包尔之金 2022-03-17

Will there be further revisions after the minor repairs are submitted for review?

奎阁高香 2022-03-12

Finally, it is about to be accepted. The submission process took 6 months, and the reviewers provided very good feedback, making the article's viewpoint more distinct. Here is a timeline of this submission:

2021-8-24: Submission
Editor assigned: Almost a month, then under review
2021-11-28: Decision in process
2021-12-22: Feedback from reviewers received
2022-1-13: Revised submitted, with editor
2022-1-17: Editor assigned
2022-2-1: Under review
2022-2-10: Reviewer(s) invited
2022-3-04: Decision in process
2022-3-11: Accepted after minor revisions.

包尔之金 2022-03-09

May I ask what happened to the article later? I also encountered this problem, how should I handle it better?

gyh 2022-03-07

I would like to ask how the result is going. I also applied in December 2021, and the middle two months were under review. Since then, it has been review invited until now.

skli.bnu 2022-03-06

The submission has been 7 months now, during which there was one instance where required reviews were completed but no feedback was given, and it went back to being under review. Now it has become "reviewer invited", and a withdrawal letter was sent two days ago. The editor replied, "I am aware of your concern about your manuscript. I am doing my best to find one more reviewer to gather a final response for you." We still have to wait.

caoxc 2022-02-22

I am currently in the same situation. May I ask the OP about the outcome?

椭圆三向箔 2022-02-07

The previous experts must be re-evaluated, and then the editor will decide whether to add new reviewers based on the modifications made to the article.

菜鸟第六人 2022-02-07

Thank you, the reviewer raised some minor issues, I need to make some small revisions and invite another reviewer, it's really frustrating.

SBSctd 2022-02-07

Based on my experience and the experiences of people around me, anything is possible. It is possible to accept, possibly reevaluate (with the same expert), and also possible to add another reviewer...

菜鸟第六人 2022-02-07

Does Xiaoxiu need to submit for external review?

菜鸟第六人 2022-02-07

Hello, may I ask if this journal requires external review for minor revisions? Should it be sent to the previous reviewers or will new reviewers be added? Thank you.

小伙伴快来 2022-02-04

Submission with editor changed in a week, sent for review on the same day, received major revisions result in three weeks, had a revision meeting in a week, accepted after half a month. Just in time for Christmas, hahaha. Colleagues can join the group to exchange submission experiences: [Ⅰ]~ [Ⅲ]~ [Ⅵ]~ [Ⅴ] ~ [Ⅴ]~ [Ⅵ] ~]four]~ ]⑤]~ [⑤].

miaomiaomiaomiao 2022-01-27

Hello, may I ask which editor you choose?

筷子辣椒德芙 2022-01-25

9 Dec 2022 Submitted to the journal
10 Dec Editor assigned
12 Dec Under Review
24 Jan 2022 Decision in Process

Translation:

9th December 2022 - Submitted to the journal
10th December - Editor assigned
12th December - Under Review
24th January 2022 - Decision in Process

小李子000 2022-01-24

Submitted on September 16th, 21. Under review since October 18th. The status was updated several times during the process. Peer review was completed on January 16th, 22. Major revisions were requested on January 23rd. Two reviewers provided numerous comments, one with 44, and the other with 46 comments. We were given 21 days to address the feedback. This is just an account of the submission experience for reference purposes. The article was rejected initially but fortunately, the editor provided some valuable suggestions.

奎阁高香 2022-01-14

Completed revision on January 13, 2022, with editor.

椭圆三向箔 2022-01-13

2021,08,25 Submission
2021,08,27 Reviews invited
2021,08,29 Under review
2021,09,17 Under review
2021,10,03 Under review
2021,10,17 Major revision
2021,12,04 Revised submitted
2021,12,07 Editor assigned
2021,12,09 Under review
2021,12,26 Minor revision
2022,01,04 Revised submitted
2022,01,08 Under Review
2022,01,12 Accepted

Translation:
2021,08,25 Submission
2021,08,27 Reviews invited
2021,08,29 Under review
2021,09,17 Under review
2021,10,03 Under review
2021,10,17 Major revision
2021,12,04 Revised submitted
2021,12,07 Editor assigned
2021,12,09 Under review
2021,12,26 Minor revision
2022,01,04 Revised submitted
2022,01,08 Under Review
2022,01,12 Accepted

Noah 2022-01-10

Literal translation: "Unable to eat grapes, saying grapes are sour."

Meaning: "One who can't get what they want will often criticize or belittle it."

luandaan 2022-01-09

First submission on October 19, 2021, approximately 35 days for feedback (Chinese editing), return after 1 week, accepted on December 24.

Rengar 2022-01-08

Wherever there are people, there is a world full of ups and downs. Don't lose heart, my dear brother.

如梦 2022-01-07

Submit in October, major revisions in November, return in 2 weeks, review in one week, second review completed in a month, accepted the same evening. The speed depends on the editors and reviewers.

奎阁高香 2021-12-22

Marked, posted on 2021/8/24, and received review comments on 2021/12/22. Major revisions were requested, and a 3-month period was given for the revisions.

DDHJX 2021-12-18

Hello, may I ask how long it will take for the results? I have reached this stage and have been waiting for a week already.

DDHJX 2021-12-18

Hello, may I ask how long will it take for the results to come out? I have reached this stage and have been waiting for a week.

如梦 2021-12-17

Submission is a mystical art, its speed, quality of opinions, and whether it gets accepted are highly correlated with luck. Therefore, it is not a bad thing for researchers to occasionally seek blessings from Buddha!

超人爱唱歌 2021-12-15

The speed is quite fast. The manuscript was submitted to the editor's hands in about three days, and then it was rejected after about three days. It was informed that the article is more suitable for the field of agriculture and does not fit the theme of CATENA. However, looking through the articles previously published in the journal, there are many articles on agricultural management techniques, so I feel that the editor's response is a bit perfunctory, and the reason is also ridiculous. One of our senior classmates has submitted to this journal before, and the first submission was rejected. After choosing to submit again and sending the article to a familiar person, it was accepted in less than two months. Therefore, I seriously doubt the professionalism of this journal. I will not consider it in the future!

筷子辣椒德芙 2021-12-13

Supplement:
9 Dec 2021 - Submitted to the journal
10 Dec 2021 - Editor assigned
12 Dec 2021 - Under review

筷子辣椒德芙 2021-12-10

2021.12.09 Submitted to the journal: This means that a document or article was sent to a journal for consideration or publication on December 9, 2021.

2021.12.10 Editor assigned: This indicates that an editor has been assigned to review or handle the submitted document or article on December 10, 2021.

gyh 2021-12-06

11.17 Submission
11.18 Editor Assigned
11.28 Under Review

Translation:

11.17 Submission
11.18 Editor Assigned
11.28 Under Review

奎阁高香 2021-12-04

Not yet, just one week. I hope there will be fewer opinions, it's okay to be a few days late. [Bitter smile]