silkyrose 2023-06-09

After a major revision, Big U Big R has returned to the hands of the editors from the reviewers.
I'm really nervous and really hope to be selected.

Tabe 2023-06-08

May I ask how many months you reviewed at that time?

Tabe 2023-06-08

It's really slow. I thought it would be faster based on the comments before.

迷之书童 2023-06-06

I can't figure out what specific situations the transformation of "大r" and "小r" refers to.

myz_tj 2023-06-06

Excuse me, is there a change from big R to small R in between?

迷之书童 2023-06-06

No, I will remind you next month.

Tabe 2023-06-05

During this period, were there any reminders to submit the manuscript? I have submitted it for three months now but haven't received any news.

Alxf000 2023-06-03

Some are really slow, but the reviewing comments are very objective.

夏目33 2023-06-03

Rejected after a 7-month first review, with a total of two reviewers. One of the reviewers provided revisions, but they only consisted of two minor and unrelated suggestions. The other reviewer stated that the manuscript was not aligned with the journal's theme.

Tabe 2023-06-02

2023-03-05 submit
2023-03-05 under Review (大R)
2023-03-12 under review (小R)
2023-06-02 under Review (大R)

Translation:
2023-03-05 submit
2023-03-05 under Review (大R)
2023-03-12 under review (小R)
2023-06-02 under Review (大R)

迷之书童 2023-06-01

I have been waiting for the first-instance result for 5 and a half months.

迷之书童 2023-06-01

Not as fast as imagined, I submitted two papers, one on December 23rd, 2022, and the other on March 26th, 2023. Both are still under review. Being a graduate is really tough.

何时能毕业 2023-05-30

This is really outrageous. Have you sent an email to inquire about it? I haven't heard anything for almost a month and a half, and I can't stand it anymore. It's really frustrating.

zht411 2023-05-30

2021-12-09 Submit
2022-04-23 Reject

The first review took a full 5 months, so invest carefully.

clin123 2023-05-30

I resubmitted on November 20th, and now it has been six months, but it is still under review, with a capital "R". I give up.

Moonriver 2023-05-26

Okay, okay! So, I should be doing an external audit for this. I wanted to ask, typically after the external audit, if it becomes a "大R" (which stands for recommendation), does that mean I have to do the AD (Assistant Director) role?

好好学习天天向上~~~ 2023-05-26

Regarding "Under Review":

大U小r means it has been submitted for review.
大U大R means it is in the hands of the editor.

好好学习天天向上~~~ 2023-05-26

Hello, when just submitted, it is generally written as uppercase "U" and uppercase "R", indicating that it is in the hands of the editor.

After a few days, it will usually change to uppercase "U" and lowercase "r", indicating that it has been sent for review and is in the hands of the reviewer.

Moonriver 2023-05-26

Hello, I would like to ask how your review changes in capitalization during the submission process? After I submit, it immediately changes to an uppercase "R," and then 5 days later, it changes to a lowercase "r." Does this represent something? I don't really understand the meaning of this capitalization change, sob sob sob.

Moonriver 2023-05-26

Hello, lowercase r indicates that it has already been sent for external review, right?

Moonriver 2023-05-26

Hello, lowercase "r" represents an external review. What do uppercase and lowercase "r" represent, and what do they mean? I seek an answer.

Moonriver 2023-05-26

Hello, I would like to ask how the review in the submission process changes from uppercase to lowercase. After I submit, it immediately turns into an uppercase "R", and then after 5 days, it becomes a lowercase "r". Does this represent something? I am not quite clear about the meaning of this change in capitalization for "r". Please enlighten me.

Moonriver 2023-05-26

Hello, I would like to ask how the review changes from uppercase to lowercase in the submission process? After I submit, it immediately changes to an uppercase "R," and then five days later, it becomes a lowercase "r." Does this represent something? I don't quite understand the meaning of these uppercase and lowercase "r."

Moonriver 2023-05-26

Hello, I wanted to ask how the capitalization of the review changes during the submission process? After I submit, it immediately turns into a capital 'R', and then 5 days later it becomes a lowercase 'r'. Does this represent anything?

何时能毕业 2023-05-25

According to logic, the resubmission should still be assigned to the previous reviewer. Why has it been in the editor's hands for over a month?

xxxxxxx3 2023-05-25

Sorry for the mistake, Da R is indeed in the hands of the editor, while Xiao R is the reviewer.

何时能毕业 2023-05-25

Is the big 'R' in the hands of the reviewers? When I submit, it becomes the big 'R', but I see everyone saying that the small 'r' is in the hands of the reviewers?

xxxxxxx3 2023-05-24

Dear R, please confirm that the manuscript is in the hands of the reviewer.

xxxxxxx3 2023-05-24

Who said that the hiring cycle is short? It's too mysterious.

Zzzzippo 2023-05-24

What is the difference between big U and small U?