难难难 2022-07-28

The feeling is not great. When you all have a result, please update the results. Carbon has always been very fast, and their editors are all part-time employees from various institutions and schools. There is no concept of taking a vacation for them. I'm a bit anxious.

迷途书生 2022-07-28

It has been 8 days with editor.

难难难 2022-07-28

It has been eight days for mine too. Could it be due to other authors not confirming? The submissions before were very quick, with some being reviewed within three days.

难难难 2022-07-28

Remember to update if there are any changes.

lihui_thz 2022-07-28

I suppose the office is on summer vacation, otherwise why are the submissions so slow during this period?

cata123 2022-07-27

It has been 20 days with the editor.

ncuxu 2022-07-26

May I ask what is your number? Mine has been half a month.

alexander94 2022-07-26

July 7 submission
July 8 with editor
July 26 today, still with editor

Is this situation normal? Does it mean the chances of success are low?

小文 2022-07-22

21日online translates to "online on the 21st" in English.

yin1 2022-07-17

How did you know about major repairs and minor repairs? Why didn't mine have any?

小文 2022-07-17

5.30 submit to journal
5.30 with editor
6.7 under review
6.17 required reviews completed
6.20 Review Complete (major review, 2 reviewers, one major revision and one minor revision. Nearly 20 comments)
7.12 with editor. Submit revised manuscript, Under Review the same evening
7.16 Received acceptance email in the evening, Accept
Carbon is very fast, the editor's handling speed is fast, and the review process is also fast.
Here, special tribute to Editor Emilia Morallon, Prof., very efficient.

Peng Jiaxin 2022-07-07

5.1 submitted
5.2 with editor
5.9 under reviewer
6.7 major revision
6.28 resubmitted
7.5 minor revision
7.7 accepted
Nikhil Koratkar has extremely high editing efficiency and did not use recommended reviewers. The reviewer he found himself should be a big name in the industry. The questions raised were very professional and the answers and revisions made the article feel improved. Wishing the journal continued success.

沪上晓风75 2022-07-05

5.18 submitted
5.19 with editor
5.26 under reviewer
6.18 major revision
6.26 resubmitted
6.27 under review
7.4 accepted
Nikhil Koratkar is a very nice editor with high efficiency. I wish the journal continued success.

逍遥小猪猪 2022-07-01

2022.5.27 submitted
2022.5.28 with editor
2022.6.4 under review
2022.6.13 major revision
2022.6.23 R1 submitted
2022.6.24 under review
2022.6.29 accepted
The editor and reviewers were particularly friendly and highly efficient, thank you!

xiayuwanyouxila 2022-06-21

Is this too outrageous of you?

帆... 2022-06-19

2022.5.11 - submitted
2022.5.14 - with editor
2022.5.18 - under review
2022.5.24 - minor revision
2022.6.1 - accepted

晚上打羽毛球 2022-06-16

2022.6.8 Submit
6.16 with editor

TD小菜鸡 2022-06-11

5.15 Major Revision, two reviewers, 14 minor comments.
6.7 Submitted.
6.8 Under review.

animalyao 2022-06-07

Yes, quickly, received.

cucoo 2022-06-04

Does the email about the change of editor notify the new editor? The date of my article with the editor has changed twice.

张临远 2022-05-31

Sometimes the review process can be quite fast.

NJUSTYMZ 2022-05-25

My submission has been under review for two months, I'm dying.....

animalyao 2022-05-24

What does it mean that the first time under review to required reviews completed time is so short? Mine is only 5 days, and I saw yours took 9 days. Is it possible to receive feedback so quickly?

TD小菜鸡 2022-05-10

2022.05.03 Under Review

TD小菜鸡 2022-04-29

2022.03.19 Submitted
2022.03.21 With editor
2022.03.22 Under review
2022.03.28 Under review
2022.04.19 Under review
2022.04.21 Under review

I don't quite understand what it means to only change the date and not the status.

终究是凡人 2022-04-21

3.18 submitted
3.23 under review
4.18 minor revision
4.20 accepted

Translation:
3.18 submitted
3.23 under review
4.18 minor revision
4.20 accepted

president-D 2022-04-18

2022/2/28 submit
2022/3/2 with editor
2022/3/8 with editor (changed editor)
2022/3/10 under review
2022/3/26 major revision (minor revision, rejection, major revision)
2022/4/8 with editor
2022/4/9 under review
2022/4/17 accept

大弟仔 2022-04-16

2022/4/13 under review.

大弟仔 2022-04-10

2022/4/10 with editor translates to "April 10, 2022 with editor."

大弟仔 2022-04-08

2022/4/6 submitted to journal;
2022/4/7 with editor;

Translated:

Submitted to journal on April 6, 2022;
With editor on April 7, 2022.