yanglq 2023-07-02

Comparatively lucky, no rejection letter.

aaas，truth 2023-06-30

I want to ask if any of the six reviewers rejected it.

Veronica 2023-06-16

How is dual communication solved? Thank you.

bloomying 2023-06-16

Which editor are you? I've been with an editor for a week already.

24March 2023-06-16

The above issues have been resolved.
Submitted on the afternoon of June 15th, directly rejected on the morning of June 16th, with roughly three reasons. The volume of submissions was too large to be reviewed, the articles lacked innovation, and the topic exceeded the scope of the publication's research.

24March 2023-06-14

Do any experienced professionals know how to select dual communication for ER?

bloomying 2023-06-12

May I ask who the chief editor is and how many reviewers there are?

bloomying 2023-06-12

2023.6.09 submitted to journal
2023.6.09 with editor
2023.6.11 with editor
2023.6.20 Under Review

Translated to English:
2023.6.09 submitted to journal
2023.6.09 with editor
2023.6.11 with editor
2023.6.20 Under Review

我会发光耶 2023-06-12

2023.04.17 submitted
2023.04.17 under review
2023.05.09 decision in process
2023.05.09 revision
2023.05.29 revision submitted
2023.05.30 under review
2023.06.11 accept
The editors and reviewers were very efficient. It was a nice submission process.

是小陈呀 2023-06-12

2023.04.19, Submitted
2023.04.20, With Editor
2023.04.22, With Editor
2023.04.26, Under Review
2023.05.25, Decision in process
2023.05.26, Revise
2023.05.31, Revision Submitted to Journal
2023.6.1, With Editor
2023.6.8, Decision in process
2023.6.9, Accept
Thank you kind editor and reviewer.

bloomying 2023-06-07

Which editor are you, and how many reviewers are there?

bloomying 2023-06-06

2023.6.09 Submitted to Journal
2023.6.09 With editor
2023.6.11 With editor

yanglq 2023-06-03

Overall, the submission experience was pleasant. This was my first time submitting to this magazine, and I would like to share the process:

2023.02.28 - Submitted
2023.03.04 - Under review
2023.04.22 - Major revision (6 reviewers, 40+ review comments)
2023.05.11 - Revision submitted
2023.05.13 - Under review
2023.05.25 - Required reviews completed
2023.05.31 - Accepted

文博 2023-05-26

I just received the received email today. There were two reviewers in total. It was not easy to make the changes, but I carefully revised it. The other party accepted our modifications. The editor is Wang Aijie, who is beautiful and kind-hearted.

加油鸭 2023-05-25

Invited reviewers on May 14th.
No reviewer accepted the review on May 25th.

bloomying 2023-05-18

Wang Dada, the chief editor of Harbin Institute of Technology, handles revisions very quickly.
2023.5.18 submitted to journal
2023.5.18 with editor
2023.5.22 with editor
2023.5.24 under review
2023.6.07 required reviews completed
2023.6.10 revise (3 reviewers)
2023.6.12 revision submitted to journal
2023.6.12 with editor
2023.6.16 under review
2023.6.21 decision in process
2023.6.22 revise
2023.6.29 revision submitted to journal
2023.6.29 with editor
2023.7.02 decision in progress
2023.7.02 accepted

bloomying 2023-05-18

Thank you, Mr. Wang, for giving me the opportunity to make modifications. In the future, I will vote for kind-hearted Mr. Wang every year in the selection of academicians.

bloomying 2023-05-18

May I ask which editor are you assigned to?

bloomying 2023-05-18

May I ask which editor are you? Your efficiency is so high.

落叶知秋 2023-05-18

Submission Experience:
2023.03.06 Received
2023.04.26 Revised
2023.05.12 Online

Suzy1920 2023-05-15

Excuse me, are there many reviewers and their suggestions for revision?

文博 2023-05-15

Today, comments for revision have already been given.

Suzy1920 2023-05-09

Is there any progress in the follow-up?

文博 2023-04-27

It took twenty days, and finally the external audit was completed.

keyanhaoo 2023-04-26

May I ask what are the word count and icon requirements?

文博 2023-04-25

I submitted the manuscript on April 5th, and it is still with the editor today. Is this speed normal? In 2020, I experienced a similar situation, but I don't recall it being this slow.

Wa. 2023-04-22

Hello, may I ask if this journal allows authors to choose whether to make their submission open access or decide whether to make it open access after acceptance?

GYC202202 2023-04-19

Does one reviewer's editing decision determine everything?

GYC202202 2023-04-19

Invited 2+ reviewers, but only one reviewer accepted and submitted the review. Unsure if the editor will handle it. ??????? Looking forward to it.

陈园润 2023-04-09

Where can I see the return time? It's not mentioned in the email the editor sent me.