lajihaochibu 2022-04-14

I would like to ask why, even though I am also in the field of electrochemistry, after a week of submission, my paper is still marked as "with editor" and not "under review".

王嘎 2022-04-14

3.18 Submission
4.4 Major revisions given by the editor, minor revisions by two reviewers
4.11 Responded to reviewer comments
Currently waiting for news
Hoping to receive good news soon

王嘎 2022-04-14

When replying to the review comments, will there be a notification email? The boss said that they replied on the 11th, but I didn't receive any email.

zhanxi 2022-04-14

4.13 Reception
After completing major repairs, another major repair was given upon return. It has now been received.

合肥风投 2022-04-12

Translate the following text into English: 04.12 Stayed up late to finish formatting. Just submitted the application for the visual detection of optical materials in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. Hoping to receive good news before graduation.

黑羽 2022-04-07

What is the "with editor" status before "under review"? Has the status changed while the actual status remains the same?

等待 2022-04-07

What does it mean? Is "under review" still in the hands of the editor?

YIDAOQ 2022-04-07

The current "under review" does not mean it has been submitted for review.

卡门 2022-04-06

Can I consult about the issue of an appeal letter?

lilifefe 2022-04-05

2022.1.14: Submit a review.
2022.2.21: Received comments, require 15 days for major revisions. Three reviewers provided feedback with nearly 100 questions, mainly minor issues. Overall evaluation of the article is good. Request for a 10-day extension.
2022.3.14: Returned.
2022.3.22: Received second round of comments. Two reviewers agreed to accept the article, while one reviewer provided around 10 minor questions and requested additional references. The editor allowed 5 days for revisions.
2022.3.27: Returned.
2022.3.30: Accepted.

黑羽 2022-04-04

So now "under review" means "under consideration", can't you tell if it has been submitted for review? ?
A few days ago, the status of my submission was first "with editor", then "under review", I thought it was already sent for review. ?

zhantr1975 2022-04-01

2022.01.24 Draft;
Received major revision comments on 2022.02.10, from two reviewers, with 10 days given for revisions;
Revised on 2022.02.20;
Accepted directly on 2022.03.31.
Waited for 40 days for the second review, had some concerns during the process, but the outcome was still good. Hopefully, I can publish in AFM again in the future.

曙光 2022-03-30

May I ask where to check the status "under consideration"? Why haven't I had this status all along?

lily-ding 2022-03-29

March 9th submission,
March 19th first-round minor revisions,
March 24th revised,
March 29th directly accepted.
A very nice journal, also wishing the journal to continue to improve.
Thank you, Editor Mary De Vita.

小林 2022-03-29

How long does the status "Revised Manuscript Submitted" typically last after submission?

lily-ding 2022-03-28

Mine too, Xiaoxi returned the next day and became "under review".

王嘎 2022-03-26

Hello, may I ask if there will be an email notification for the submission review? Thank you.
Already submitted. Come and enjoy some good luck.

王嘎 2022-03-26

Already invested, absorb European luck.

Aleck 2022-03-25

Yes, my submission was initially under consideration. After about ten days, I checked and it showed as under review. I'm not sure on which day the status changed to under review.

第三世界 2022-03-25

Is everyone like this? Has anyone not changed? Do you know the reason?

zhanxi 2022-03-25

Submitted on March 6th.
Major revisions on March 16th. Three reviewers (two minor revisions, one rejection).
Revised on March 23rd. Currently waiting for news.

zhantr1975 2022-03-24

Reply to submission experience:
Submitted on January 24, 2022;
Received major revisions comments on February 10, with a given time of 10 days;
Revised on February 20;
Still haven't received any comments now.

Other users' reply:
[lily-ding] Posted on March 15, 2022, 08:54:08
How many reviewers do you have?

lucas_yueng 2022-03-23

Mine too, the major modification suddenly changed back to "under review" after 15 days.

xiongchuanyin 2022-03-23

It seems that it is now under review. I also noticed that it has changed to this status!

金隅 2022-03-22

Is the status not "under consideration" as a whole? Has it changed now?

hbhuang 2022-03-21

My manuscript has been under consideration for one month and 20 days, and surprisingly, its status changed from "under consideration" to "under review". Has anyone else experienced this situation? It's so magical.

lily-ding 2022-03-19

Submitted on March 9th.
Received the first review on March 19th, with three minor revisions.

lily-ding 2022-03-15

How many reviewers do you have, please?

lily-ding 2022-03-11

March 9th submission, come and absorb some European vibes.

憋吭气 2022-03-10

2022.2.4 Submission
2022.2.18 Received major revision comments from three reviewers: one major revision, one minor revision, and one rejection. 10 days to make the revisions.
2022.2.27 Submitted revised manuscript.
2022.3.7 Accepted directly.