wzb666 2022-07-26

How long does it take for this journal to be reviewed?

jdhuang 2022-07-20

Submitted on 7.19, it was under review the same day. Is this how this journal usually operates? Can any experts share their experiences? Has it been sent for review or not?

爱种水稻的小林 2022-06-19

Returning one month after major revisions, all the suggestions mentioned last time have been modified. The reviewer has provided three separate opinions. Although they are not particularly difficult to implement, they still require significant revisions. I must admit that I am having trouble understanding the editing process.

番茄吃吐了 2022-06-17

The paper submitted in April was reviewed in May, and it took one month for the review. The review comments included both minor revisions and major revisions, and overall, the paper was rejected. The review comments for the major revisions were quite amusing, as if they were taken out of context. The reviewer had a limited understanding of the research direction and the instrumentation used in the paper, leading to many scientific doubts. The review comments for the minor revisions were more objective but lacked descriptions related to agronomy. The reviewer provided reasonable critiques for the shortcomings of the article.

爱种水稻的小林 2022-05-09

One reviewer rejected it, while another reviewer suggested major revisions. However, considering the overall feedback, the editor decided to go with the major revisions, which turned out quite well. The only downside is that this journal is a bit slow. Will the process speed up after the revisions are returned?

BinCheng 2022-04-19

2022.4.15 Required reviews complete - This means that all necessary reviews have been finished as of April 15, 2022.

2022.4.19 Decision in Process - This indicates that a decision is currently being made or processed as of April 19, 2022.

BinCheng 2022-04-15

2022.4.15 Required Reviews Completed translates to "Required Reviews Completed on April 15, 2022."

爱种水稻的小林 2022-03-24

The first trial took 6 months, so long. It's already been 2 months for me. Can I send an email to remind them?

BinCheng 2022-01-09

The text translates to: "On January 5, 2022, the editor returned with moderate revisions, but the reviewer gave major revisions."

稻子JX 2022-01-06

May I ask if there is any news about the thesis?

BinCheng 2021-08-17

Submitted on June 2, 2021, still under external review, no news at all, the review process is too slow.

wudixiaofu 2021-05-27

Submitted on March 10th, the first review came back on May 27th, which is still relatively fast. They provided a moderate revision.