Sakuya 2022-05-27

4.16 major revision. Three reviewers, the first two reviewers do not seem to be within the field. The first reviewer focused heavily on the formulas and kept asking questions. The second reviewer was more friendly and suggested minor revisions. The third reviewer should be an expert in the field, as their questions were all very professional, but they were somewhat sarcastic and not very friendly. There were a total of over thirty comments, and the response letter ended up being over twenty pages long, longer than the paper itself. I don't feel very hopeful about it.

Nostalld 2022-04-15

I also applied in December 2021, and now (April 15, 2022), it is still under review.

张恒巍 2022-04-07

Field of Network Security

2021.04 Submission;
2021.07 Major revision;
2021.11 Minor revision;
2022.03 Final acceptance.

All three reviewers are colleagues and experts in this field. Their review comments are detailed, accurate, sharp, and profound. The initial revision had a total of 16 comments, and it took nearly 50 days of deep thinking and meditation to respond to the revisions. Detailed supplementary experiments and data analysis were added to pass the review. The final response letter was 12 pages long, with an additional 4 pages of supplementary experiments and analysis, making it longer than the initial draft.

PS: It feels like the review cycle of TNSM has become longer recently. Previously, it took only 4 months from submission to acceptance for a paper to be published. It could also be an individual experience.

CSK 2022-04-05

It has been 4 months since I submitted, and today a reviewer I recommended informed me that they just received the invitation for review.

Sakuya 2022-04-01

No, I asked the editor last week and they said they still need one more reviewer. The editor said we might have to wait for another 2 weeks at most... Anyway, if this reviewer does a bad job, then we'll probably need to replace them, which means we'll have to keep waiting.

JamesBD 2022-04-01

Have you received the first instance opinion?

Sakuya 2022-02-22

2.21 Inquiring about the progress, AE replied that three out of five review comments were missing. The deadline for submission is mid-March, and the estimated review time is around three months.

Sakuya 2022-02-06

Has it been under review all this time... Oh my god, I want to withdraw the submission.

CSK 2022-01-28

May I ask if you have sent an email inquiry?

00 2022-01-28

Submitted on June 1, 2021.
No news so far.

up. 2022-01-25

Excuse me, it has been 3 months, is there any result?

Sakuya 2022-01-04

12.20 submit - Please submit by December 20th.
12.22 assign ae - AE will be assigned on December 22nd.

Nostalld 2022-01-04

Record it.
Submission date: 23-Dec-2021.

CSK 2021-12-27

I will also make a note of it.
Submitted: 2021.12.27

天唐锦绣 2021-11-01

Record your own submission time, afraid of forgetting in the future.
Submit: 2021.10.28