AA华蓥山NU 2021-12-20

May I ask how long it usually takes for your with editor? Thank you.

AA华蓥山NU 2021-12-19

It has been one and a half months since submission, and there has been no change with the editor for forty days.

Amiee1111 2021-12-19

Just forgot to share an important thing, which is that I was directly hired after my internship. I personally believe that this stroke of good luck might be attributed to my patient wait throughout the long process. Keep it up!

Amiee1111 2021-12-19

I am an example myself. I submitted on March 14th and received a revision on August 25th. During this period, I received an email from the editorial department notifying me of a change in the reviewing expert, so I waited for almost half a year. My personal suggestion is not to rush.

Amiee1111 2021-12-19

Submission date: 2021.3.14
First retirement date: 2021.8.25
Submission for revision date: 2021.10.23
Accepted after revision date: 2021.12.17

Previously, I have always seen information from others about the process from submission to acceptance. I often come here to take a look, hoping to have some good luck. Finally, I have become a lucky person myself.

IdaWang 2021-12-17

OP, how long have you been waiting for the reviewer?

IdaWang 2021-12-17

It has been four months under review. Should I remind the editor to speed up? I have been hesitating.

AA华蓥山NU 2021-12-16

It has been a month and a half with the editor, so tired.

weAreAllGod 2021-12-16

Submitted Jul 9 2021 9:02AM
Accepted Dec 9 2021 1:47PM
I have come back to express my gratitude. This website has provided a lot of guidance and information, so I would like to contribute some information as well. My first scientific paper also meets the graduation requirements. The journal is excellent. I received feedback after four months of submission, and both reviewers were positive. They gave me two months to make revisions, which I completed in two weeks. Then, it was directly accepted. The overall speed was quite fast.
I hope it continues to improve!

AA华蓥山NU 2021-11-18

May I ask how long did the first round of review with the editor and under review stages take? Thanks.

AA华蓥山NU 2021-11-18

May I ask how long it took for the first round of review with the editor and the "under review" stage to be returned? Thank you!

AA华蓥山NU 2021-11-18

May I ask how long it took for the first round of review with editor and under review stages?

长风有时 2021-11-07

A very good journal, the review process is relatively standard, using a double-blind format. It is still a certain distance away from top-tier journals, but it is not easy for students to have a paper published. The impact factor of the journal has steadily increased in recent years, and it is expected to soon enter the top rankings~

logistics 2021-10-15

The statement upstairs is a bit exaggerated. It is a very good journal for engineering, but only top professors from top universities can publish in it. It is too exaggerated to compare it with NS. However, there is hope to enter the top tier (Zone 1) of journals.

Schafeli 2021-10-14

Why are there so many dislikes? It is originally a top-tier engineering journal, only a place where top-tier scholars from top universities can publish. The requirements for innovation are very high, and generally can reach the level of NS.

Annia 2021-10-02

Hello, this magazine is asking for code sharing. Will it be stolen? I haven't finished writing my thesis yet.

Annia 2021-10-02

Hello, if I request to share my code, will it be stolen? I haven't finished my thesis yet.

学术圈就是个坑 2021-09-14

The journal is pretty good, with double-blind review and rejection of personal relationships. I hope other journals can also adopt double-blind review more frequently. The quality of the articles is good, requiring some level of innovation, but not considered top-tier. It is a high-level journal that is fair and just. It falls a bit short of being a top-tier journal, but there is hope for the future.

啥时候能毕业啊烦死了 2021-09-04

It has been over a month since I submitted it, but it is still with the editor. They are taking too long! Sigh.

论文暴击者 2021-08-22

Is it possible for the journal to be upgraded to Zone 1 (Top journal)?

学术追寻者 2021-08-13

Submitted in October 2020, retired in August 2021!

wdnn 2021-06-08

Nov 11, 2020 - Submitted to Journal
Nov 13, 2020 - With Editor
Nov 26, 2020 - Under Review
May 17, 2021 - Revise
May 31, 2021 - Submitted to Journal
Jun 01, 2021 - With Editor
Jun 07, 2021 - Decision in Process
Jun 07, 2021 - Accept

小白兔白又白 2021-02-23

2020.01.03 Submission
2020.05.07 First review comments returned (two reviewers, major revisions, two months for revision)
2020.07.02 Revised manuscript returned
2020.08.26 Second review comments returned (minor revisions, only one comment)
2020.08.28 Revised manuscript returned
2020.08.31 Accepted