kk-k 2023-05-15

5.2 with editor: This refers to a document or version that has been worked on or edited by someone.
5.29 under review: This indicates that a document or version is currently being examined or assessed.

长安PHD05 2023-05-13

Is "handing editor" the chief editor? Have you ever encountered this situation, is it good or bad in the hands of the chief?

幻想时分 2023-05-11

Last time, Chi Sun Poon took 45 days with my things, it seems like everything he handles is very slow...

lcjz 2023-05-11

May I ask which editor is very slow?

李 2023-05-11

I have submitted two articles to this journal and both were accepted very quickly, basically within two months. However, there is one editor in this journal who is very slow. If the article reaches his hands, it takes him a month to decide whether to send it for review. My classmates and I submitted our articles together, and it took him half a year to accept them. Submitting articles is really a matter of luck!

lemonster 2023-05-10

Ah, I also applied in October last year, but the processing only started in February this year. I still haven't received any updates and it's still under review. I'm too scared to follow up, it's really tough.

lcjz 2023-05-10

Uh, which editor handled this?

cfh456789 2023-05-10

May I ask if you have been under review for such a long time?

灰灰 2023-05-10

Don't rush me for the submission. If the topic is not suitable, I have referenced many articles from this journal and saw many similar ones to mine.

Previously, when I submitted to architecture and environment, I received a reply within one day.

灰灰 2023-05-10

Posted on October 27, 2022, the first reminder was sent in February 2023. No response was received. The second reminder was sent in March, and the third reminder in April, but there was still no response. The fourth reminder was sent in May, and finally received a response via email. However, the reply did not match the journal's theme and instead recommended another journal. After waiting for six months, it is advised that those in a hurry to graduate should not submit to this journal as it is unreliable. I will not submit to this journal again.

奔跑的小旺子 2023-05-10

2021-8-22 submitted
2021-10-20 for repair
2021-11-9 resubmitted for repair
2021-11-27 accepted

YAnglv 2023-05-07

May I ask if there is any news about your thesis? Mine has been with RRC for 10 days now, and today they sent another email regarding RRC.

stytt7 2023-05-06

4.27 submit - Submit on April 27th
4.28 with editor - With editor on April 28th
5.6 with editor - With editor on May 6th

长安PHD05 2023-04-28

2023.4.24 The system says that one reviewer has completed the review. However, currently, out of the five invited reviewers, only this one has agreed to review. It is estimated that we will have to wait for a long time.

飞飞0217 2023-04-27

2022.8 With editor: August 2022 with editor
2022.4 Major revision, lasting 7-8 months for first review
Accepted directly within one week after modification

lcjz 2023-04-27

How can I see the edits in the email?

灰灰 2023-04-27

I saw it, it's Scott T. Smith.

Boombayah 2023-04-27

21 DEC 2022 SUBMITTED
21 DEC 2022 WITH EDITOR
22 DEC 2022 UNDER REVIEW
22 JAN 2023 UNDER REVIEW
22 FEB 2023 UNDER REVIEW
12 APR 2023 MINOR REVISION
24 APR 2023 REVISION SUBMITTED TO JOURNAL
25 APR 2023 ACCEPT

The editing process was very fast, and each step was handled promptly. The main delay was caused by the reviewers.

HP_ 2023-04-26

When sending an email to the editor, you can see which editor you have sent the email to.

灰灰 2023-04-26

Where did you see the editor's name? I don't know who my editor is.

HP_ 2023-04-25

Hello, may I ask how long you were with the editor at that time? It's been five days for me and there's still no progress.

HP_ 2023-04-25

Hello, may I ask how long it took with the editor at that time?

HP_ 2023-04-25

Hello, I have been with Editor for five days too. May I ask which handling editor you are?

franthy 2023-04-24

The reminder letter sent by the system, edited by Kim Van Tittelboom, has been processed quickly.

灰灰 2023-04-24

The system has sent two reminders, but there has been no response. It has been six months, and I am considering withdrawing the submission.

幻想时分 2023-04-23

4.23 Finally, it is Under Review, a total of 24 days have passed. Last week, I reminded them once, and it seemed to have had some effect.

长安PHD05 2023-04-21

Is it with the editor or still under review?

灰灰 2023-04-21

Same question, the system email was sent, but no reply. Asville platform was also contacted, and the platform urged the editor, but the editor also ignored it.

灰灰 2023-04-21

It has been six months. The date has not changed. What should I do? How do I withdraw the submission? Does anyone know? Any suggestions?

Fy~ 2023-04-21

麻了 - It's a slang phrase in Chinese and it is difficult to translate directly into English. It is often used to express surprise, shock, or frustration.