孤独的山野 2021-10-07

It has been a month since the first trial, and there is still no news. Why is it so slow now?

kappa 2021-10-06

The second trial is approaching in nearly a month, urgent, urgent, urgent!!!

kappa 2021-10-06

The second review has been close to a month now, and it is still under review. May I ask what the situation is? I'm feeling really anxious about it. Are there any fellow countrymen who have experienced a similar situation?

五行者 2021-10-06

Web of Science shows that the articles from October have not been indexed, while the ones from December have been indexed. This is very strange, and I would like to know the reason behind it. Does anyone know?

DPAO 2021-10-05

The first trial is fast, while the second trial is slow!

李凌1997 2021-10-03

Can you see the editor? Isn't the option to edit not available? ?

蜗牛也是牛 2021-10-02

The review process was fast. I received opinions from six reviewers within a month, totaling 76 comments. There was major revision suggested, and I was given three months to complete it. I submitted the revised version after 40 days, and five reviewers accepted it. However, there was a minor revision requested, which involved conducting additional experiments. I made excuses for not conducting them, but the reviewers insisted on it. I then completed the experiments and resubmitted the revised version within one month. It took 14 days for the reviewers to respond, and the editor took an additional 9 days. It seems that the paper was not directly accepted by the editor without review. The entire process took four months. I want to express my gratitude to editor Zhangwen.

水环境菜鸡 2021-10-02

Submitted on the 27th, I got a new editor, Vítor Jorge Vilar, on the 28th. Three days later, it's under review. The review process is quite fast.

oolili 2021-09-30

One week after submission, it is still "with editor"
Too slow! Negative review!

gaoleiniko 2021-09-29

Yang Liu, PhD.

水环境菜鸡 2021-09-27

The one who was rejected by the previous company and transferred here, after checking, the manuscript number has already reached 8601. Only a little over 1000 are accepted this year, so the acceptance rate is no more than 15%. Suddenly, it feels like it's going to be difficult... Will update if there is any further news.

Panzr 2021-09-27

Submitted the first draft on July 21st, received feedback for revisions on September 6th, was given a month to make major revisions, submitted the revised draft on September 16th, and it was with the editor on the same day. On September 20th, it was still with the editor, and it remains so until today. I am not sure if there was a change in editors or what happened, and there has been no further review or update. I am hesitant to inquire about it and wanted to ask if anyone else has had a similar experience.

paper多多不要秃头 2021-09-26

May I ask which editor you have been assigned to?

paper多多不要秃头 2021-09-26

The first review was quick, about a month. They gave me three months for major revisions, and I returned after two months. After more than two weeks, the status changed to "require review completed" and it has been like this for two weeks. I'm wondering why. I'm waiting to graduate and I don't dare to rush them. It's uncomfortable.

gaoleiniko 2021-09-25

Today is September 25th, I'm truly speechless. It's still under review, so I'm getting ready to write a reminder letter.

貂妹儿 2021-09-22

During the period from July 20th to August 31st, it usually takes about 8 to 10 days for the review process. The "under review" status changes once in a while, and my second review took longer. On September 6th, the status changed to "required review completed," but after a few hours, it changed back to "under review," which really worried me. I was really concerned, so I sent an email to the editor. The editor quickly replied, asking me to wait a little longer as the manuscript would soon enter the next stage. I had no choice but to continue waiting. Finally, on September 16th, I received the news that my article was accepted. Although there were regrets, I was mostly happy and could continue with my work peacefully. Many thanks to editor Despo Fatta-Kassinos! I hope friends who are anxiously waiting for the results of their articles can be patient, as good things take time! I wish everyone success in publishing more papers!

我比风冷iii 2021-09-17

Master's first SCI, after being rejected by CEJ, transferred to JECE, from submission to acceptance a total of 57 days.

新新月 2021-09-14

Posted on September 14th, continuous updates to follow.

bronise 2021-09-14

Just got hired today, the review speed is quite fast.

不爱科研的阿怪 2021-09-13

My date has also been updated, but it is still under review. Ah, it has been two months already and I don't know how others are so fast.

gaoleiniko 2021-09-10

The system previously showed "under review" on August 19th, but now it has changed to "under review" on September 7th. The status hasn't changed, only the date has changed, which means that there is a feedback that has been received. Anyway, I just can't understand why others are so quick...

不爱科研的阿怪 2021-09-10

I have been submitting for over forty days and there is still no change, it is still under review.

不爱科研的阿怪 2021-09-10

How do you know someone has returned? Is there a website where I can check?

gaoleiniko 2021-09-08

On September 7th, under review, there was a change in the date and I received a reviewer's comment. I don't know why my submission process is quite lengthy.

gaoleiniko 2021-09-08

On September 7th, under review, there was a date change, indicating that there must be a reviewer's comment back. I don't know why my submission process is quite lengthy.

parkyuunsi 2021-09-07

2021.7.1 submitted to journal
2021.7.13 with editor
2021.7.19 under review
2021.8.3 major revision, two minor revisions
2021.8.23 resubmitted
2021.9.7 accepted
Overall, the process was quite fast, but the submission to the journal was a bit slow. Wishing everyone smooth research and more publications!

Aqueous 2021-09-07

Photocatalysis direction, submitted to CEJ, suggested transferring to JECE. I agreed to transfer because I didn't feel like looking for another journal. The submission timeline is approximately as follows:
July 9, 2021: Submitted to editor of JECE
July 10, 2021: Under review
July 24, 2021: Major revision
August 14, 2021: Resubmitted and under review on the same day
September 6, 2021: Accepted
Overall, the initial review process was fast, but it slowed down in the later stages.
Thanks to Prof. Xiwang Zhang from Monash University!
Wishing everyone smooth scientific research and many papers!

不爱科研的阿怪 2021-09-06

I submitted my application in July and still haven't received any results.

Daybreak 2021-09-06

Everyone's submission experiences seem to be quite fast. Why is mine so slow? I submitted on August 24th, and it's still "with editor" on September 5th. Speechless.

MingzZ 2021-09-02

20210731 Submission
20210817 Major revision
20210827 Revised
20210901 Accepted
The editing and review experts have been very prompt in their handling, and I am extremely grateful! Thank you very much to Professor Xiwang Zhang from Monash University! Wishing everyone success in publishing papers!