认证评论 - Ecological Indicators
注: 认证评论选取于全球各个学术评论平台和社交媒体。

伪装 2022-10-25

The layout fee is 2600 US dollars, equivalent to 18990 RMB.

伪装 2022-10-25

It has become open source, with 140 articles published every month. In one year, it will surpass 1500 articles, following the Hindawi model. If we continue with such openness, we will soon decline...

hkwhkwhkw 2022-10-25

I also only have one reviewer, may I ask if there will be any other reviewers after the first revision?

yonggan 2022-10-25

I only received one reviewer's feedback. Reviewer #2's feedback is blank. Could it be that the editor forgot to copy it, or is there only one feedback?

白衣大虾 2022-10-24

10.21 接收 translates to "10.21 Reception" in English.

amirhamza 2022-10-21

Hello, I would like to ask how to write the list of changes required by the midterm journal. Do I need to write a reply letter to each external reviewer? Can you share your experience? Thank you. Sorry to trouble you.

amirhamza 2022-10-21

Hello, I would like to ask how to write the "list of changes" required by the mid-term journal. Do I need to reply to each external reviewer as well? Can you please share your experience? Thank you for your help.

白衣大虾 2022-10-20

09.07 Submission
09.12 Resubmitted after modifying and editing suggestions
10.02 Revise
10.12 Resubmitted after revision
10.18 Revise (minor)
10.19 Resubmitted after revision

xiaoxiaodesuxin 2022-10-20

How should I fill out the invoice information?

文森特 2022-10-20

Ecological Indicators submission on hot environmental-related achievements
Feedback from two reviewers received within one month, prompt and professional opinions
Initial Date Submitted: Sep 18, 2022
With editor: Sep 19, 2022
Under Review: Sep 20, 2022
Required Reviews Completed: Oct 17, 2022
Revision: Oct 18, 2022

花落不沾衣 2022-10-15

Record:
Jul 25, 2022 - Submitted to the journal
Jul 28, 2022 - With editor
Aug 02, 2022 - Under review
Aug 17, 2022 - Required reviews completed
Aug 24, 2022 - Revise
Sep 22, 2022 - Returned to the revised manuscript
Sep 25, 2022 - Under review
Sep 27, 2022 - Required reviews completed
Oct 05, 2022 - Revise
Oct 12, 2022 - Returned to the revised manuscript
Oct 14, 2022 - Accepted

lanqijun 2022-10-14

2022-10-14 under review - This means that something is currently being examined or evaluated on October 14, 2022.

Gaven 2022-10-13

Hello, will you send an email notification to the corresponding author when sending it for external review?

mencci 2022-10-12

Submission: 2022.8.12
Review: 2022.8.17
Feedback: 2022.9.12
Revision: 2022.9.24
Feedback: 2022.10.6
Revision: 2022.10.9
Accept: 2022.10.12

lft 2022-10-11

Is this a revised draft? However, try marking the revised parts in red.

amirhamza 2022-10-10

Hello, I would like to ask: how should I mark the modified content when making revisions? Can you share your experiences?

青菜 2022-10-07

The review speed is not slow, regardless of the size of the revisions. Accepted after two rounds of revisions. The first review was conducted by two experts, one domestic and one foreign (based on the reviewer's comments). The domestic expert had positive opinions, while the foreign expert could only provide non-negative feedback... In the second review, an additional reviewer was added, who acknowledged my work but mentioned that the innovation significance was limited and remained neutral. Accepted after the second revision within two days. Thanks to Editor Fu-Liu Xu for his dedication. By the way, why did my senior sister find five reviewers after submitting? Is it easy to find experts in the field of lake gas?

QiQ2 2022-10-07

In the submission system, there is a link to send an email to the editor. Clicking on it allows you to send an email.

lanqijun 2022-10-07

2022-10-6 under review translates to "October 6, 2022, under review" in English.

lanqijun 2022-10-07

Just fill in the number of words in your Word document, I don't think a regular research paper can exceed 20,000 words. :)

没什么 2022-10-07

Hello, may I ask how many words are required for this submitted manuscript? However, there is a limitation of 20,000 characters. I'm in a hurry, thank you so much.

没什么 2022-10-06

May I ask how to fill in this question when submitting? How many words does your submission contain? (whole text file, including tables and figure captions).

lanqijun 2022-10-05

2022-10-4 under review translates to October 4, 2022, under review.

2431794687 2022-10-04

No, in the end I gave up.

据说昵称可以保护个人隐私 2022-10-03

Sorry, Yonggan bro. I just saw the message. There are two reviewers, and although they don't have many comments, there are a lot of modifications required for each comment. The email didn't mention whether it's a major or minor revision. I also wish you all the best!

据说昵称可以保护个人隐私 2022-10-03

9.27 Return for repair
9.29 Under review
10.3 Required review completed
10.3 Accepted
Thank you to the helpful reviewers! Wishing everyone all the best!

lanqijun 2022-10-03

2022-10-2 under review

lanqijun 2022-10-03

2022-10-2 under review translates to "October 2, 2022 under review" in English.

Andy Lau 2022-10-01

Did you get in touch? Please share.

Andy Lau 2022-10-01

This speed, I envy.

Discover Peeref hubs

Discuss science. Find collaborators. Network.

Join a conversation

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started