Jay 2023-05-08

Why is my submission for 4.19 still "with editor" while yours is so fast? Do I not have a peer reviewer, is that the reason? Frustrated and in urgent need of publishing my article, yet it's stuck like this, refusing to move.

一叶周周 2023-05-08

May 07, Manuscript Submitted
First time submission, good luck!

Jay 2023-05-05

How is it going now? I also submitted mine on April 19th and it has been "with editor" all this time. It's a waste of other people's time to neither accept nor reject it.

江江Jiang酱 2023-04-28

May I ask if "under review" means the submission stage? Will the communication author receive an email during the review process?

玉竹南笙 2023-04-27

Share a fresh and exciting experience of submitting an AFM paper.
23.1.5, submitted to AM.
23.2.16, received reviewer comments: minor revision, major revision, rejection. Editor gave a reject.
23.2.27, submitted appealing letter.
23.2.28, appealing letter rejected.
23.3.5, submitted AFM.
23.3.9, editor mentioned seeing AM reviewer comments, asked for major revision, replied to AM reviewer's comments.
23.3.27, submitted revised manuscript.
23.4.4, accepted.
23.4.13, proofreading.
23.4.25, online publication.
In summary, everything went smoothly.
AM was close, unfortunately, very unfortunate.
If it weren't for the urgency to graduate, I would definitely try AM again.

同志仍需努力 2023-04-23

Do you have any news, my friend?

保护下个人隐私 2023-04-19

Anxiously waiting... The processing speed is ridiculously slow, and all the time has been stolen.

月出皎兮 2023-04-19

3.25 submitted
3.27 under review
4.6 minor revision
4.11 resubmitted
Currently accepted

同志仍需努力 2023-04-18

Let's encourage each other a little.

大哥伟哥 2023-04-17

I am under review on 2.20, and also haven't returned yet.

Rouny.Zh 2023-04-17

I submitted on February 19th, and still haven't received any news. I don't know what's going on.

LzTWin312 2023-04-17

After 10 days of submission, it still remains as "submitted." What's going on?

同志仍需努力 2023-04-17

On April 17th, it is still under review. It has been over a month since March 16th when it was under review. We are anxiously waiting. Taking a deep breath and hoping for good luck from everyone.

努力努力发Paper 2023-04-17

4.11 Manuscript Submitted: The manuscript has been submitted.
4.17 仍然Manuscript Submitted: The manuscript is still submitted.

西湖醋鲈鱼 2023-04-17

I hope good luck.

保护下个人隐私 2023-04-15

I found that foreign journals really take weekends off and do not work. Submissions made on Thursday and Friday will only be processed next Monday. It's so agonizing...

Sophiezx 2023-04-15

I have also been with editor for 12 days.

西湖醋鲈鱼 2023-04-15

Posted on 3.23, with editor on 3.24, and still with editor as of 4.15... Has anyone encountered a similar situation? What is going on?

Jiangbaba 2023-04-12

Has the result come out?

Jiangbaba 2023-04-12

2022.11.20 Submitted.
2022.11.21 Under review.
2023.1.25 Received first-round comments, 2 minor revisions approved, 2 major revisions required.
2023.3.20 Revised.
2023.3.21 Under review.
2023.4.12 No results yet, feels very slow!

niliu 2023-04-11

Rest assured and wait patiently, there will be a good outcome.

一叶知秋 2023-04-11

3.29 submitted
3.30 with editor
4.3 under review
No news yet.

niliu 2023-04-11

2023.3.20 revised manuscript submitted
Due to busy schedule, the return for revision is delayed by one week.
2023.3.29 under review
2023.4.11 accept
Also, good luck to everyone~

拜拜雪饼 2023-04-10

2023.04.06 Manuscript submitted
There has been no movement for four days now.
How many days until it reaches the editor's hands?

同志仍需努力 2023-04-07

March 12th - submitted
March 14th - with editor
March 15th - under review
Until now - under review
Currently, it has been 21 days since submission. Just recording it, hoping for a good outcome.
Previously, I submitted to Science Bulletin but it was not sent for review. AFM editor reviewed it quickly, hoping for a good outcome.

西湖醋鲈鱼 2023-04-06

3.23 submitted
3.24 with editor
Good luck!

sci_888 2023-04-05

How long does it take to review?

sci_888 2023-04-05

May I ask, has it been submitted for review?

大哥伟哥 2023-04-04

Hmm, there is still no news.

Rouny.Zh 2023-04-03

I am under review on February 23rd, and I still haven't received any updates.