s110 2021-05-24

Several days have passed and the editor still hasn't processed it.

temper昊 2021-05-20

Hello, I would like to ask if the reminder letter was sent through the system? It has been two months since my first review, and the day before yesterday, I sent a reminder letter through the system but have not received a reply...

gone with the wind 2021-05-18

The review experts are very professional, and the editors are efficient.

temper昊 2021-05-18

It has been over two months since submission, and it is still under review. Everyone seems to be progressing quickly, making me a bit anxious...

baby北 2021-05-17

Just submitted and it shows "submitted to journal", but on the third day it directly changes to "under review" without the "with editor" status.... What's going on with this situation....

一之濑夜 2021-05-17

Congratulations, congratulations. I just submitted mine today too, hoping for good luck.

Jacky Xing 2021-05-15

Tonight the article was finally accepted, and I hope everyone's articles can be accepted smoothly too. Let me share my submission process with you:
2021.2.23 Submitted the first draft, with editor
2.27 Under review
3.18 Minor to moderate revision
3.28 With editor
4.2 Revised English
4.8 With editor
4.9 Under review
5.14 Required reviewers to complete
5.15 Accepted
Managed to graduate smoothly...

Jacky Xing 2021-05-15

The status of 5.14 has been updated to "required reviewers complete."

xiaojianrong531 2021-05-14

Feb 14, 2021 Submitted to Journal
Feb 17, 2021 With Editor
Feb 18, 2021 Under Review
Mar 03, 2021 Required Reviews Completed
Mar 14, 2021 major revision (Deadline Apr 03, 2021)
Apr 15, 2021 Revision submission (Too busy, requested extension), Under Review
Apr 23, 2021 Minor Revision (Deadline May 14, 2021)
Apr 28, 2021 (Submission of modifications) With Editor, Under Review
May 01, 2021 Highlight has some minor issues, made further small edits, accepted on the same day.

志在远方 2021-05-14

4.1 submission, until 4.18 it was with editor, Eugenio Del Re. On 5.14 received rejection. The editor is the aforementioned Eugenio Del Re, who was not efficient in the initial stages, but after Mina finished reviewing, immediately returned with review comments. The reviewer did not carefully read the paper, said there were no experiments, and had no other comments. Does RIP require experimental papers? After dragging the review for over three weeks, they easily wrote a few comments and rejected it for someone else, being irresponsible. It took over a month, and in the end, there was not even a single substantial helpful comment.

Finally, it should be noted that the manuscript was urged by the device, and all the responses were from the editorial department. After three reminders, there were changes on the next day or the same day.

小硕 2021-05-12

Brothers, I was officially accepted this morning at around five o'clock. Good luck to everyone!

志在远方 2021-05-11

It has been over twenty days since "under review." Wasn't the review period supposed to be 14 days? It has been delayed again...

一之濑夜 2021-05-07

Congratulations, Xiaoshuo! I also wish everyone to be accepted successfully!

好运相伴 2021-05-06

Congratulations, Xiaoshuo! May you also have good luck and be successfully hired.

Jacky Xing 2021-05-05

I envy Little Shuo brothers. Mine is still under review.

小硕 2021-05-05

Friend, my second-round review comments have come out. Let me polish it before I publish it. The reviewer approved the previous revisions, but there are language issues that need to be polished. Finally, good luck to you!

喳喳锐 2021-05-02

Ah, me too. I am also this editor, Vadim A. Markel... I don't know if it will work, feeling uncomfortable.

小硕 2021-05-01

I have been a first reviewer for over a month, and now it has been a month for second review plus with editor. If we count it properly, it will be exactly one month on the 2nd, and I am quite nervous.

Jacky Xing 2021-05-01

I'm a little worried. The first trial took three weeks, and now the second trial has been almost a month. Moreover, this article is indeed quite necessary. I hope everyone is lucky.

小硕 2021-04-30

Friend, you just need to confirm in the submission system. After downloading the PDF generated from your submission, please take a look to see if there are any issues. If everything is fine, click on "confirm submission" to proceed.

一之濑夜 2021-04-30

My advisor has not confirmed yet, so it may be next month before I submit. After submitting, I will also update my status for everyone's reference.

小硕 2021-04-29

I probably received the initial review comments a few days after one month.

忆一怡 2021-04-29

How long does the general review process usually take? The status date has changed once, but it is still in the "Under Review" state.

小硕 2021-04-27

This Jackey Xing's big brother, I come here every day to see if you have updated your status or not (forced smile).

Jacky Xing 2021-04-27

Hello, when did you submit your article and has it been accepted yet?

小硕 2021-04-25

Hmm, mutual good luck, quack, ahahaha.

Jacky Xing 2021-04-25

Let's be patient and wait, maybe in a few days, there will be results.

小硕 2021-04-25

We are both editing teachers, and I have been doing the second review for almost a month. I feel exhausted both physically and mentally.

Jacky Xing 2021-04-24

So anxious. There is still no news. It has been under review for two weeks... The editor is Professor Vadim A. Markel.

小硕 2021-04-24

Just look at the reply to the comments on the manuscript and you will know.