madandan123 2023-03-05

2023.1.2 submitted
2023.1.10 under review
2023.1.31 Major revision, 2 reviewers, both found our work highly innovative and provided some modification suggestions
2023.2.19 Revision
2023.2.28 Accept
Thank you to Dr. Brenton Hammer for editing, the processing speed was very fast :), and thanks to the reviewers for recognizing our work!

神经蛙蛙 2023-03-01

It should be sent for review, right? Yours.

ray1 2023-02-28

How long does it usually take for a major repair to be completed and produce results?

让我发个大子刊吧 2023-02-27

Posted on January 21st, sent for review on the 28th, one month has passed and still no news. Praying for good luck!

lau-2020 2023-02-24

It has been over two months since the end of December and there is still no news. Have any of you encountered this situation?

木菇 2023-02-23

From 1.16 until now, there have been 27 submissions; but there has been no news so far... It's a torment, hoping for a good outcome, as scientific research is not easy.

龙龙哥哥 2023-02-21

The feeling of the reviewer rejecting the manuscript is toxic, fortunately the editor likes it.

高处不胜寒啊 2023-02-19

Received on the evening of February 18th.

高处不胜寒啊 2023-02-16

Yesterday afternoon, I gave Xiaoxiu a small revision, there were only three minor issues for the reviewer.

JINTY 2023-02-15

Don't worry, this is normal. It's been less than two weeks for you.

高处不胜寒啊 2023-02-15

Not yet, I'm so anxious. It's still under review.

JINTY 2023-02-15

How are you? Have you come back yet?

Ccccccy 2023-02-14

Posted on October 20 of the 22nd year, underwent major revisions on December 3 with three reviewers. Revised and wrote a 6,000-word response letter on January 3. It was a bit slow after the Spring Festival, but fortunately, it was accepted directly on February 2. The volume of data and new concepts are crucial factors for the journal's decision on whether to submit for review.

高处不胜寒啊 2023-02-09

2.3号返修的

Repaired on the 3rd of February.

JINTY 2023-02-09

How many days has it been since your second trial? Do you know how long second trials usually take?

高处不胜寒啊 2023-02-09

No, the repair is still under review.

JINTY 2023-02-08

Have you received the result of your second review?

高处不胜寒啊 2023-02-03

Are there any major revisions that have been rejected? I'm about to make major revisions and I'm really afraid of being rejected.

海子言 2023-01-31

The submission was rejected after a week, and the editor asked to submit it to another magazine, AMI, which he is the chief editor of. It's so awkward, such an obvious conflict of interest. The editor is Jolke Perelaer.

LIULIUHU 2023-01-30

2022.11.26 submit - Submitted on November 26, 2022.
2022.1.2 major revision - Major revision required on January 2, 2022.
2022.1.21 resubmit - Resubmitted on January 21, 2022.
2022.1.26 recommended for publication - Recommended for publication on January 26, 2022.
2022.1.29 accepted - Accepted on January 29, 2022.

逍遥君君 2023-01-13

2022.11.15 Submission
2022.12.20 Minor revisions, both reviewers suggested 15% changes, editor requires one week to respond with revision suggestions, request for extension
2023.01.12 Completed experiments, submitted revised manuscript
2023.01.13 Accepted

HenryHu99 2023-01-06

Oct 28, 2022 manuscript submitted
Oct 29, 2022 with editor
Nov 1, 2022 under review

It has been over two months now and it's still under review. Does anyone know what's going on? Should I send an email to inquire? It's possible that it has been delayed due to various year-end holidays.

W-Chen 2022-12-23

After my second submission, it changed to "under review". Two weeks later, it changed to "required reviews completed". May I ask how long it will take for the final "required reviews completed"?

Xujiawang 2022-12-08

September 20th - Submission
September 25th - Review
October 21st - First review, acceptance, rejection, major revision. It is evident that the editor has a preference and has given a major revision, resulting in significant changes!
November 8th - Resubmission for review
November 23rd - Minor revision. Consensus is that it has a lot of potential and is recommended for publication, but there is a small issue that needs clarification.
November 31st - Return, waiting for further polishing.
December 5th - Accepted directly.

小兵欧里 2022-12-06

How is it? Have you received the comments on the manuscript?

Oliver_power 2022-11-28

11.21 manuscript submitted
11.26 with editor
11.28 under review
12.12 Transfer Offer to Laser & Photonics Reviews
01.13 Accepted

阳光洒落 2022-11-25

Still reviewing, a bit slow.

攀登永无止境 2022-11-22

My submission was on November 1st, with editor on the 8th and currently under review.

cyanine 2022-11-22

Brother, has the article been accepted?

cyanine 2022-11-22

So embarrassing, I actually meant to reply to the comment of the senior member at 152nd floor, but instead ended up making a separate comment.