我你他我 2023-04-11

I'm really fed up. I'm now in my second revision, and when I calculate the time, it has been almost a year since I submitted the article!!!!
This journal is really slow, incredibly slow!!!!

Bright001 2023-04-10

0410 status remains unchanged, reviewers please review it quickly~~~

jishuwen 2023-04-07

2022.12.28 received
One week later under review
2023.3.02 Major revision
Then add line numbers
2023.4.03 Accept! (Thought there would be a minor revision, but it was accepted directly)
2023.4.05 Proof
First Elsevier paper, like the formatting.

dikesen 2023-04-07

The format is quite flexible, but when submitting, you must include line numbers, otherwise it will be quickly returned, wasting time. Also, if the article is too long or has too many pictures, the reviewers will ask for revisions.

OABLO 2023-04-06

23-01-05 submitted to journal - Submitted to the journal on January 5th, 2023.
23-01-15 with editor - Under review by the editor on January 15th, 2023.
23-01-20 under review - Under review by reviewers on January 20th, 2023.
23-02-13 major revision - Requested major revisions on February 13th, 2023.
23-03-10 under review - Under review by reviewers again on March 10th, 2023.
23-03-21 minor review - Requested minor revisions on March 21st, 2023.
23-04-02 accept - Accepted on April 2nd, 2023.
First self-written review article for SCI, very excited. Wishing everyone can achieve the same.

Now2023 2023-04-06

How is your manuscript coming along? What is its current status?

菜狗 2023-04-05

The status is Decision in Process, and it hasn't changed for over twenty days now.

Hokir 2023-04-05

2023-04-04 major revision
Two reviewers, a total of 9 comments, were given 21 days, but the comments are quite harsh... I feel like I need to make significant improvements.

wangquezhidu 2023-04-04

This journal is particularly slow, so if you're in a hurry, don't submit! Many people have commented that the time with the editor is quite long, and I have seen cases where it takes over two months to enter the under review stage. There are also some people who receive acceptance relatively quickly, around two months, but not many.

Now2023 2023-04-04

What is the status of your article now?

青蔷薇23 2023-04-03

May I ask if this journal has any formatting requirements? For example, is there a limit on the number of figures allowed in the main text?

Bright001 2023-04-03

Some people are getting impatient with "Under Review" status and hope that the reviewer can speed up the review process. They are looking forward to a good outcome.

xhw2 2023-03-31

What does "dip" mean? I submitted an article, and it was returned for major revisions after the first review for over 20 days. It was returned for major revisions again after the second review for 14 days. After the third review for 10 days, it was returned for minor revisions. Now it is the fourth review.

菜狗 2023-03-29

DIP has been 20 days already, do any brothers know why? Is it going to be over?

Chen xingguang 2023-03-29

11/21 submit to journal - Submitted to the journal on November 21st.
11/23 with editor - Under review by the editor on November 23rd.
12/16 under review - Currently being reviewed.
12/28 Required Reviews Completed - The required reviews have been completed.
1/9 under review - Currently being reviewed.
1/17 Required Reviews Completed - The required reviews have been completed.
1/28 major revision - Major revisions are needed.
2/19 revision submit - Revised version submitted.
2/22 with editor - Under review by the editor on February 22nd.
3/6 under review - Currently being reviewed.

enhaikuoyi 2023-03-28

Mar 26 2023 with editor
4.6 with editor, no changes.

破罐子 不能破摔 2023-03-27

Feb 8 - Submit the Journal
Feb 10 - Resubmit due to formatting issues
Feb 13 - With Editor
Feb 17 - Under Review
Feb 24 - Under Review
Feb 24 - Required Reviews Completed
Feb 27 - Major Revision
Mar 12 - R1 Submission
Mar 17 - With Editor
Mar 19 - Under Review
Mar 20 - Required Reviews Completed
Mar 27 - Accept
Overall, it was quite fast, especially the initial review process which took only ten days. At one point, I thought it might be rejected, but luckily it was accepted smoothly!

Adam123 2023-03-27

2022.08.16 Submission
2022.08.20 with editor
2022.09.22 Under Review
2023.01.05 Major revision;
2023.03.17 Accepted
It's really slow! Luckily, the result is good!

wxyxw 2023-03-20

It has been three months. The reviewing time is updated approximately every 7 days, probably reviewed by editors. However, only one person has finished reviewing so far...

Hokir 2023-03-19

20230318 under review translates to "under review" on March 18, 2023.

dikesen 2023-03-15

Did you accept it directly after the major repairs?

超超 2023-03-15

The first SCI article.

超超 2023-03-15

22.8.30 Submission
22.12.18 Major revision
23.3.5 Acceptance
with editor for three months, review process for 15 days, second review process for 50 days

无怨 2023-03-13

No reminder for submission, already rejected.

Bright001 2023-03-13

The first review of this journal takes over two months.

梁建海 2023-03-13

Is there a reminder to submit the manuscript in the middle?

无怨 2023-03-12

3.11 Required Reviews Completed

我你他我 2023-03-09

2022-9-21 Submission
2023-2-1 Major revision
2023-2-18 First revised submission
2023-3-8 Minor revision
2023-3-8 Second revised submission
Hope for a good outcome

又被拒了 2023-03-08

How long does it take for this journal article to be published after it has been accepted?

Hokir 2023-03-08

I didn't expect that the process from being submitted to the journal to being with the editor would require me to send an email to push the progress.

Status change: 2023-03-08 with editor