RC_SJTU 2023-06-23

I feel like the meaning of his "Ur" and "UR" has changed. Now it seems like "大U大R" is for external review, while "大U小r" is in the hands of the editor.

是小王同学呀 2023-06-23

Submitted on 6-5
Is it still Big U Big R on 6-23, is this normal?

愿世界越来越美好 2023-06-22

Because the review comments have come back.

CharlotteYYY 2023-06-22

5-30 submit immediately Under Review
6-6 changed to Under review (small r)
6-22 changed to Under Review (capital R)
Why did Under review with a small r change back to a capital R?

RF 研究员 2023-06-22

After replying to me the next day, in the afternoon I took a glance and saw the status was "AD", feeling that the result was about to come out. However, in the evening, it changed to uppercase "UR" again. I don't know the reason, and I felt very anxious, as if it was going to be a long wait once again.

迷之书童 2023-06-22

It's not the ad stage, right? The ad stage should have a dedicated ad status display.

高启强 2023-06-22

This is the awaiting decision stage.

RF 研究员 2023-06-22

The UR has been ongoing for almost 3 and a half months. After sending a reminder, the editor replied, "Thank you for your email. Your manuscript has reached the Make Recommendation stage and you can expect to hear from the editor soon." I would like to ask, what does this stage mean?

赶紧发论文 2023-06-21

He thinks that my discussion on the value of a hyperparameter is not detailed enough, that's all. Does this count as a technical flaw?

尘世中迷途小书童 2023-06-21

The situation is exactly the same.

Joie 2023-06-20

Update the status on June 20th. Has it changed to "U R"? Is it the opinion coming back? Or what's the situation?

高启强 2023-06-20

Excuse me, may I ask if you, the original poster, have changed the reviewer for minor revisions?

XYZZZ 2023-06-20

Yes, the lowercase "r" is the one that is sent out.

XYZZZ 2023-06-20

Did the first reviewer of the second trial really point out any technical deficiencies in your article or paper?

棠 2023-06-20

Guys, the article that was submitted on March 30, 2023, initially had a brief appearance of big U and small r. However, it has been three months since then and it has consistently been big U and big R. What is going on? Has the article not been sent out at all? (crying)

何时能毕业 2023-06-20

I would like to ask if the Manuscripts I Have Co-Authored account can see the change in review case, or is it only visible in the submitting author's account?

高启强 2023-06-20

The editor-in-chief for this year has been changed, and Nei Kato has taken over the position.

T.SEM 2023-06-20

I submitted it on December 5, 2022, and received the feedback (revise and resubmit) on February 3, 2023. After resubmitting on April 28, 2023, it has been going back and forth between major revisions and minor revisions. It has been almost a week since the last major revision. If there is any progress, please remember to reply. I would like to know the current situation. Thank you.

赶紧发论文 2023-06-20

In addition, in the previous two rounds, it changed from "ur" (lowercase) to "ad" directly. This time, in the resubmission, it alternates between "Ur" (uppercase) and "ur" (lowercase). In the previous two rounds, I received responses from the previous editor-in-chief, but it seems that the recent editors who have returned the results have changed, and I don't know if it is related to this.

赶紧发论文 2023-06-20

The first review was very positive. Reviewer 1 fully agrees with the work and had three minor points (grammar, words, charts, etc.). Reviewer 2 requested an additional experiment and some discussion on related work, with a total of four points.

In the second review, there were a total of six points from two reviewers. It seems that Reviewer 1 was replaced, as they asked similar questions to Reviewer 2 in the first round, with a total of four points. Reviewer 2 mentioned that the previous issues have been resolved but there is a need to modify a few word abbreviations and address another problem with a caption. After that, the associate editor mentioned that the reviewers pointed out technical flaws in the paper, and it needs to be revised.

Tabe 2023-06-18

I almost voted, but there is no news at all.

Zzzzippo 2023-06-18

2022-11-23, submit;
2023-2-28, major revisions
2023-3-27, resubmit
2023-6-16, minor revisions and resubmit
2023-6-17, accepted

The reviewers were very professional, and both the editor-in-chief and associate editor were very diligent and responsible. They provided many constructive suggestions that greatly improved the article. I hope the IoT Journal continues to thrive!

高启强 2023-06-17

Can you urge for the draft? Some editors deliberately delay making a decision. Buddy, have you got any results?

Zzzzippo 2023-06-17

I reviewed it for a little over three months.

Tabe 2023-06-17

Dude, how long did it take you to review?

高启强 2023-06-17

My situation is similar to his. It can be seen from the result of the second review that the second reviewer has changed; otherwise, the second reviewer in the second review could have raised that opinion in the first review.

高启强 2023-06-17

After revising and resubmitting, a new manuscript number will be assigned to the resubmission link.

好好学习天天向上~~~ 2023-06-16

Different, there are differences in the display between the major and RR systems. RR makes more changes than major and has no time limit for returns.

asyy 2023-06-16

For iotj, does "major" mean revise and resubmit?

智慧树下我和你 2023-06-16

How do I reply to your second review? Did the second review include a reviewer? Can you please send me the review comments from the second review?