邓阿喵 2023-03-31

March 30th, under review.

邓阿喵 2023-03-30

March 29th, under review.

邓阿喵 2023-03-30

March 29th, under review.

哈哈lucky 2023-03-29

The final result is good and has been successfully received. The editing is especially good, and the reviewer's comments are also very fair. I hope the journal will continue to improve! Grateful.

Plasticsnow 2023-03-27

2023.3.27 decision in process translates to English as "Decision in process on March 27, 2023."

邓阿喵 2023-03-27

March 8th, submit to journal
March 12th, with editor
March 14th, with editor
March 26th, under review

Plasticsnow 2023-03-21

3.9 submitted
3.12 with editor
3.14 with editor
3.19 with editor

Translation:
3.9 submitted
3.12 with editor
3.14 with editor
3.19 with editor

Iris Zhang 2023-02-27

2019.12.2-Submitted
2020.2.14-Revised
2020.3.19-Accepted

Translated into English:

2019.12.2-Submitted
2020.2.14-Revised
2020.3.19-Accepted

也是头秃的一天 2023-02-25

Feb 22, 2023 With Editor
Feb 25, 2023 Decision in Process
Probably going to be rejected again.

也是头秃的一天 2023-02-22

Excuse me, is this journal fast or not? Did you submit it on February 20th or are you planning to submit it?

论文拾荒者 2023-01-13

Is it still with the editor???

论文拾荒者 2023-01-13

Are you still with the editor?

liranran 2023-01-11

The second review takes about a month, much faster than the first review, but it's still very long... For those who are graduating, it is advised not to invest.

论文拾荒者 2023-01-04

The longer, the better or the shorter, the better.

JLZH 2022-12-30

What's been going on with the editor recently? It's been almost three weeks, I wonder if anyone has encountered a similar situation?

哈哈lucky 2022-12-15

November 25th, submit to journal
November 26th, with editor
December 5th, changed the date, still with editor
Today is already December 15th, still with editor
I hope the editor can expedite the review.

哈哈lucky 2022-12-02

I hope for a good outcome.

Taqiangrentaqiang 2022-11-29

Very good journal, but the impact factor is not high.

求毕业//// 2022-11-29

Hello, I would like to ask how long does it usually take for your second review to be under review?

liranran 2022-11-28

The article was finally accepted after 5 months, I'm happy!!!
I'll share the process for everyone's reference.
It was submitted on 11th June 2022, took more than a week for review. After three months, we finally received the reviewer's comments. We made the necessary revisions and resubmitted it. Two minor revisions were required, and the editor gave us one month to make the changes. In total, we addressed 25 questions, involving experiments, characterization, and calculations. The workload was quite large.
After the revisions, we resubmitted and received a response from only one reviewer after a week. They agreed to accept it. Perhaps the editor couldn't wait any longer and directly accepted it.
I hope everyone has good luck. The review process at CES is truly lengthy, and I don't want to submit again in the future.

wang184 2022-11-05

The time for "under reviewd" is very short, only 10 days. Is it already over?

Jason- 2022-11-02

Original text: 楼主，接你的好运啊。。。

Translation: OP, receive your good luck...

飘荡的叶子 2022-10-30

Posted on August 16, received for minor repairs in the middle, and accepted on October 30. This efficiency is acceptable.

siyu0203 2022-10-08

What happened next, OP?

siyu0203 2022-10-08

Original text: 楼主 同道中人 有消息没

Translation: Original poster, fellow traveler, any news?

荣老湿 2022-09-19

Aug 04, 2022 Submission
Sep 18, 2022 Not yet reviewed DIP
It's a bit slow... for your reference.

vlk 2022-09-09

I have submitted three articles and only two have been accepted. The speed is really slow, it took about six months for each article. Even if it is rejected, it takes the editor a month to get back to me after the review. And even if the reviewers suggest minor revisions, I still have to wait for almost a month for the editor to send it back to me. If I need it urgently for graduation, this is too slow. Also, starting from last year, the journal has dropped from JCR Q1 to Q2. In my personal experience, good journals tend to be faster, although this is not always the case. Some Q1 journals (not all) are indeed much faster, at least they don't keep you waiting for a long time in the hands of the editor.

YYYezt 2022-09-06

Just wanted to ask, how long does it usually take to get results with the editor? If it's not being reviewed, do we still have to wait a long time?

wenkeli 2022-08-15

My every time takes about three to four weeks in "Required Reviews Completed."

liranran 2022-08-11

CES is really slow, it took two months from submission to completion by two reviewers and the manuscript was returned to the editor. Now it's back under review, probably because they are looking for a third reviewer. I have no idea how long this will take... I'm really speechless. If it wasn't for the fact that this journal counts as two publications for a PhD in chemical engineering, I wouldn't submit here. The speed is unbelievably slow.