何时能毕业 2023-07-11

After being urged, it finally became "小r" on July 9th. I hope it is still the original reviewer.

Tabe 2023-07-11

7/9 under review (upper)

Joie 2023-07-10

Update July 10th, revise and resubmit, hoping to pass, keep going.

xxxxxxx3 2023-07-10

No restrictions, same as other IEEE journals, additional page charges apply for more than 8 pages... Why has the speed of this journal suddenly become so slow recently?

Jianfeng Zhang 2023-07-10

I want to ask, is there any page limit for the initial draft in this journal? Is there a rejection criteria for the initial draft exceeding a certain number of pages?

bluesandwich 2023-07-10

I can't remember precisely, but it seems that the time for Xiao U and Xiao R was only about ten days.

是小王同学呀 2023-07-09

7.5 becomes small r, 7.9 becomes big R, it feels like everything is changing so quickly...

追光的日子 2023-07-06

I reviewed an article in April, which was submitted in November last year, so this timeframe is probably normal.

柚子皮 2023-07-05

2022.3.21 Big U Big R
2022.4.13 Big U Small R
There has been no change until now, and there was one reminder in between, stating that it is still under review.

caojian 2023-07-05

Excuse me, does the journal charge a page fee? Is it charged for more than 8 pages?

赶紧发论文 2023-07-05

Yes, direct employment was offered.

myz_tj 2023-07-05

May I ask how long did the second review of Little U and Little R last? Was it transferred to the AD stage after Big U and Big R?

bluesandwich 2023-07-05

Posted on 2022.11.24, revised and resubmitted on 2023.2.09 (two reviewers provided major revisions with a lot of comments); resubmitted on 2023.4.3, received major revisions on 2023.5.20 (one acceptance, one major revision); finalized and submitted on 2023.6.12, accepted on 2023.6.18. The same two reviewers were involved throughout the process, and reviewer 2 is suspected of bias, requesting citations from their own work and providing detailed lists. Overall, the process went relatively smoothly, but the inclusion of biased references was quite frustrating.

XYZZZ 2023-07-04

After you resubmit, the review comments are directly accepted without any modifications, right?

赶紧发论文 2023-07-04

It's over. On the 1st, I couldn't resist urging for the manuscript, and today the editor-in-chief personally accepted it.

myz_tj 2023-07-03

Is it submitted after revising and resubmitting, or is it a major revision?

huhumao 2023-07-03

It has been nearly 2 months since the second review. There have been two changes in the reviewer, initially a senior reviewer and then a junior reviewer, and now it is a senior reviewer again. I wrote a letter to the editor, and the editor said it has entered the recommendation stage. Why hasn't it turned into an advertisement yet? It's frustrating.

Tabe 2023-06-28

You can see that I used my account to view it, but my teacher is a communication.

焦急等待中 2023-06-28

May I ask if the transformation of "under review" from capital R to lowercase r can only be seen by the person who submitted it, or can it be seen by all co-authors as well?

Tabe 2023-06-27

6/27 under review (small)

RF 研究员 2023-06-27

The translation of the given text into English is: "It doesn't feel right... The first trial result hasn't been announced yet, and the chances of receiving it all at once are almost zero."

myz_tj 2023-06-27

Did it eventually become uppercase UR?

clin123 2023-06-27

Yes, there are changes.

何时能毕业 2023-06-26

May I ask if there are any changes in the size of "r" during your review process?

clin123 2023-06-26

6-20 has already been directly accepted. I guess the editor also thinks that the reviewer's time is too long and there are no major comments, so they are probably more satisfied with revising and resubmitting.

clin123 2023-06-26

Does recommendation mean that acceptance is imminent?

dunk 2023-06-25

Excuse me, everyone. After the minor repair, my car has been making a loud noise and shaking for one and a half months. Is this normal? According to previous experience, it usually takes about a month to see results.

DJJDKK 2023-06-25

Very good, very good, very good.

CharlotteYYY 2023-06-24

6-24 Big R becomes small r again.

是小王同学呀 2023-06-23

Is that so? At first, I didn't pay attention to whether it was a capital "R" or a lowercase "r." Later, I searched on the forum and found out that a lowercase "r" means to send it for external review. If the capital "R" is now for external review, then that would be great.