baiyang2000 2023-02-05

This editor is slow. The first review was all approved, but there has been no news for more than two months after the second review for revisions. It has been over half a year since submission, and I am mentally exhausted.

ChaiFF 2023-02-05

Raskin urged, but did not reply.

Tomas 2023-02-02

Who is your editor? Can you remind them?

ChaiFF 2023-02-02

I have looked around, why is it still over a month? It has been 4 and a half months, mine is still in the first trial, and there is still no news. Burst into tears...

惊鸿伊现 2023-01-31

2022.02.15 With editor
2022.04.05 Decision--resubmitted (two reviewers major revisions, one resubmission, editor gave 6 months)
2022.08.10 Resubmitted
2022.09.17 Major Revision (two reviewers minor revisions, one reviewer major revision, editor gave major revision)
2022.10.20 With editor
2022.11.07 Minor Revision (two reviewers accepted, one reviewer minor revision, editor gave minor revision)
2022.11.29 Accept
The editors and reviewers at EST are indeed very diligent!

zhuyinong 2023-01-30

The guidelines for submission are no longer available, but recently after I submitted, it was rejected. They told me that images are counted as words, so they asked me to shorten it.

zhouzijun 2023-01-27

2022.10.19 submitted
2022.11.31 major revision (3 reviewers, three minor revisions)
2023.12.16 resubmit
2023.1.27 accept

Enlighten_qm 2023-01-20

I couldn't find it either, does this mean that pictures don't count towards the word count?

baiyang2000 2023-01-19

The first review is almost 4 months, all reviewers agree, but there is no news after the second review for 7 weeks.

vincentlavida 2023-01-17

It has been two months since the second trial... I have already urged once but there is still no progress.

加油Y 2023-01-09

Has anyone submitted to EST LETTERS before? I have been assigned as the editor for over a week now, and I thought this journal was supposed to be fast.

加油Y 2023-01-09

I have already received it, thank you.

Epi-man 2023-01-04

I just came back from repair, and you repaired it too quickly...

加油Y 2023-01-02

Excuse me, have you won the lottery? Mine is a major overhaul, but I have two minor repairs, one rejection, and the second review has been pending for 20 days now.

加油Y 2023-01-02

Excuse me, have you been selected? Mine is major renovation, but it consists of two minor repairs, one rejection, and the second review has been almost 20 days.

Dhk 2022-12-29

Doesn't DFT mean manuscript?

keyan 2022-12-22

I submitted it for several days and it was assigned to the associate editor Greg Lowry, who gave such comments. It scared me. The key is that I didn't do DFT. I quickly checked, and there was no mention of DFT or anything similar in the entire article!!!

大砻坊人 2022-12-12

I would like to ask everyone if the latest submission guidelines of EST have canceled the requirement of converting the number of pictures into words.

Epi-man 2022-12-11

Thank you~~ 3 reviewers

加油Y 2022-12-09

Congratulations, how many reviewers are there?

加油Y 2022-12-02

There is news, let me know, ha ?

打野的跟上啊 2022-12-02

Dude, the review process for your article has taken three years.

Epi-man 2022-12-01

It looks very familiar....

Epi-man 2022-12-01

Will the status of the journal's review comments change?

加油Y 2022-11-30

Okay, I don't know how this editor is doing.

Epi-man 2022-11-30

No news, in peer review...

加油Y 2022-11-24

We both submitted on the same day, to the same editor. Have you received any updates on yours?

fan88888 2022-11-22

I submitted it on October 4th and it has been under review since then. It seems that this magazine has been slow recently.

科研菜鸟 2022-11-19

It has been 5 days since submission, and the editor has not been assigned yet. Isn't this speed a bit unusual...

manggo 2022-11-19

No results yet, this is really awkward, right? It's been almost two months since you submitted for review, huh?