silkyrose 2022-06-08

So fast? How many reviewers are there?

alwaysyou 2022-06-07

Could it be that the editor thinks that the reviewer's comments are not sufficient and there are temporarily no other reviewers to review it?

alwaysyou 2022-06-07

So fast???

louyimo 2022-06-07

2022.3.29 Submission under review (R capitalized, manuscript waiting for assignment at ADM: Tyagi, Surbhi)
2022.4.12 Under review (R lowercase, manuscript has been assigned to a reviewer by the editor)
2022.5.10 Under review (R capitalized, reviewer will suggest revisions to the editor)
2022.5.11 Awaiting decision
2022.5.13 Major revision
2022.5.23 A revision has been submitted under review (R capitalized, manuscript waiting for assignment at ADM: Tyagi, Surbhi)
2022.5.24 Under review (R lowercase, revision suggestions have been assigned to the reviewer for review)

louyimo 2022-06-07

2022.3.29 Submission Under Review
2022.4.12 Under review
2022.5.10 Under Review
2022.5.11 Awaiting decision
2022.5.13 Major Revision
2022.5.23 A revision has been submitted Under Review
2022.5.24 Under review

silkyrose 2022-06-04

After two rounds of review, it stopped moving. Has anyone encountered this situation before? Is it because the editor is unwilling to continue reviewing?

Hu Chance 2022-06-04

2022.5.7 submit/Upper case Under review
2022.6.9 Lower case Under review

alwaysyou 2022-06-02

June 2nd, changed to lowercase "under review"

silkyrose 2022-06-02

26-Mar-2022: Under Review
5.3: Under review
5.6: Under Review
5.7: Under review
5.18: Under Review
I have been stuck on "Under Review" for a while now, not sure if there is still a chance.

alwaysyou 2022-05-29

This is the result of a reviewer, right? Mine also changed from lowercase 'r' to uppercase a few days ago. It should change, considering the review cycle of the previous few posts. I feel that the editor's first reply to the review comments should be around three months.

Bryan.xu 2022-05-29

2.11 submitting - Submitted on February 11th.
5.25 major revision - Major revision requested on May 25th.
The reviewers are still relatively professional, but the review process is too long.

owlPattern 2022-05-28

Now the review process for this journal takes a little longer than before, so we shouldn't rush. The original poster should do whatever they need to do.

owlPattern 2022-05-28

I also want to share my experience as the corresponding author of this article. I am the first author. It took 11 months to finally get accepted.

1. Submitted in July 2021.
2. On October 24, 2021, we received revision comments with only 4 weeks given for revisions. The revisions were extensive, with feedback from five expert reviewers, including suggestions from four junior colleagues and one senior colleague, totaling dozens of points.
3. Submitted the revised version on November 15, 2021. The revisions were challenging, and we had to redo one crucial experimental grouping. The point-by-point response reached 65 pages.
4. On January 18, 2022, we received the review results, and all five reviewers were very satisfied with the revisions. However, minor revisions were requested, with only 3 weeks given for revisions.
5. Submitted the revised version on February 7, 2022.
6. Accepted on May 25, 2022. Prior to acceptance, I had to carefully follow up three times, sending reminders every month.

The above information is provided for reference. My student has published several articles in this journal, and my experience tells me that authors must be patient. Journal peer review is highly professional, and revisions should be as thorough as possible. At the same time, when submitting, it is essential to evaluate the innovation of your article seriously. If the innovation is not significant, it is better not to submit to avoid wasting valuable time.

信女求录用 2022-05-26

【Under the Wisdom Tree, You and I】After my last lowercase "under review," I didn't check the status for a day (covering my face). When I looked again, it was "awaiting decision."

信女求录用 2022-05-26

Thank you everyone for your replies~ Very helpful!
Reply [Under the Wisdom Tree, You and Me] Awaiting Decision.

信女求录用 2022-05-25

How long has your "awaiting decision" status lasted?

alwaysyou 2022-05-24

5.24 returns to uppercase "under review" again.

wang_xw 2022-05-22

May I ask what field you are in? I feel like we are quite similar.
How is this journal? Is it friendly towards the field of deep learning?

relaxihg 2022-05-21

I submitted it on March 18th, 2022. Because I didn't know the difference between "Under review" and "Under Review" and didn't pay attention to observe, it is currently "Under review". Let's wait patiently. I feel that the results will be out in no more than three months.

Bryan.xu 2022-05-19

The UR (uppercase and lowercase) has always been changing, not very informative. Submitted on 2.11, awaiting decision on 5.16. It feels like waiting for EIC's decision will also take a month.

liubufan505 2022-05-17

Having four reviewers is a very normal process, don't worry, bro. One of my buddies in the lab had five reviewers' opinions at the time. Personally, I think it is fortunate to have someone willing to review our manuscript, even if it becomes "under review" in lowercase.

lltyzzzr 2022-05-17

It is possible that they are looking for a new reviewer or the previous review process was slow. In any case, if AE is involved, it should be faster.

alwaysyou 2022-05-17

I've seen a mention of this review mechanism in the comments of the 115th floor before.. It seems that there are quite a few reviewers for this.

alwaysyou 2022-05-17

Speaking of this journal, how many reviewers are usually involved...

信女求录用 2022-05-17

Seek advice from you guys, what does it mean that "Under review" has appeared in lowercase for the fourth time since submission? Has the fourth reviewer reviewed it? The timeline of status changes is as follows:

Submitted on March 13, 2022 (in uppercase "Under Review")
Changed to lowercase "Under review" on April 4, 2022
Changed back to uppercase "Under Review" on April 6, 2022
Changed to lowercase "Under review" on April 16, 2022
Changed back to uppercase "Under Review" on April 23, 2022
Changed to lowercase "Under review" on April 25, 2022
Changed back to uppercase "Under Review" on May 15, 2022
Changed to lowercase "Under review" on May 17, 2022

I'm exhausted from this back and forth (crying). Thank you, guys, for your kind advice!

alwaysyou 2022-05-11

Finally, on the 26th day of submission, the capital letter "R" became lowercase "r".

求求你让我中吧 2022-05-10

The difference between the two interpretations above is whether "awaiting decision" refers to waiting for AE or waiting for EIC.

求求你让我中吧 2022-05-10

I would like to ask how long it usually takes for the decision to be made. I have been waiting for a long time and still have not received any results, so I am quite anxious. Thank you all!
Also, based on the comments from the previous Irons, I still don't quite understand the interpretation of capitalization and the "awaiting decision" status.
One interpretation I have is: when the submission is just made, it is capitalized, indicating that it is in the hands of the editorial department. Then it becomes lowercase, indicating that it has entered the external review stage and is in the hands of the reviewers. Afterwards, it becomes capitalized again, indicating that some reviewers have completed their reviews and it is now awaiting the recommendation of the Associate Editor (AE). Then, "awaiting decision" means that the AE has finished recommending and it is now waiting for the final decision from the Editor-in-Chief (EIC).
Another interpretation I have is: when the submission is just made, it is capitalized, indicating that it is in the hands of the editorial department. Then it becomes lowercase, indicating that it has entered the external review stage and is in the hands of the reviewers. Afterwards, it becomes capitalized again, indicating that some reviewers have completed their reviews, but not all of them. Then, "awaiting decision" means that all reviewers have completed their reviews and it is now waiting for the recommendation of the AE. The AE will make the final decision and there is no need to submit it to the EIC again.
I wonder which interpretation the Irons think is more reasonable? Thank you!

silkyrose 2022-05-10

I see that the change between uppercase and lowercase is quite fast, changing once every 3-4 days.

久雨初晴 2022-05-08

Submitted on January 18, 2022, there is still no news about the first trial! I feel like crying.