一个科研小民工 2023-02-17

Okay, brother, thank you!

一个科研小民工 2023-02-17

"Finished reviewing in just four days? That's impressive!"

zherowang 2023-02-16

This is really outrageous how fast you are.

liuhaha 2023-02-16

11.21 Major renovation
12.16 Submission
1.2 Major renovation
1.18 Reception

只高不冷 2023-02-16

SI choice of Guotao's e-component

只高不冷 2023-02-16

The SI option of Guotao is e-component.

只高不冷 2023-02-16

The current Guo Tao is no longer like before. It's not easy to invest in it after it's been upgraded to Zone 1. It's all about luck if you can get it approved.

Tsolmon 2023-02-15

It could also be due to a sharp increase in the number of submissions after being promoted to Zone 1 in December last year. I estimate it won't be easy to get selected in the future.

BOXINYAU 2023-02-14

I am also in the same situation, but I didn't get instantly rejected. I was rejected in the early morning after submitting my application in the afternoon. Brother, are you sure that the rule of only one submission per year for this communication is the latest regulation?

不会迷路的麋鹿 2023-02-13

1. Submit on December 15th, 2022.
2. Revise with two reviewers on January 5th, 2023.
3. Return with modification suggestions on January 19th, 2023.
4. With the editor on January 28th, 2023.
5. Accepted on February 9th, 2023.
6. Online on February 11th, 2023.

斯文野兽 2023-02-10

This article is for graduation purposes, and the whole process went quite smoothly. The editor and reviewers were very responsible and efficient. The entire cycle took exactly one and a half months.

December 26, 2022: Submission
December 27, 2022: The next day it was sent for review, and the editor was Pietro Vincenzini.
January 16, 2023: First round of review comments with two reviewers. The first reviewer made minor revisions, suggesting improvements in language and raising some common knowledge issues. The second reviewer, presumably the major revision, delved deep into the topic and raised many mechanistic questions. It was only after making the changes that I realized the reviewer's expertise and how helpful it was for improving the article and myself. Neither of them requested additional experiments.
February 7, 2023: Revised manuscript and response to comments submitted.
February 9, 2023: Accepted late at night.

The efficiency and speed were high, and the article has been promoted to a higher tier in the latest issue. Once again, I would like to thank the editor and reviewers, and I wish the journal continued success!

一个科研小民工 2023-02-09

How to add supplementary files when submitting a post? The system does not have an upload option for "Supplementary material".

lingzi 2023-02-08

Already submitted for review, the reviewers accepted the request very quickly, less than 12 hours, thumbs up!

lingzi 2023-02-08

Already submitted for review, the reviewer's acceptance speed is very fast, thumbs up.

clover98 2023-02-07

Very anxious, waiting for this graduation thesis, finally I waited for it! It was accepted in just two and a half months, which has the fewest issues with peer review. The acceptance process was fast, and both the editor and reviewers were very efficient. It didn't delay during Christmas, New Year, and Lunar New Year. Everyone worked hard!

11.27: Submitted
Assigned to Editor Hou
12.04: Under review
12.09: Required review completed
12.19-12.25: Under review
12.31: Decision in process and converted to major revision
1.26: Submitted
1.27: Under review
2.2-2.3: Required review completed
2.6: Decision in process and converted to accept!

Guo Tao's speed is as fast as ever. It has already been upgraded to a higher tier. This is great news for ceramic researchers. I hope the journal continues to thrive!

BOXINYAU 2023-02-06

Did you submit it for review today? Is there any editing going on?

lingzi 2023-02-06

It has been almost a week, and it hasn't been reviewed yet. I'm getting a little anxious.

西安王斌的知识产权圈 2023-02-06

Godspeed,
Submitted on January 10th,
Accepted on January 29th,
Directly online on February 3rd.
Currently, the latest version of the Chinese Academy of Sciences has reached the top tier.
Feeling like I hit the jackpot. Currently, there are two more articles being written, to be submitted next month, just need a few more authors.

晋哥铁马 2023-02-02

2.2 13:25 Now it's "decision in process". Finally, there is some news. It should have been reviewed and sent back to the editorial department. The review process took a little over three weeks, which is alright. Let's see if they will give the opportunity for revisions.

晋哥铁马 2023-02-02

2.2 13:25 Now it is Decision in Process, finally there is news.

zpj 2023-02-01

The required reviews for January 27th have been completed. Does anyone know when the results will be available?

帕瓦罗蒂 2023-01-29

Has your "under review" status changed?

晋哥铁马 2023-01-29

It has been almost three weeks and it is still under review. At least when I submitted to OSA, I could see a few reviewers and have some idea about the progress. But now, there is no information at all. It's really frustrating.

JKKK 2023-01-15

May I ask, my current status is "Under Review", where can I see how many reviewers there are? Are they in agreement with the review? How many reviewers does this journal usually have? Please kindly advise.

siojetonlg 2023-01-12

20221218 Submit revise
20221231 Major revision Two reviewers accepted one reviewer discussed 2 issues in detail.
20230104 Submit revise
20230112 Accept (Resubmitted once on 0109 due to a missed revision)

Thanks to editor Pietro Vincenzini for the highly efficient editing and to the reviewers for providing very professional opinions.
Looking forward to obtaining a PhD :) Hope to have the opportunity to continue publishing achievements in national ceramics.

晋哥铁马 2023-01-10

Rare earth doped microcrystalline glass
1.9 23:45 submission
1.10 08:45 under review
It's quite fast. According to the official website, it takes more than a week to reach the reviewer, but I didn't expect it to arrive in the morning when I woke up.

学术0001 2023-01-09

Now it's changed. It seems like a communication can only submit one article per year. My second article was also rejected instantly.

EBC-APS 2022-12-21

2022.11.14 Submission, with editor
2022.11.16 Under review
2022.12.02 Review completed, revise minor changes (three reviewers)
2022.12.04 Resubmitted
2022.12.04 With editor
2022.12.21 Accepted
It was accepted in just over a month. Thanks to the editor-in-chief and associate editor.

Mo12301 2022-12-21

One district has been completed! No losses.

Tsolmon 2022-12-21

12.09 submitted
12.11 with editor
12.14 under review
Surprisingly, Guotao has changed to Zone 1. It just so happens that I got one article accepted this year, and another one is currently under review. What a pleasant surprise!