哈哈哈1992 2022-11-27

This situation is asking you to switch to other situations.

隔壁小刘 2022-11-24

I submitted with the editor 25 days ago, and there is still no news on the external review.

棒棒糖大仙 2022-11-24

After successful submission, it only took a few minutes to be with the editor. So fast!

冲冲冲呀 2022-11-22

It is estimated that there is some problem, or it may be rejected.

冲冲冲呀 2022-11-22

10.19 Submit initial draft
11.07 Receive reviewers' comments (from 2 reviewers)
11.18 Submit revised manuscript
11.22 Acceptance
The speed is indeed very fast and efficient, only one month! Thank you, editor!

励志读博 2022-11-10

How long is the review period?

shangweihe 2022-11-03

8.20 submitted
8.22 with editor
8.24 under review
9.3 required reviews completed (5 reviewers)
9.9 submitted
9.10 with editor
9.16 accepted

隔壁小刘 2022-11-01

Day 22, finally under review. Hoping for a major revision. Fingers crossed, really need this article.

luyuan1994 2022-10-31

Hello classmate, mine was submitted for review early this morning. How about yours?

luyuan1994 2022-10-28

I have sent you my contact information. Let's find some time to communicate.

隔壁小刘 2022-10-28

Just like you, it has been 20 days and it is still in the hands of the editor. It feels uncomfortable. The boss won't let me rush and I have to wait.

luyuan1994 2022-10-28

I submitted on the 9th, had it with the editor on the 11th, and still haven't received any updates. Classmate, have you received any updates on yours?

断桥残雪雪无延 2022-10-26

Boss, I'm planning to submit to this journal. I want to ask if there is an option to select a specific editor when submitting the manuscript?

西部科研小虫 2022-10-25

What is the result? I submitted my application two days ago, and it is already showing "decision in process" without being reviewed.

隔壁小刘 2022-10-23

It has been fourteen days, why is it still in the hands of the editor? I am anxious to graduate, sir.

tans_ 2022-10-21

10.4 submit
10.21 under review
Waiting for news

隔壁小刘 2022-10-21

It has been eleven days. Are you still with the editor? Why? Didn't they say it would be fast?

思路不清晰加点石墨烯 2022-10-18

10.16 Revise

汪金鹏 2022-10-16

9.9 Submitted
9.17 Under Review
Approximately one week later, Required Reviews Completed
10.1 Revise Four reviewers, all positive feedback.
10.8 Revision Submitted
10.10 With Editor
10.12 Under Review
10.13 Required Reviews Completed
10.15 Decision in process
10.16 Revise
10.18 Revision Submitted
10.19 With Editor
10.21 Decision in Process
10.23 Revise
10.31 Revision Submitted
11.1 With Editor
11.2 Decision in Process
11.3 Accepted
Thank you, editor!

稳稳的 2022-10-14

Received at Editorial Office: 25 Apr 2022
Article revised: 11 Sep 2022
Article accepted for publication: 12 Oct 2022

I don't know if anyone else has had a similar experience. It took almost half a year for the review process, and surprisingly, there were five rounds of revisions with a total of three reviewers. One of them kept rejecting it and consistently asked basic questions about the model (as if they didn't understand the model at all). I asked the editor if all three reviewers had to approve it before it could be accepted. I thought it would be secure after two rounds, but in the fourth round, another reviewer rejected it as well, stating that they needed research from multiple cities instead of just one. I was really frustrated and couldn't take it anymore, so I wrote a long argumentative letter to the editor, expressing my dissatisfaction with the lack of respect for my hard work and questioning the reviewers' backgrounds and potential conflicts of interest. I basically wanted to make a point even if it meant "dying with dignity." However, the editor unexpectedly retracted the rejection and asked for revisions for the fifth round. The two reviewers who rejected it didn't continue reviewing or provide any feedback, while the other reviewer agreed to accept it. There were delays and a month later, based on the previous review comments, only one reviewer uploaded their feedback, which was positive. The other two reviewers didn't provide any feedback, but the article was accepted. I wanted to share this story to encourage everyone not to give up until the very end and hope that all your hard work will be accepted.

稳稳的 2022-10-14

Received at Editorial Office: 25 Apr 2022
Article revised: 11 Sep 2022
Article accepted for publication: 12 Oct 2022

I don't know if anyone else has experienced the same difficulties. It took almost half a year for the article to be reviewed, and there were a total of five rounds of revisions with three peer reviewers. One of the reviewers consistently rejected it and constantly asked basic questions about the model (the kind you wouldn't even know about modeling). I asked the editor if all three reviewers had to approve it for acceptance. I thought it was stable after the second round, but to my surprise, another reviewer rejected it in the fourth round, stating that research from multiple cities was needed, not just one. I was really devastated, so I wrote a long argumentative letter to the editor, expressing my frustration about the lack of respect for my work, questioning the reviewers' expertise, and demanding that they declare any potential conflicts of interest. I basically wanted to go down fighting. However, the editor unexpectedly withdrew the rejection and asked for revisions for the fifth round. The two reviewers who rejected it refused to continue reviewing or submitting their opinions, while the other reviewer still agreed to accept it. It was a series of delays, and one month later, based on the feedback from the previous round, only one reviewer uploaded their opinion, which was in favor of acceptance. The other two reviewers did not submit their opinions. I wanted to share this story to encourage everyone not to give up until the last moment and to hope that everyone's work can be accepted.

伍豪120 2022-10-13

Boss, my submission has passed. I haven't received any automatic reply emails. I'm really confused. I beg for an explanation from the expert.

伍豪120 2022-10-13

Boss, can you help me clarify something? I didn't even receive an automated reply email after submitting my application, and I didn't receive any initial draft number or anything. I haven't heard anything back after submitting. I'm completely confused. I beg you to enlighten me.

森大影 2022-10-10

I also waited for almost half a year before daring to remind for the first time.

Mcflyy 2022-10-06

Hello, may I ask how your article is coming along the day after tomorrow? I also submitted my contribution to DIP a day ago, and I'm not sure about the situation.

学术彩鸡 2022-09-26

I submitted it at the end of June, and it is still under review until now. I dare not rush them, so I can only wait patiently.

嘎嘎呱 2022-09-16

The reviewing process was very fast, and both the editor and the reviewer were very responsible. Thank you very much!

呵呵哒 2022-09-15

2022.07.11 submitted
2022.0714 with editor
2022.07.16 under review
2022.08.12 required reviews completed
2022.08.12 decision in process
2022.08.13 minor revision
2022.08.16 with editor
2022.08.18 under review
2022.08.25 accept
Thank you to the editor and reviewers, the process was very fast.

森大影 2022-09-02

Currently, non-OA is the main focus. When submitting, you can choose it yourself. Non-OA does not have any fees.

geottm 2022-08-27

Hello senior, I would like to ask if this journal charges any fees.