忘忧草谭 2021-11-19

The journal is very fast, the editors are very friendly. After a long time, I finally have a thesis that can be graduated. Submitted on August 23rd, received the review comments on September 20th. One month for revisions. Returned for revisions on October 20th, and accepted on November 12th. Very grateful, and I wish the journal continued success.

Daive Hu 2021-11-18

This journal is super friendly, and the handling speed of the manuscripts is also very fast. The main delay was due to my own revisions taking a long time. I hope the journal will continue to improve!!!!

水月2021 2021-11-18

The magazine with fast speed, submitted in June and accepted in November, had its first major revision in the middle. The modifications were minor, but after the revision, there was a sudden surge in suggestions for further revisions. It felt like the magazine was playing games. However, we still made the necessary improvements and after the second revision, the editor accepted it in just 3 days. I didn't expect such efficiency in handling the process. In the future, if I submit a manuscript for review, it will be directly accepted. Overall, this submission was quite good. The significant increase in suggestions for the second revision may be due to the fact that the feedback from the first review did not come in time. The long submission time was mainly because I was slow in making the revisions, which dragged it to the maximum duration of 5 months. The shortest time for the entire process, from submission to acceptance, is estimated to be around 2 to 3 months. I recommend this magazine as it has great potential.

Laphael 2021-11-16

9.19 submitted to journal
9.25 under review
10.14 major revision given 25 days to modify
11.8 revised
11.14 accepted

不爱学习的曾同学 2021-11-16

I also don't know who edited it. At first, a foreigner was chosen. The reminder for submission said that they couldn't find a suitable reviewer.

judy121212 2021-11-16

8.18 submitted to the journal
8.19 with editor
9.1 under review
9.27 major revision
10.16 under review
11.15 accept

oolili 2021-11-08

Let you guys experience what speed is! Awesome, thanks to the reviewer for their efficiency!
2021.9.24 Submitted to journal
9.25 with editor
10.1 Under review
10.3 Required reviews completed
10.14 Major revision
10.23 Under review
10.25 Required reviews completed
11.05 Accept

薛定阳的烤鱼 2021-11-06

Overall, it was quite fast. It took two and a half months from submission to acceptance. I submitted the manuscript on August 24th and it was accepted on November 5th. There was a major revision in between, and four reviewers raised 40 questions that scared me. After completing the revisions, I thought I would have to revise again, but unexpectedly it was directly accepted for publication. I am very grateful to Associate Editor Wen Zhang, Ph.D. I wish your journal continued success!

聪明绝顶 2021-11-05

The editor is still very powerful, materials related to environmental conservation are being done, and articles related to practical environmental management applications should be relatively easy to be accepted.

Transferring on August 12th.
Major revisions based on the initial review comments for about a month.
Minor revisions based on the comments received after about a month.
Revised and directly accepted on November 5th after four days.

The journal should value articles related to environmental applications. In my article, I added an application of materials in desert management.

liuxm0 2021-11-05

What is the reason for not delivering the display to the editor's hands?

liuxm0 2021-11-05

I have been submitting for almost two days and it is still submitted to the journal. Has anyone encountered this situation before?

judy121212 2021-11-05

The second trial has been 20 days, and the date has not changed. Urgent, I don't know how long everyone has used for the second trial.

sunxiaodui 2021-11-04

Hello! May I ask how you determine which editor to assign to? Can you teach me? Sorry for the trouble.

gaoleiniko 2021-11-03

May I ask who your editor is? I haven't received any updates since the end of August.

不爱学习的曾同学 2021-11-03

September 5th submission
September 17th Under Review
September 18th Under Review
Stayed with the editor for two weeks for review, sent a reminder on November 2nd, but still no response until now.

oolili 2021-10-30

Second review required reviews completed for a week. Still no results?

二源 2021-10-30

Submitted on June 20th, received initial review comments in early August, returned at the end of August, and accepted in early September. The review process was reasonably prompt. The editor is Xiwang Zhang, Ph.D., who is very kind.

从此不远游 2021-10-27

7.8 submit
7.14 under review
7.17 required reviews completed
7.23 required reviews completed
7.27 required reviews completed
7.30 major revise
9.8 return
9.8 with editor
9.27 with editor
10.2 under review
10.6 required reviews completed
10.24 accept

The first review was quick, the manuscript was revised by seven reviewers for a month. The second review was sent back for revisions and it took another month with the editor. I was anxious, but still patiently waited. Unexpectedly, it was accepted directly, which was a great surprise. Thank you to the editor and reviewers. Best wishes to everyone!

gaoleiniko 2021-10-26

Since August 14th, there has been no response after the first review. I sent two reminder letters, but the replies were insignificant. I will wait for one more month and then prepare to withdraw the submission.

oolili 2021-10-26

Translated text:

Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering Submission
2021.9.24 Submitted to journal
9.25 With editor
9.30 With editor
10.1 Under review
10.3 Required reviews completed
10.14 Major revision
10.22 With editor
10.23 Under review
10.25 Required reviews completed
I asked customer service and they said that there is still one reviewer's opinion pending, but the previous two reviewers have agreed to accept. I hope for an early acceptance!

CHEN666666 2021-10-23

Why is it that I have been submitting for two days and it is still submitted to the journal?

lzxxxx456 2021-10-20

I still transferred to this journal. I chose to transfer in the first place because I wanted it to be faster. But the result is that it has been 14 days since I transferred with editor. By the way, how does everyone see the editor?

gaoleiniko 2021-10-18

I don't know what to say. I noticed that other friends' applications were reviewed quickly. Anyway, I submitted mine for review on August 19th, and today is October 18th, but it's still under review.

xie多多 2021-10-18

Thank you, host. I feel for you. Let's work hard together in future scientific research!

匿名小菜鸡 2021-10-18

The efficiency of the journal is relatively high. However, the editor assigned to me should only handle manuscripts once a week, so it takes a week each time it reaches the editor. Originally, this article could have been eligible for a national award. I put in my full effort to respond to the first review, addressing 49 comments in three days. But the time it took for the editor and the second review was too long. On September 21, I had to urgently write a letter to urge them. The editor's response was very friendly, saying that they only received comments from one reviewer and needed to wait for two to make a decision. The deadline for submitting award materials was September 30, and on October 1, the second review comments came back, still from one reviewer. It would be false to say that I am not disappointed, but I have also come to accept it. The editor's handling and review time are within a reasonable range. It seems that others have had faster experiences with their submissions, maybe I just didn't have that luck. The quality of the article still needs improvement, and I should not rely on others' efficiency. Finally, I wish everyone can achieve their wishes!

匿名小菜鸡 2021-10-18

7.20 Submission
8.17 Feedback received, awaiting editor's decision
8.22 Major revision
8.25 Minor revision
9.1 Sent for review
10.1 Minor revision
10.14 Submitted
10.14 with editor
10.17 Accepted

K1 2021-10-16

The second review has been going on for over a month, and it's still under review. The longer it takes, the more anxious I get!!!

匿名小菜鸡 2021-10-14

I am also this editor, and I feel that the processing speed of the manuscript is very slow...

oolili 2021-10-14

3 reviewers, the first two reviewed for 2 days and finished reviewing, the third reviewer reviewed for 10 days and finished reviewing. The editor gave a major revision today. Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering, very efficient. Recommended rating: 5 stars.

oolili 2021-10-09

October 1st - Under review
October 3rd - Required reviews completed
Until now, there has been no change in status?
What is this situation? I finished the application so quickly, but there has been no further action for a long time... This efficiency, sigh!!