认证评论 - IEEE Internet of Things Journal
注: 认证评论选取于全球各个学术评论平台和社交媒体。

好好学习天天向上~~~ 2023-05-24

The first review takes about 6 months, which is quite long, and it is not easy to find reviewers.
The second review takes about 3 months, and it is accepted for final submission.
The revision time for each review is about two weeks.
The overall process takes about a year.

The original manuscript is solid, and the revised version is also carefully done, so it is not surprising that it was accepted after major revisions.
It is a very good journal, but it seems that the review process is becoming stricter and the cycle is getting longer. At least two of the three reviewers are colleagues in the same field, and they review the paper very carefully. Their comments and suggestions greatly improve the paper. Thank you for the reviewers' efforts, and I hope IOTJ will continue to improve.

何时能毕业 2023-05-24

Before, it was revised and resubmitted. It has been a month since it was submitted in April, but the status has not been updated. It has consistently shown "Under Review" in capital letters. What is the situation?

小夏_0321 2023-05-24

What is your final result? May I ask? I have been submitting for a month, it changed from U R to U r for almost a month, and now it has become Under Review. I'm not sure what the result is.

冬瓜瓜不瓜 2023-05-19

I have been awaiting a decision for twenty days already, feeling so anxious.
Will there be a change of reviewer after revising and resubmitting?

被拒稿的心路历程 2023-05-18

2023.02.14. Submit, IoT-282XX-2023, Under Review;
2023.02.25. Under review (minor);
2023.02.25. Under Review;
2023.4.11 Under Review->Under review (minor)
2023.4.17 Under review (minor)->Under Review
2023.4.18 Under Review->Awaiting Decision
2023.4.18 Awaiting Decision->Reject (do not resubmit)

u3tfzzz 2023-05-17

What other procedures are required after transferring copyright?

-橘柚香 2023-05-17

I have been waiting for over a month since the end of March.

-橘柚香 2023-05-17

9.31 First submission
12.9 Rejected (revise and resubmit)
1.17 Resubmission
2.2 Awaiting decision
2.4 Minor revision
2.7 Resubmission
2.25 Awaiting decision
3.26 Accepted

yasin 2023-05-15

Did the EIC change recently, causing all of us to be stuck in AD for a long time? Have any friends recently received the results?

zhb 2023-05-14

Did you remind me to submit the draft for external review after AD?

夏目33 2023-05-10

How long does the ad approximately take?

u3tfzzz 2023-05-10

Did you hire? How long does it usually take for AD? ?

u3tfzzz 2023-05-10

May I ask how long does the process of awaiting decision generally take?

asyy 2023-05-07

Really? In my impression, it was just a big R as soon as it was submitted.

pose 2023-05-07

I have asked, and the correct translation for "Under Review" is "外审" in uppercase letters.

pose 2023-05-07

Para el Journal de IoT, el estado del manuscrito sigue siendo 'Bajo revisión' desde 'Editor en Jefe Asignar Editor Temático' hasta 'Esperando la Recomendación del Editor Asociado'.

小夏_0321 2023-05-04

Hello, I would like to ask you a question. The initial status of my submission was "Under Review," and now it has changed to "Under review." Could you please inform me about the sequential process of this submission status?

u3tfzzz 2023-05-04

After my first submission, there was a major revision, then a minor revision. It was submitted on 3.31, and after more than 10 days, it changed to "awaiting decision" and has not changed since then. When will the result be announced? Will it be rejected? ?

pose 2023-04-26

After I submitted my manuscript, it immediately appeared as "under review" in lowercase. Later, it changed to "Under Review" in uppercase. Does the capitalization difference indicate that it is being externally reviewed?

WYFDK 2023-04-24

Probably not, I have previously submitted a translation, and it took five months for three rounds of review.

undefined 2023-04-24

May I ask if it has been almost two months since the third review, and if it still shows "under review," does it mean it will be rejected?

Dream.Kang 2023-04-23

4.23 becomes small r.

cmdxmm 2023-04-21

My paper still underwent peer review, but the process was quick.

WYFDK 2023-04-18

2023-04-12, finally became little r. Looking forward to kind reviewers.

asyy 2023-04-18

When did the OP投?

二郎神贝贝 2023-04-18

April 18, 2023, Big R changes to AD.

Dream.Kang 2023-04-17

12-Apr-2023 After modifying the format issue, please resubmit it directly as "小r". Looking forward to good news, will update again if there is any further information.

yg99992 2023-04-13

15-Jul-2022 SUBMITTED - Submitted on July 15, 2022
21-Sep-2022 Reject (revise and resubmit) - Rejected on September 21, 2022 (needs to be revised and resubmitted)
01-Dec-2022 Resubmitted - Resubmitted on December 1, 2022
24-Mar-2023 Minor Revision - Minor revisions made on March 24, 2023
27-Mar-2023 Submitted - Submitted on March 27, 2023
11-Apr-2023 Accept - Accepted on April 11, 2023

我真的会谢55 2023-04-12

大r又变小r translates to "Big r becomes small r" in English.

anancc 2023-04-12

29-Oct-2022, submit;
03-Feb-2023, major repair;
21-Feb-2023, submit modifications;
24-Mar-2023, minor repair;
25-Mar-2023, submit modifications;
11-Apr-2023, receive

Publish scientific posters with Peeref

Peeref publishes scientific posters from all research disciplines. Our Diamond Open Access policy means free access to content and no publication fees for authors.

Learn More

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started