know how fast this editor handles submissions?

小白白2021 2021-06-05

Is three months such a long time? Haven't you sent a message to ask?

ddtenvelope 2021-06-05

The final decision has been pending for almost a month. Why is the editor taking so long to make a decision... It's causing anxiety while waiting.

jacen2021 2021-06-03

Artificial Intelligence. Submitted on 30th January 2021, received reviewer comments on 9th May, replied to reviewer comments on 31st May. Currently under review.

CCc666 2021-06-02

My first trial took 12 months to come back... It has already been almost four months since the second trial returned in February. I have been struggling with a paper for nearly a year and a half, and I have no idea what the outcome will be.

小白白2021 2021-06-02

It has been such a long time, I feel like there should be results soon. If there is any news, please share it in a timely manner~

心想事成 2021-06-02

It's almost two months in just one week... Such a touching speed!

小白白2021 2021-06-01

Which round of review are you on? I have been in the "decision in process" state for a month now, after the third review.

accept 2021-05-31

We are the same, dare not rush, afraid of being rejected immediately after rushing.

心想事成 2021-05-28

No, it has been a month and a half already... The teacher said they dare not rush it.