类鸟居 2022-03-06

2022.1.10 Submitted
2022.1.26 Received major revision comments from two reviewers, possibly due to the Spring Festival. The editor has given a month to make revisions.
2022.2.25 Submitted revised manuscript
2022.3.06 Accepted

Roy991030 2022-03-06

Already been 24 days, still under consideration, ?

类鸟居 2022-02-28

Returned for three days, hope to receive the acceptance email soon.

sarazqj 2022-02-28

2022.1.28 Submission
No feedback has been received yet.

zhantr1975 2022-02-27

2022.01.24 posted;
Received major revision comments on 2022.02.10, given 10 days for revision;
Revised on 2022.02.20;
Still haven't received any comments yet.

brucewang 2022-02-26

12.11 submitted
1.13 major revision (2 positive reviews, 1 rejection, all comments were very professional. The editor gave one month for major revisions, probably because it coincided with the winter holiday, allowing for more time).
2.18 response R1
2.23 accept
Thank you AFM journal, thank you editor, thank you reviewers for the professional review! Keep up the good work in the future!

xunM 2022-02-24

Is it possible to send the appeal directly to the journal's email address?

xunM 2022-02-24

I also encountered the same situation, and it would be a pity to give up directly. May I ask how you prepared your appeal letter? Could you give me some guidance?

xunM 2022-02-24

Could you please tell me how to prepare an appeal letter? I have encountered a similar situation and would appreciate some guidance.

哦哦哦好吧 2022-02-18

Just submitted, looking forward to review~

advanced soft materials 2022-02-10

Posted on October 10, 2021.
Rejected on October 30, 2021. Two reviewers, one highly praised and one harshly criticized. Editor rejected it.
On January 3, 2021, after serious revisions, decided to appeal, and the next day the editor notified for major revisions.
Accepted directly on January 17, 2021.
If you have confidence in your work, you should still dare to strive for it. Wishing everyone a prosperous Year of the Tiger with many significant papers!

半身浸江，秋水生凉 2022-02-08

I'm really happy! It's my first time in a research career!

597509989 2022-02-06

Posted on December 16th, still no news yet?

下巴都惊掉了 2022-02-05

May I ask if there will be an email notification for the submission review?

半身浸江，秋水生凉 2022-02-04

On the third day of the Lunar New Year, I received the acceptance email from the editorial department, which can be considered as a Spring Festival gift!!

Submitted the initial draft on July 27, 2021.

On October 18, 2021, two reviewers provided feedback, one requested major revisions and the other rejected it, with a total of 13 questions. The editor rejected the submission and I appealed by submitting an appeal letter. The editor then requested major revisions.

Submitted the revised version on November 27, 2021.

On January 8, 2022, two additional reviewers for the appeal process raised a total of 5 questions, all of which were accepted after the revisions.

Submitted the manuscript on January 16, 2022.

On January 19, 2022, a reviewer raised one final question that needed clarification.

Accepted on February 3, 2022.

Wishing everyone good luck in the Year of the Tiger and may you publish many articles!

打老虎 2022-01-31

Hope for a good outcome, praying ?

打老虎 2022-01-31

Submitted on December 5th, 2021.
Significant revisions based on the review comments were made on December 21st, 2021.
Returned with review comments on January 6th, 2022.
Currently, no feedback has been received.

类鸟居 2022-01-31

Amazing, just ten minutes after posting a comment, I received feedback for major revisions.

小千 2022-01-28

It has been so long, it must have been reviewed.

类鸟居 2022-01-26

Already invested for sixteen days, hoping for a good result, praying ?

四夕成 2022-01-22

Posted on December 20, 2021, and still no news.

Cap 2022-01-21

Posted on January 20, 2022.

SuperDan 2022-01-20

Usually, if there is no news for 14 days, it means that it has been sent for review, but there are exceptions too. If the status remains unchanged, it actually means that it is uncertain whether it has been sent for review or not, so we can only wait.

bad man 2022-01-18

Submitted on December 12th, received three months later. AFM has been getting slower and slower. Even when the first review comes back, it's still listed as "under consideration." No need to email the editor, just wait.

guangtaodejia 2022-01-12

It has been 50 days since submission, and there is still no news. I am feeling anxious. Are the reviewers on vacation?

polymer2020 2022-01-12

May I ask if there is any news about your article?

597509989 2022-01-11

Have you received the first-instance opinion yet?

mengguoyun 2022-01-08

Submitted AFM on December 27th, and went through the Christmas and New Year holidays. The current status is "under consideration," but unsure if it has been reviewed yet.

点绛唇_33 2022-01-07

May I ask on what date did you submit it? How long did it take for the review comments to come back? How much time was given for revisions? I am currently awaiting the review comments and feeling anxious. Thank you.

597509989 2022-01-06

May I ask how many days is your first trial?