赶紧发论文 2023-06-16

It's so difficult to endure. One round of major revisions, followed by a rejection (revise and resubmit) in the second round. After resubmitting in April, it has gone back and forth between major revisions (big R) and minor revisions (small r) three or four times. And now it has been a week since the last major revision.

Zzzzippo 2023-06-16

Dude, my big R turned into an ad in just three days. Wish me luck!

LIESMARS 2023-06-15

In recent years, the peer review process for academic journals has become increasingly slow. However, the reviewers I found are becoming more professional. The first review took six months, which was quite challenging. The second review took four months, but luckily the outcome was positive and my paper was accepted for publication. I hope that the journal continues to improve, and I also hope that everyone else can succeed as well!

pose 2023-06-15

The review process generally involves the editor-in-chief assigning an editor in the relevant field to be responsible for reviewing your paper. For your paper, this editor acts as the associate editor. They will find reviewers and then write a recommendation based on the reviewers' opinions and their own opinions, which will be provided to the editor-in-chief. The editor-in-chief will then give the final decision on the paper based on their recommendations.

pose 2023-06-15

The deputy editor's opinion is based on the opinions of external reviewers, as well as their own opinions.

liulang_ 2023-06-14

投 - April 26th submission
返回结果 - June 14th returned results
编辑给的reject，send else where - The editor gave a reject, send elsewhere
但是从审稿人意见和编辑意见看，结果不是很差，但还是被拒了，这意思是不能重投了吗？ - However, based on the comments from the reviewers and editor, the results were not very bad, but still rejected. Does this mean I cannot resubmit?
之前有个同学被拒直接说不能重新提交任何形式的修订版本。我这个还能重新投吗？ - Previously, a classmate who was rejected said they couldn't resubmit any form of revised version. Can I still resubmit mine?

Tabe 2023-06-14

No, I followed up on this later and received a response.

Thanks for your inquiry on the manuscript submitted for review. It is currently under review. You will be informed via email as soon as the review process completes.

Kindly note, for IoT Journal the manuscript status remains 'Under Review' from 'Editor-in-Chief Assign Topical Editor' to 'Awaiting Associate Editor Recommendation'.

Thank you for your understanding and continued patience.
I also don't know the current situation.

Zzzzippo 2023-06-14

Excuse me, did your paper change from "小r" to "大R" before the second review results came out?

Zzzzippo 2023-06-14

After becoming bigger in size, did you get any results?

Zzzzippo 2023-06-14

Hello, my first review was initially changed to a smaller size after submission, and after about three months, it was changed to a larger size. What does this mean? Does it mean that the comments have been returned to the editor?

myz_tj 2023-06-14

It feels like in this response, Big U and Big R are saying that the editor assigned the paper to the associate editor and is now waiting for their recommended suggestions.

myz_tj 2023-06-14

I had a day where the capital letter "R" turned into a lowercase "r" in the middle, and then it turned back into a capital "R" after a day. I don't know what happened.

pose 2023-06-14

I didn't notice before. Didn't I post the reply from the editorial department above? The U and R above are both capitalized, right?

何时能毕业 2023-06-14

Excuse me, during the review phase, was there a transition between uppercase 'R' and lowercase 'r' on the page?

何时能毕业 2023-06-14

May I ask if it's still possible to remind the editor about resubmitting after two months?

pose 2023-06-14

I have received two articles before, and both were accepted after about six months.

Zzzzippo 2023-06-13

6.13 has been invested, currently in Big U and Big R, come and absorb the good luck from all the experts.

www 2023-06-13

Mine also became "Under review" three days later. Does this mean it has already reached the hands of the reviewer? Is it possible to find a reviewer that quickly?

myz_tj 2023-06-13

Has your paper already been accepted?

pose 2023-06-13

The editorial office's response is precisely the big U, big R.

pose 2023-06-13

This is the result of my inquiry:
谢谢您对提交的稿件的询问。目前正在审查中。一旦审查过程完成，您将通过电子邮件收到通知（根据审稿人的回复速度而定，可能需要多达60天）。请注意，对于IoT Journal，稿件状态从“主编分配专题编辑”到“等待副编辑建议”仍然是“审查中”。

Zongzhou Wu 2023-06-12

Urgently requesting the manuscript multiple times, it was rejected after 9 months of the first review with less than 10 comments from two reviewers. I hope the journals I submit to in the future will treat me kindly.

clin123 2023-06-12

2022-7 Submission, 2022-10 Rejection and resubmission.
2022-11-23 Resubmission.
During the review period, major revision.
2023-6-12 Under review, minor revision.
2023-6-20 Accepted directly. It might be because the revisions made during the revise and resubmit process satisfied the reviewers.

silkyrose 2023-06-11

Can I ask now?

silkyrose 2023-06-11

After the repair, it took only 2 days to become small r. It stopped for more than 20 days and went to big U, big R.

asyy 2023-06-11

The text "同批投的。。。。 也还没返回。。。。" translates to "Those who invested together... haven't returned yet..." in English.

Joie 2023-06-11

21-Mar-2023 Submission
After three days, it changed to Under review.
Now it's June 11, 2023, and it's still U r.
It's estimated that I still have to wait for another two months. It's too slow.

Tabe 2023-06-09

How long did you spend on the first review, bro?

myz_tj 2023-06-09

How long does it take for small r to become big r after you have a major overhaul?

被拒稿的心路历程 2023-06-09

I have submitted an article for 8 months, but still have not received any results.