bessage 2021-04-01

One reviewer made direct revisions after modification, while another reviewer had unclear explanations for the innovative points. The rest were minor formatting issues. Finally, it was sent back for the second reviewer to review.

seraphina 2021-04-01

May I ask if you need to go back and make minor revisions, is it the editor who decides whether to accept it directly or does it go back to the reviewer for further review?

bessage 2021-04-01

Posted on 2021-01-05
Feedback received on 2021-03-05 with minor revisions
Returned for modifications on 2021-03-10
Accepted on 2021-03-31
Overall, the speed is good. The development of domestic journals is getting better and better. Keep up the good work.

HEHEDAHAHA 2021-03-14

My submission was almost the same. After submitting, the review process was very quick, and the required review was completed in less than twenty days. But after that, there was no further progress. It has been over two months now and the status hasn't changed. I have sent several emails to the editor, and they said they would notify the relevant personnel to handle the manuscript as soon as possible, but there has been no change so far. I am really frustrated!

149 2021-03-09

This journal's review process is too slow. The first external review took 2 months, and after the editor gave revisions, there has been no progress since the submission with the editor. It has been almost 3 months already. I only need to complete one more paper to graduate, but I have sent 3 emails and the editor has ignored them all. Helpless. How can one support domestic journals like this?

jessie1288 2021-03-02

Posted in April 2020
Received review results in August 2020, minor revisions
Submitted revised version in September 2020
Received acceptance notification on October 10, 2020
Published online on October 29, 2020
On November 8, I made further revisions to the manuscript and returned it

Now it's March 2021... The latest update is: I would like to keep you informed that we are awaiting Editor proof for your article before the final version is published online.

Oh my goodness.

hxchxc 2021-02-26

May I ask, if I publish an article in CJCHe magazine, do I still need to pay publication fees if I don't choose open access?

hxchxc 2021-02-26

Excuse me, OP, when other people mention a page fee of 450 yuan, are they referring to choosing open access? If not chosen, there is no need to pay a page fee for publishing an article in that journal, right? Thank you for answering.

一瓣大西瓜 2021-02-20

Submission process:
2021.01.06 submitted
2021.01.21 minor revision (reviewed by three reviewers, all minor revisions)
2021.01.30 revised
2021.02.04 revision (formatting)
2021.02.10 revision (formatting)
2021.02.19 accepted
This article is about composite materials. Initially, I was very confident that the data was innovative and comprehensive, and I aimed to submit it to a first-tier journal. However, I faced continuous rejections since the manuscript was completed in April 2020. Finally, it was accepted by the Chinese Journal of Chemical Engineering this year, which made me very happy. Moreover, this journal has been upgraded to a second-tier, while the journals that rejected my paper have been downgraded to a third-tier. It can be considered as good luck. The review process was fast, and the questions were not difficult to answer. However, the journal had strict formatting requirements. I had to make two revisions for formatting issues. The figures and tables needed to meet the requirements of Chinese core journals (possibly similar to other domestic journals). If you plan to submit to this journal, please pay attention to the formatting requirements.

一条小鱼 2021-01-16

How much does this layout fee cost?