奋斗的小鸟 2021-09-02

The editing was done in a timely manner and the suggestions from the reviewers were also very professional.

Xuxl-2019 2021-08-31

Please log in to the JECE submission system again to make edits and submit.

小能豆 2021-08-30

Last month, I submitted an article to the Chemical Engineering Journal. The editor suggested that I transfer it to the Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering. I directly clicked on the transfer option in the system. Now, how can I check the status of my article? Has anyone had a similar issue?

小能豆 2021-08-30

I submitted my paper to CEJ and then transferred the editing suggestions to the Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering. I directly clicked on the transfer option in the system. Could you please tell me how to check the status of the transferred article?

Milke 加糖 2021-08-24

7.15 Submission
8.20 Review completed, waiting for editorial decision
Currently, the review process takes one month. Looking forward to receiving good news.

gaoleiniko 2021-08-23

August 19th, under review, it's okay, it's okay.
I think it's slow because someone from the laboratory submitted it before. It was submitted on May 28th, and the required review was completed on June 5th.

judy121212 2021-08-23

Excuse me, has it been sent for review now? I have submitted it for 5 days and it is still "with editor".

Daive Hu 2021-08-19

Suddenly very slow
Submitted on August 14th
Still with editor...

gaoleiniko 2021-08-18

I am speechless, the high speed of other friends has not fallen upon me.
Submitted on August 15th
With editor on August 15th
Received email on August 16th, changed to a different editor
Still with editor until today
Compared to STOTEN, which completed submitted, with editor, and under review within 5 hours.

ssdasa 2021-08-10

Did the editor review your article directly?

貂妹儿 2021-08-09

My deadline was extended for one month.

MingzZ 2021-08-06

The major renovation took almost 3 months, and there was plenty of time available.

蜗牛也是牛 2021-08-05

I want to know how long the OP has been renovating.

蜗牛也是牛 2021-08-05

I want to ask, how long did the major repair take?

MingzZ 2021-07-31

Brother, the impact factor for 2021 is 5.909, of course it is included in SCI.

pre致信 2021-07-18

I would like to ask, my friend, is this journal SCI, with an impact factor of 5.9, now in the year 2021?

貂妹儿 2021-07-14

5.27 Submission
5.28 Under Review
6.17 Major Revision
7.2 Revision
7.3 Under Review
7.13 Under Review - Date changed once but status remained the same

Actually, this article is quite important to me. It is not only a recognition of my long-term efforts but also a hope for assistance during the awards evaluation. However, until now, I have not received any response, and it happens to be too late for the awards. To be honest, I feel a bit regretful and unwilling because of this, and I have been feeling anxious during this period. I have seen some people quickly accept revisions, but mine has not. The second review is also within a normal timeframe. Perhaps, I just don't have that luck, and the article still needs improvement. Let's leave it to fate, it will get better and better.

I will write these here for now, to give everyone some reference, and I will complete it once I am fortunate enough to officially accept it.

不爱科研的阿怪 2021-07-14

I have not received a response to my submission yet, so I want to ask if anyone has encountered a situation where the order of authors filled in during submission does not match the order in the article? How was it resolved in the end?

MingzZ 2021-07-06

Thank you very much, Prof. Wen Zhang from New Jersey Institute of Technology! Wishing everyone many articles!

MingzZ 2021-07-06

20210416 Submission
20210522 First-round major revision
20210610 Revised
20210703 Second-round minor revision
20210704 Revised
20210706 Accepted

今天恰奶茶嘛 2021-07-03

The entire submission to acceptance process took one month! The review speed was really fast! Originally, I was planning to go for 8 reviewers and 60 review comments, but unexpectedly, it was accepted so quickly, haha.
20210601 submitted
20210605 required reviews completed
20210608 Major revisions
20210618 submitted revisions
20210619 RRC (Reviewer Recommended Changes)
20210623 Major revisions
20210625 resubmitted, with editor on the same day
20210628 with editor
20210630 Accepted
This paper was completed in May, with experiments and the entire manuscript written, and then submitted in June, and it got accepted. It's really exciting!

一棵小草 2021-07-03

Which editor is so fast?

吃胡萝卜的北极熊 2021-07-03

My submission cycle is relatively long.
2021/1/24 Submission
2021/4/15 Major revision (the date may change, but the status remains the same; there have been cases where it switched from "Required Reviews Completed" back to "Under Review") 4 reviewers raised 30 questions, and I replied with over 8000 words.
2021/5/14 Revision requested
2021/6/15 Minor revision
2021/6/29 Revision requested
2021/7/1 Accepted

五行者 2021-07-01

JECE2020JCR impact factor 5.909

易水寒12123 2021-06-30

In the upgraded version, this journal is classified as "Zone 3". Is it recognized domestically as "Zone 2" or "Zone 3"?

CarlChen 2021-06-27

A very fast journal, Chinese Academy of Sciences (second tier), JCR (Journal Citation Reports) first tier.

Submitted on April 10, 2021.

With editor on April 12, 2021.

Under review on April 14, 2021.

Major revision on April 28, 2021.

Reviewer's comments included major and minor revisions, but the editor's efficiency was extremely high, and the comments were returned in just over ten days.

Revised on May 17, 2021.

With editor on the same day.

Under review again on May 23, 2021.

Accepted on June 6, 2021.

I thought that after the revision, it would go through another round of minor revisions before being sent for review again, but it was directly accepted.

The efficiency of text editing was also extremely high. It was proofed on June 8, 2021, and online on June 9, 2021. The submission to online publication took less than two months.

The process of paper submission was complicated, going through six or seven journals from CEJ (Chemical Engineering Journal) to JHM (Journal of Hazardous Materials) to JCLP (Journal of Cleaner Production) to FUEL. Finally, it was accepted. Good luck to everyone.

little rain 2021-06-25

13 Apr 2021 submit to journal - Submitted to the journal quickly, the editor's efficiency is really high.
29 May 2021 revised - Revised with 3 reviewers and around 40 questions, answered around 5000 words.
13 Jun 2021 accept - Accepted.
Overall, the journal's processing speed is really fast and the questions raised by the reviewers are very valuable. I hope JECE will continue to improve.

学渣进狼群 2021-06-22

Received 2.21; Major revision 3.23; Received in revised form 5.5; Accepted 6.1; Twists and turns... Returned for revision for a month, reviewer number reached 5, received 3 comments, 2 small and 1 big, all comments were very positive. Revised within 25 days (required reviews completed date changed 5 times, probably because the editor was waiting, felt pessimistic at one point), fortunately accepted, second review had 9 reviewers! 7 responses, 5 directly accepted, 2 requested minor revisions (very serious, felt like native language reviewers), everything was normal until acceptance, then came the twists... Received proof in 3 days, took a look, original manuscript? Not the revised one. Immediately emailed the Data Administrator to request a change, the Data Administrator forwarded my email to the journal manager, who quickly replied saying so sorry, will resolve it soon. Judging by the email time, the Data Administrator is in Europe, the journal manager is in India (thinking about the Indian pandemic, scared of this manager... you know...), and I am in the U.S. A damn email crossing so many time zones, well... Sent 2 reminders in between, they said it would be resolved in 3-5 business days, but it wasn't. Finally, after the third reminder, a new proof was sent.

kevin 2021-06-18

Already submitted, accepted after major revisions, will be published in 3 months. The editor is very responsible, grateful for the opportunity to make major revisions given by the editor, and thankful for the constructive feedback provided by the reviewer.

磊予 2021-06-16

May I ask if the editing email does not have a proofreading link, can the proofreading be found in the system?